♫ Before I talk, I should read a POLL! ♪ ILM Artist Poll #93 ♪ B-52’s ♫

I remember K-earth playing this and Another Brick in the Wall all the time

guessing:

#4 Your Own Private Idaho
#3 Roam
#2 Dance This Mess Around
#1 52 Girls

Because of how it effected me as a kid, my #1

Sorry about all the posts in a row, at work

I'd love to have been at those first concerts. This is such a batshit song to release as your first single.

uh "Roam"

(not the order i had those songs in fwiw, just trying to read the ILM hivemind!)

No way are "Roam" and "Your Own Private Idaho" better than "Rock Lobster".

I think I first heard the original DB Records "Rock Lobster" single on Dr Demento, before the debut album was released

My #1. It changed my life. Details when I have more time to type.

I'd love to have been at those first concerts.

I was. More later...

I was just about to post about the single version. I kind of prefer the DB version of 52 Girls:
https://youtu.be/V2DEgpiK8Oc

https://i.imgur.com/R4KdLfD.jpg
4. Roam

796 points, 30 votes. Highest position on ballot: 2

Cosmic Thing
music video

mtv live, 1990

Live 1999, with Julee Cruise

My #1.

This song.

Those harmonies.

That guitar.

Kate's finest hour

overplayed, but for good reason

roam is a wonderful song. not top 10 for me, tbh, but i will never skip it.

I really like that image.

My #1.

Roam was not your #1, if you were referring to it with that post (it was your #2)

thanks jmm!

i'll be back in 30 minutes to finish the top 3

Way late, but:

i was one of the #1 voters. there are other b-52's songs that rock much harder or that make me giggle but this one puts tears in my eyes, i think it's so beautiful. one of the best musical evocations of real bittersweetness, genuine smiles in looking back through incredible loss and pain, to a time that can never be had again but which still lifts the spirit and matters. a love letter of gratitude to one's bandmates, a statement of just how much it could matter, at the right time, to have a few other proud deadbeats to bum around with.

(Roam was my #2 too)

shout *out*, even

And *who's*. My word.

My #1.

Roam was not your #1, if you were referring to it with that post (it was your #2)

― Karl Malone, Wednesday, November 14, 2018 5:29 PM (two minutes ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

See? I was right about changing my mind!

Monster cracked the top 3?!

"Loveland" hasn't placed, has it? Clearly impossible now. Didn't vote for it, but wouldn't have picked that as the sole Mesopotamia omission.

"Roam" always reminds me of returning to school at end of (southern hemisphere) summer, early 1990. It was new and suddenly as massive as "Love Shack" and was playing in art class. A girl who usually didn't say much (least of all about music) was moved to remark "this is such a good song, isn't it?" I don't remember any occasion when it would have been harder to find a dissenting view.

thanks dorsalstop - and i also had "roam" at #2!

come on Flintstones theme

Lol

"Roam" is brilliant and I don't know many other songs as perfectly affirmative.

https://i.imgur.com/RjY2EHk.jpg
3. Private Idaho

888 points, 33 votes. 4 first place votes.

Wild Planet
music video

another guiding light performance(!), from 1982

Live 1992, with Julee Cruise

placed on 33 of the 34 ballots!

OK, who didn't vote for Private Idaho.

I'm glad three other people also put this as #1

again, I prefer the Party Mix version, so great with this wide open sound

Yes,a great song

Yeah, who didn't vote for Private Idaho!!!!!!

...

:D

the bonus secret question is Who Voted For 'My Own Private Idaho'?

A: several of you

https://i.imgur.com/CarUDmi.jpg
2. Dance This Mess Around

892 points, 32 votes. 3 first place votes.
The B-52’s
live 1983

tv performance 1990, new year’s eve

https://i.imgur.com/Dn3kdBy.jpg
1. 52 Girls

932 points, 32 votes. 5 first place votes.

