The Girls of American Idol

Message Bookmarked
Bookmark Removed

i started a s/d thread a while ago. i think it's time for a poll. plz post links below of favorite performances.

Poll Results

OptionVotes
Kelly Clarkson 10
Fantasia Barrino 4
Katharine McPhee 3
Ryan Starr 1
Tamyra Gray 1
Kellie Pickler 1
Mandisa 1
Frenchie Davis 1
Paula Abdul 0
Melinda Doolittle 0
Jordin Sparks 0
Lisa Leuschner 0
Melissa McGhee 0
Lisa Tucker 0
Paris Bennett 0
LaKisha Jones 0
Haley Scarnato 0
Gina Glocksen 0
Asia'h Epperson 0
Amanda Overmyer 0
Ramiele Malubay 0
Kristy Lee Cook 0
Carly Smithson 0
Brooke White 0
you left my favorite girl out, and i listed her below 0
Stephanie Edwards 0
Syesha Mercado 0
Lindsey Cardinale 0
Diana DeGarmo 0
Trenyce 0
Vanessa Olivarez 0
Julia DeMato 0
Kimberly Caldwell 0
Carmen Rasmusen 0
Kimberley Locke 0
Christina Christian 0
Jasmine Trias 0
La Toya London 0
Jennifer Hudson 0
Mikalah Gordon 0
Jessica Sierra 0
Nadia Turner 0
Vonzell Solomon 0
Carrie Underwood 0
Leah LaBelle 0
Amy Adams 0
Camile Velasco 0
Nikki McKibbin 0


Tape Store, Friday, 26 September 2008 18:06 (ten years ago) Permalink

Classic combos

Tape Store, Friday, 26 September 2008 18:10 (ten years ago) Permalink

making Paula an option is unnecessary, there's so many other possibilities for joke votes even without her.

some dude, Friday, 26 September 2008 18:15 (ten years ago) Permalink

Paula isn't a joke option!

A great answer:

Tape Store, Friday, 26 September 2008 18:16 (ten years ago) Permalink

Paula isn't a good answer, though.

Tape Store, Friday, 26 September 2008 18:17 (ten years ago) Permalink

airline jam

Tape Store, Friday, 26 September 2008 18:23 (ten years ago) Permalink

the original
">

Tape Store, Saturday, 27 September 2008 18:33 (ten years ago) Permalink

so i've narrowed this down to tamyra, kelly and jordin...tamyra was the best on the show, kelly has the best discography and jordin is somewhere between those two accomplishments (also she obviously has my sentimental support)

Tape Store, Saturday, 27 September 2008 18:38 (ten years ago) Permalink

also angry about this:

Tape Store, Saturday, 27 September 2008 18:41 (ten years ago) Permalink

Ryan Starr forever!

kornrulez6969, Saturday, 27 September 2008 23:03 (ten years ago) Permalink

Fantasia obviously, no contest.

After The Hurricane (The Brainwasher), Saturday, 27 September 2008 23:04 (ten years ago) Permalink

My top 5 in no order:

Tamyra (agree, was the best on the show)
Carly (those of you who posted on the last AI thread will find this weird, but I really warmed up to her)
Trenyce (FIERCE!!!!!!! her Come See About Me is one of my fav Idol perfs)
Latoya (the only time I ever stopped watching AI was after she was eliminated. Maybe if Jasmine had left before her I would have been okay with it)
Kelly (a very close second to Tamyra on season one, but the greatest solo output)
Paris (I will concede that her audition was probably her best performance)

I'm pretty sure I said this before, but if Tamyra had been on any season than the first, the show would have had the resources and the momentum to turn her into a huge star. Oh well.

john mccain's illegitimate black child (musically), Saturday, 27 September 2008 23:21 (ten years ago) Permalink

All you Pickler bashers. Have you even seen an interview with McPhee? She sounds "dumber" than how you perceive Kellie, only without the adorable Southern accent that drives me wild. And Kellie has a better body. If we were to vote, I'd rather get naked with Pickler. Instead of rose petals, I could spread a bunch of sliced dill pickles on the bed. I love pickles. Besides, I sleep with McPhee every Tuesday, every time she sings. Yawn.

ilxor, Sunday, 28 September 2008 00:39 (ten years ago) Permalink

Automatic thread bump. This poll is closing tomorrow.

