Singers Who've Lost Their Voice

Lou Reed's voice was essentially completely shot by the time of the Bells, which is more or less where I get off the boat but I know others here rep hard for what came after

i'd almost prefer a thread of the opposite idea, singers who've preserved their instrument beautifully over the years

yeah this might be more interesting, because honestly it's much more rare

I believe Mariah Carey kinda lost hers, too, right ?
And she's still successful.
Same for Whitney Houston by the end of the 90s, iirc (she wasn't successful anymore though).

Yes, there could be two twin threads !

would also allow accounting for those people who always just *sounded* old right from the start, so when they actually got really old it was like nothing had changed much (cf. Ralph Stanley)

xp

Prince kept his voice 'til the end, didn't he ?
Same for MJ (I'm not sure about that one) ?

xp Simeon Coxe from the Silver Apples would be a good candidate for that one, he's 80 years old and really doesn't sound that much different than he did in '69, when he also sounded like an old hippie

Prince's range remained very impressive right to the end, yeah. True, he didn't do quite as much yowling + screaming.

I don't think Lou Reed's voice was totally shot by "The Bells" because, later on, he did occasionally sing songs entirely straight and acceptably ... when he felt like it.

Either Springsteen is still in excellent voice or there's some discreet autotuning of the top of his range on the new album.

title of this thread is irritating tbh. Every singer over the age of 70s is going to have their lungpower and range decrease, it's just a fact of aging.

More appropriate title might be "quality music by senior citizen singers" or something

Chet Baker for the lost voice part of the thread.

Greg Lake comes to mind, he sounded incredible in the early 70s but if you listen to those later ELP records (which I don't really recommend) you can hear his register start to lower and lose its power. he sounded okay through the 80s, but by the 90s reunion it was totally shot to the point where it was kinda painful to hear him try the old material - was surprised to find out he was only in his forties then

Honestly, a lot of the examples given so far either lived hard or certainly chain smoked for decades. That's got to make a difference, especially as you get older. Springsteen, for example, I'm not sure he ever smoked, and while his voice isn't what it used to be, it's still a pretty powerful thing.

Didn't Joanna Newsom's voice change after she got a throat operation? For nodes?

Lol nobody mentioned before this post was 70 when they lost their voice

my point was that sooner or later almost every singer is in this "singers who've lost their voice" category

Scott Walker's voice was pretty well-preserved right until the end - never touring obviously helps.

xp especially when they die

alright. I started the thread

Singers Who've Kept Their Voice

Either Springsteen is still in excellent voice or there's some discreet autotuning of the top of his range on the new album.

― Brad C., Wednesday, July 3, 2019 8:36 AM (five minutes ago) bookmarkflaglink

i think springsteen lost some of his range circa tom joad/the rising, his voice gets narrower and distinctly more dylan-y and strained around then. he still sounds great live so i sometimes wonder if it was a conscious choice

Either Springsteen is still in excellent voice or there's some discreet autotuning of the top of his range on the new album.

my point was that sooner or later almost every singer is in this "singers who've lost their voice" category

right, I was thinking about Annie Haslam here...her voice suddenly got thin and wobbly, but on the other hand she still sounded great through her sixties, so idk if she counts really. you can't have a soprano like that at 72 years old

Springsteen has definitely lost range and power, but his voice was a thing of magic to begin with.

Axl sounded pretty awful for a while, but he seems better, or at least better than it was. Roger Daltrey, he had a few bad years as well, but has sounded okay since surgery. Stevie Nicks is nowhere near where she once was.

Kurt Wagner. coping mechanisms: falsetto, autotune

Hetfield is struggling. David Lee Roth for sure. Bruce from Maiden ... doing ok?

Ian Tyson (of Ian and Sylvia) is a strange case. he sounded great in the early '00s, but he fried his voice later in the decade when he tried to out-sing an over-amplified backing band and later came down with a bad cold. he regained some of his vocal power after having polyp surgery, only to lose it again after he was intubated during heart surgery a few years ago. I don't think he's well enough to perform these days. cowboys are allowed to have gravelly voices, so it doesn't seem like the ordeal took too great a toll on his career.

Billy Corgan.

