My Favorite Wife: The Justin Verlander Thread

Verlander was Cano gets suspended vs. Verlander when former Tigers teammate Jhonny Peralta got suspended. pic.twitter.com/rnKEdhkeIZ

— Mike Axisa (@mikeaxisa) May 15, 2018

Twitter's demise will be a great gift to every living baseball player.

i will say that i was sort of surprised when i saw Verlander’s face recently. i hadn’t paid too much attention to him in a couple of years. he suddenly looks kind of beefy and bloated around the jowls in a way that i associate with mcgwire, clemens etc.

comeback player of the year (AL)

More like PEDs are making a comeback! (Kidding.)

Steeling myself for when these ads are every other commercial on Houston TV in the autumn:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IGiKhz_5YFI

Lost, but pretty solid start yesterday: 7 IP, 2 runs, 2 BB, 4 K. Of course hoping for him vs. Scherzer in a crucial September game.

I didn't realize he won his 250th game the other day (and 251st last night)--did that get any attention? There must have been stories about how he'll be the last guy ever to win 250. He turned 40 in February, so 300 seems almost inconceivable. But I wouldn't rule it out completely if he wants to keep going. Ryan pitched till he was 46, Randy Johnson 45, Clemens 44; whether one or all of them got some help, probably.

Carlton lasted to 43, but his was terrible his last two seasons.

"he"

He seems quite ready to play till nobody wants him, so I guess it'll be health and money, in that order--if he's healthy, I'm sure someone will be willing to pay him.

https://www.sportico.com/leagues/baseball/2023/justin-verlander-mets-300-wins-chase-1234730600/

I feel like 300 wins is one of those achievements that'll definitely be accomplished but it'll truly require a Maddux-like level of being consistently injury free and declining slowly vs precipitously.

There's no one under the age of 30 with 100 career wins. Top 3: Berrios (29 yrs old, 81 wins), Marquez (28 yrs old, 65 wins), Giolito (28 yrs old, 60 wins).

I wonder if Verlander's injury troubles the last few seasons have been a trade-off: costing him wins, obviously, but saving him innings and extending his career. If he is serious about 300, I'd do my best to stay in Houston.

Had the game on in the background last night, listening more than watching. Two outs away from a shutout; got a great inning-ending DP early in the game after loading the bases.

Man, that Justin Verlander's a great pitcher.

https://phildellio.tripod.com/lincecum.jpg

(Kidding around here.)

lol

Returns tonight. He was good last year, but how long can he keep this up? Clemens won a Cy Young at 41; probably had some help. Spahn, Johnson, and Ryan were good. Maddux was so-so. I don't know if there are any other relevant comparisons.

he got shelled in his two minor league rehab outings

Didn't know that...I should have included Seaver and Glavine; both so-so at 41. I left out guys like Jamie Moyer and Bartolo Colon--impressive careers, but not the same caliber as the others. Left out Niekro, too, for obvious reasons.

One guy who famously tried to stretch it out and fell apart at 41 was Carlton.

6 IP, 2 ER, 4 H, 4 K, 0 BB, 78 pitches is nice work, even if it is against the nats

8/21 first-pitch strikes is subpar, but maybe even more impressive that he overcame it

260th win, top 10 in strikeouts:

https://www.mlb.com/news/justin-verlander-passes-greg-maddux-for-10th-all-time-in-strikeouts

I agree with the URL here: unlikely but not impossible.

https://www.cbssports.com/mlb/news/will-justin-verlander-get-to-300-wins-why-milestone-is-unlikely-but-not-impossible-for-astros-veteran/

6% according to the Favorite Toy. The first necessity is someone who actually cares about getting there, and Verlander does seem to check that box. With the indifference to pitcher wins in the analytic era, it might be more of a curiosity than anything else if he managed to pull it off.

His 0.4 fWAR/-0.1 bWAR so far this season isn't doing him a lot of favors in the projections department.