System, Tuesday, 30 September 2008 23:01 (ten years ago) Permalink

so is 'ilxor' the new deeznuts or what?

some dude, Wednesday, 1 October 2008 03:41 (ten years ago) Permalink

Not enough people on this thread! I'm voting Tamyra.

Tape Store, Wednesday, 1 October 2008 04:50 (ten years ago) Permalink

The correct answer is Kelly.

Tape Store, Wednesday, 1 October 2008 04:50 (ten years ago) Permalink

I still hold a major grudge against Katharine McPhee because Elliott should have won that season.

Tape Store, Wednesday, 1 October 2008 04:54 (ten years ago) Permalink

Not enough people on this thread! I'm voting Tamyra.

― Tape Store, Tuesday, September 30, 2008 9:50 PM (Yesterday) Bookmark Suggest Ban Permalink

The correct answer is Kelly.

― Tape Store, Tuesday, September 30, 2008 9:50 PM (Yesterday) Bookmark Suggest Ban Permalink

multiple personality disorder is a tragic thing

john mccain's illegitimate black child (musically), Wednesday, 1 October 2008 14:51 (ten years ago) Permalink

I hate Katherine McPhee and Carrie Underwood so much.

i am the small cat (HI DERE), Wednesday, 1 October 2008 14:52 (ten years ago) Permalink

I bought a bootleg of seasons 1-6 on DVD and can I just say that Ryan Starr was SO MUCH worse than you remember!? Rewatching season 1 was surreal; the production was almost ameturish and the auditions that got through were godawful. Good times.

john mccain's illegitimate black child (musically), Wednesday, 1 October 2008 14:53 (ten years ago) Permalink

Automatic thread bump. This poll's results are now in.

System, Wednesday, 1 October 2008 23:01 (ten years ago) Permalink

one year passes...

Two rough mixes of new songs from Megan Joy:

http://mjsbigblog.com/new-song-from-megan-joy-feel-love.htm

I like them!

Such A Hilbily (Dan Peterson), Thursday, 17 December 2009 20:02 (eight years ago) Permalink

four months pass...

Ha!

EdKranepool69, Monday, 26 April 2010 23:01 (eight years ago) Permalink

kind of ridiculous how carrie underwood got 0 votes when other than Kelly she's probably been the most successful and will probably be around for years

Jamie_ATP, Monday, 26 April 2010 23:35 (eight years ago) Permalink

kind of ridiculous how carrie underwood is more famous than tamyra gray

Yonder Mountain Zing Band (Tape Store), Monday, 26 April 2010 23:53 (eight years ago) Permalink

top 5 performances:
Jennifer Hudson - "Weekend In New England"
Kelly Clarkson - "Stuff Like That There"
Kelly Clarkson - "Before Your Love" (can't remember if it was the final night or finale face-off version)
Kelly Clarkson - "(You Make Me Feel Like) A Natural Woman"
Kelly Clarkson - "You Lied"

Paul, Tuesday, 27 April 2010 00:32 (eight years ago) Permalink

top 2 male performances:
Rickey Smith - "It Might Be You"
Rickey Smith - "I've Done Enough Dyin' Today"
the rest are probably all Ruben!

it was worth all the rest of the shit I had to sit through just to hear those 7 (and a few other) performances above

Paul, Tuesday, 27 April 2010 00:45 (eight years ago) Permalink

Tamyra - "A House Is Not A Home" (video above) also belongs on the greats list

Paul, Tuesday, 27 April 2010 00:48 (eight years ago) Permalink

four years pass...

I don't think anyone here's watching this anymore, but look, this season has its own Lana Del Rey:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jjGZ3roumzE

Losing swag by the second (Dan Peterson), Friday, 27 February 2015 15:28 (three years ago) Permalink

three years pass...

I don't think anyone here's watching this anymore, but I loved this:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u_2GjbvrX7w

No energy, only great chaos (Dan Peterson), Wednesday, 11 April 2018 18:44 (eight months ago) Permalink


You must be logged in to post. Please either login here, or if you are not registered, you may register here.