John Sebastian

tbf in the case of Corgan you can't lose what you never had

Been thinking about Bjork, she doesn't seem to have attempted any of her old vocal acrobatics this last 10 years or so, is this because she can't any more?

Roger Daltrey, he had a few bad years as well, but has sounded okay since surgery.

He was decidedly hit-or-miss in 2006-07, but yeah, post-surgery Daltrey sounds good, especially for 75.

title of this thread is irritating tbh. Every singer over the age of 70s is going to have their lungpower and range decrease, it's just a fact of aging.

Yeah, maybe I should have said "Singers Who've Lost Their Voices and Still Made Good Music" ... but the point wasn't "Hey, everybody gets old and loses their voice ... that sucks!" so much as "Some folks stop being interesting when they lose their voice (which also sucks), but some don't ... why?"

Some great points in here.

Gregory Isaacs was the poster boy for this

Robert Plant sounded shot as early as Physical Graffiti, but he's settled nicely into his new voice, especially circa Raising Sand where he sounds almost like Roy Orbison in places.

Mark Kozelek. Whether his conscious change in delivery was secretly because he can't quite sing the way he used to... either way when he tries now (from what I've heard) it sounds specifically like the new rantrapping-matthew mcconaughey Kozelek trying to sing, as apposed to him just sounding the way he did before he switched styles. Reaffirms that new asshole rapping Mark is an imposter. Real Mark is missing!

Listen to Siouxsie Sioux on The Seven Year Itch and prepare to cringe

Been thinking about Bjork, she doesn't seem to have attempted any of her old vocal acrobatics this last 10 years or so, is this because she can't any more?

― mfktz (Camaraderie at Arms Length), Wednesday, 3 July 2019 15:59 (fifty-six minutes ago) link

Yeah, she's had some serious issues with her vocal cords over the past decade (surgery, frequent forced vocal rests, cancelled shows etc.) and her upper range is weaker than it used to be but she still can belt a note out. She might even sound better in her mid-range now, but at the cost of losing the dolphin noises / acrobatics.

Joni Mitchell's loss of vocal range beginning in the 80s is very evident but she's a heavy smoker.

I remember hearing that a lot 10-15 years ago re: Bjork - "if she keeps singing like that, she's gonna lose her voice"

Pre:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pbn6a0AFfnM

Post:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aCnf46boC3I

i actually think Kylie has improved over the years.
someone could suggest studio based tweaks, however, Sundays performance (and last years Hyde Park show) would definitely contest that idea.
she has learnt how to use her range really well.

shit.
wrong thread !
ooops.
doi repost over in the other one ?

Thread title Should be “...Voices” no?

It’s actually kinda crazy to me how affecting I find ferry’s fucked old guy voice

Lucinda Williams. She's always had that drawl/slur thing going on to some extent, but over the past four or five albums it's increased to the point where I can hardly stand to listen to her any more. A couple of years ago she re-recorded Sweet Old World and the difference in her singing from the original album is excruciating.

Waits is the rare performer who "found" the voice they're most commonly associated with well into their recording career.

Post-2005 Tori Amos.

Being a huge Echo & the Bunnymen fan, I've seen loads of discussions around Ian McCulloch's voice, and obviously I have to admit that he doesn't sing like he did in the 80's - up to and including his first solo album Candleland.
But his voice is still unlike any others and he changed his style to match it, he still does amazing things with it and, while it's not what you hear on those classic records, he's a treat to hear live.

Paul Banks

A notorious one : Maria Callas

Waits is cool because he spent most of his career trying to sound like a wise, bitter old hobo and now his voice fits the persona he was working on all these decades, so the older he gets, the - i don’t know if better, but - more organic his older material sounds when he performs it.

Thom Yorke has sadly lost much of his higher tones and he sounds like he’s whining more often than not when he attempts it. Vocals break constantly live when he has to go there.

The more he losses his voice the more he likes to use it as a texture or loops inside songs and it makes for a frustrating listen to me. There’s way too much whining and mumbling that wasn’t there or at least not as noticeable in his younger years.

He’s still a pretty great vocalist but I wouldn’t mind if he toned down the high notes and the mumbling.