Which team would be willing to roster him for the sake of vanity counting stats when he's marginally above replacement and in questionable health?

The Angels

Which team would be willing to roster him

most of them?

Has he ever looked worse?

0-3, 6.93 ERA, 39 avg GameScore over last 5 starts against mostly <.500 teams.

Feel like he looks worse every start, maybe he’s not recovering as well as he used to after games

I get this mental image of him, Scherzer, and Kershaw limping to the finish line, waiting to see which one falls down first and withdraws from the race.

The Dodgers want Kershaw to be back and ready for the playoffs. If they need him...good luck, L.A.

I've never seen a more cursed starting rotation predictable outcome.

Has Scherzer been sighted at all? I know DeGrom was throwing quite recently

Verlander struggling since return from IL, only 71 ip for season, so Mets off the hook for $17 mil in '25. Scherzer on IL again, only 39 ip. Cohen's decision to eat money/move on from both last year paved the way for '24 success, with Stearns' smart signings of Severino/Manaea.

— John Harper (@NYNJHarper) September 3, 2024

I was going to include deGrom in that group, but I read he's pitching well in the minors--the finish line still seems a ways down the road for him (unless he just suddenly decides it isn't worth it anymore). Scherzer, not sure what's going on.

Verlander and Scherzer tied as the active leaders in strikeouts with 3,405 (in 3,397 and 2,874 IP, respectively)

(xpost) "Worth it" in terms of what he puts his body through, I should say--obviously, it's really worth it in other ways.

In deGrom's last 254.2 IP (2020-2023), which at one point might've been a not atypical number for a starting pitcher --

397 Ks, 0.734 whip, 192 ERA+, 2.12 ERA

no amount of flashy stats can combat how frustrated all of us are to not see him pitch in his prime

Otm

no amount of flashy stats can combat how frustrated all of us are to not see him pitch in his prime

Casas stood at his locker inside the visitors' clubhouse, preparing for an interview following the Sox's crucial series-clinching win against the Astros. A clubhouse attendant approached Casas's area, gathering his game-worn gray New Balance cleats, packing the first baseman's bag as the team prepared to head back to Boston.

"Excuse me, don't take those please," Casas said to the clubbie.
Casas turned the cleats around, showing that they had been authenticated.
Why?
"(Those are the cleats worn)on my Justin
Verlander hit,' Casas said.

no amount of flashy stats can combat how frustrated all of us are to not see him pitch in his prime

― Michael F Gill, Tuesday, September 3, 2024 5:22 PM (yesterday)

I feel like I just got carded at the bodega.

It may hurt more as a Mets fan.

yikes, just when you thought he couldn't look worse...

That's got to be one of his half-dozen worst starts ever.

Thread title delivers: Verlander uses his wife’s zoom account to attend a presser, a journalist (not on mute!) points this out. Absolutely embarrassing

Being accidentally unmuted in 2025 is crazy https://t.co/VuOC8WmHjb pic.twitter.com/YvWkdYNKGi

— dylan (@sfgsalsa) January 13, 2025

i'm willing to believe Verlander might overperform expectations in 2025, he was "okay" in the first half of 2024 and maybe he'll be reasonably effective coming off a healthy offseason. he missed two months and was terrible after that, so maybe there's some reason for slight optimism that he'll have his shit together for SF. I'm not drafting him for my fantasy team again though...

It helps that he’ll be playing half his games in SF.

if i went to SF as a pitcher I think I could break out with an ERA in the low 4s and my fastball reaches maybe 50.

yeah no, he looked good in a couple ST games

Thinking it might really be time to hang it up. The Giants in the WC mix probably makes him want to hang on, but I don't know, would he be automatic for a post-season roster--does his salary guarantee that? An SI piece about his "historic bad luck" has this:

According to OptaSTATS, there have been 4,200 starting pitchers who have entered the All-Star break with at least 65 strikeouts since the All-Star Game was established in 1933. Verlander is the only one who went into the break without a win.

That aside, he's hardly pitching well.