Re : Ferry, yeah I love his jazz/big band stuff. arguably one of the peaks of his career imo.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s2hzLpZftLQ

George Clinton!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oQVaRudcClc

Compare and contrast :(( https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CCpWh8Yi9Uc

OMG

Ian Anderson

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2QeDpONKs0U

Walter White's flute skills have improved though

Johnny Cash might be considered in the same group as Waits and Cohen.

Life has been not surprisingly pretty rough on many of the old 80s metal singers voices.

Stephen Pearcy
Vince Neil
David Coverdale
Chris DeGarmo
David Lee Roth

Thing with some is that they get them healed or fixed and they do improve some times. Axl Rose voice was completely blown on some of those faux-GNR live stuff, worst I can remember was that clip of them playing one of those Bridge benefit concerts. Axl and Phil Lewis (of LA Guns) both seemed to have lost their voice and a few years later sound much better.

as much as I hate to admit it, kate bush (although it does give some of the director's cut covers an eerie feel)

I actually really like Kate's huskier vocal style from DC and 50 Words for Snow. Her voice has definitely changed, and she's adapted/developed her singing style, but I wouldn't say she's "lost" it. I also thought she sounded good (if a bit safe) on the live recording from Before the Dawn.

Morrissey. He made it work on Vauxhaul And I but when the songwriting went downhill there was not much to work with.

Comus is kind of interesting because Roger's voice changed completely, a different singer almost, not actually bad but most probably prefer his older voice. But Bobbie sounds exactly the same!
Please make more music!

Joni Mitchell makes a compelling case for losing your voice.

Morrissey. He made it work on Vauxhaul And I but when the songwriting went downhill there was not much to work with.

if only he lost his voice, maybe then he'd stop doing interviews

I thought the story with Joni was that she smoked like crazy specifically to *change* her voice on purpose.

Michael Stipe seems to have lost most of his once-wide vocal range by 2007 (when R.E.M.'s Accelerate album was recorded).

Geddy Lee’s voice has slowly deteriorated over the years and he became unable to reach the high notes of the earliest Rush albums. But then watch the concert video of the Clockwork Angels tour and he is visibly struggling to reach even the pitched-down versions of songs. It actually hurts to watch.

Hmmm. 2008:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-0wsEzK-yJA

Pitch-y at first but he seems to settle into it

Those are pretty high notes. E5, F5?

Stipe sounds pretty bad in that 2008 clip and the RRHOF induction from the previous year, IMO

Andy Bell from Erasure

Man this makes me sad. I heard only a little bit of the latest album but it was autotuned to oblivion and I figured it was probably the case that his voice is gone

Chris Conley from Saves the Day was one of these, I think.

Re: Andy Bell. It’s not just the autotuning, it’s the way that he actually sings now - seems like something changed in his technique when he did the Pop Star to Opera Star TV show. Does make me a little sad to listen back to the earlier Erasure records and hear how good a voice he had.

I think Stipe's hitting an e4/f4 on "air". He struggles on the scale around A-C before getting back to being comfortable. Which feels like he's not getting a chance to breathe. One could say he's trying not to breathe.

literally!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ioQLg5Aodjw

I looked at the source video expecting it to be some negligible thing that stupid youtube channel blew up into a thing but nah, he legit was nowhere near the mic and his voice came in at same volume. also I know what he sounded like 4 years before that clip was recorded and it...wasn't that good.

linda ronstadt, to degenerative palsy.

Aw :(

I mean, dude was always pitchy and inconsistent even in his prime, but this is....o_O

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tobKbYRCJOo

Linda Thompson has a new album that's entirely guest vocalists due to her dysphonia.

Phil Ochs!

"One night, Ochs was attacked and strangled by robbers in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania, which damaged his vocal cords, causing a loss of the top three notes in his vocal range."

I ran across the final Demis Roussos album the other day, and by 2009 there was absolutely nothing left of his former semi-operatic voice, it's reduced to a sub-Joe Cocker rasp.

Also, it's quite something to bookend your 40-year career of sappy baroque balladry with a 9+ minute epic called "Who Gives A Fuck" (last track on his last album).

Wow.

Hoo boy @ Sebastian Bach