The B-52’s
live 1978

live 1980

live 1990

Rank, Track, Points, Total Votes, #1 Votes
1 52 Girls 932 32 5
2 Dance This Mess Around 892 32 3
3 Private Idaho 888 33 4
4 Roam 796 30
5 Rock Lobster 790 28 5
6 Give Me Back My Man 757 29 2
7 Planet Claire 735 30
8 Mesopotamia 618 25 2
9 Deadbeat Club 501 21 2
10 Party Out Of Bounds 463 19 3
11 Legal Tender 432 18
12 Strobe Light 406 18 1
13 Topaz 400 16 2
14 Song For A Future Generation 394 17 1
15 Dirty Back Road 342 16
16 Love Shack 338 16
17 Lava 295 15
18 Ain’t It A Shame 294 12
19 Girl From Ipanema Goes To Greenland 289 15
20 Summer Of Love 282 14
21 Channel Z 262 12
22 Hero Worship 260 13
23 Wig 246 12 1
24 Devil In My Car 220 10 1
25 6060-842 211 11
26 Bushfire 178 9
27 Cake 176 8
28 (tie) 53 Miles West Of Venus 128 7
28 (tie) Quiche Lorraine 128 7
30 Is That You Mo-Dean? 122 7
31 Dry County 121 6
32 Nip It In The Bud 115 5 1
33 (tie) Theme For A Nude Beach 108 6
33 (tie) There’s A Moon In The Sky (Called The Moon) 108 6
35 Whammy Kiss 107 6
36 Deep Sleep 105 5 1
37 Runnin’ Around 99 5
38 Queen Of Las Vegas 96 6
39 Throw That Beat In The Garbage Can 92 5
40 Butterbean 85 5
41 Trism 79 4
42 Cosmic Thing 75 5
43 Detour Thru Your Mind 70 4
44 (tie) She Brakes For Rainbows 68 4
44 (tie) Work That Skirt 68 3
46 Revolution Earth 60 3
47 (tie) Good Stuff 59 3
47 (tie) Loveland 59 3
49 Juliet Of The Spirits 51 3
50 Follow Your Bliss 39 2
51 Junebug 32 2
52 Downtown 28 2
53 Funplex 26 2
54 Debbie 25 1
55 (tie) Meet The Flintstones 22 1
55 (tie) Moon 83 22 1
57 Hot Pants Explosion 21 1
58 (tie) Big Bird 13 1
58 (tie) Eyes Wide Open 13 1
58 (tie) Housework 13 1
61 (tie) Deviant Ingredient 12 1
61 (tie) Dreamland 12 1

KATE! Kate and Cindayyyy

Rank, Release Name, Points, Total Votes, #1 Votes
1 The B-52’s 1012 27 16
2 Wild Planet 943 27 4
3 Cosmic Thing 805 24 4
4 Whammy! 563 18 1
5 Bouncing Off The Satellites 417 13 2
6 Mesopotamia 417 13 1
7 Party Mix/Mesopotamia 191 6 1
8 Good Stuff 56 2
9 Party Mix 36 1
10 Funplex 28 1

I basically couldn't really order my top three, of which Private Idaho was one, because I like them all too much... Private Idaho is like everything great about this band at once, and says in four minutes what Blue Velvet needs two hours to say.

these are always so fun. Thanks so much Karl & Bee, this is one of my favorite bands.
The only thing I had that didn't place was "Too Much To Think About", an attempt at having one off every album.

1 Devil In My Car
2 Dance This Mess Around
3 Hero Worship
4 Legal Tender
5 52 Girls
6 Dirty Back Road
7 Planet Claire
8 Private Idaho
9 Lava
10 Runnin' Around
11 Give Me Back My Man
12 Dry County
13 Song For A Future Generation
14 Strobe Light
15 Roam
16 Rock Lobster
17 Queen Of Las Vegas
18 Wig
19 Quiche Lorraine
20 Deadbeat Club
21 Party Out Of Bounds
22 Mesopotamia
23 Is that You Mo-Dean?
24 6060-842
25 Too Much To Think About

Final rankings by album

B-52's (#1, 4251 points)
1 52 Girls 932 32 5
2 Dance This Mess Around 892 32 3
5 Rock Lobster 790 28 5
7 Planet Claire 735 30
17 Lava 295 15
22 Hero Worship 260 13
25 6060-842 211 11
33 (tie) There’s A Moon In The Sky (Called The Moon) 108 6
52 Downtown 28 2

Wild Planet (#2, 3431 points)
3 Private Idaho 888 33 4
6 Give Me Back My Man 757 29 2
10 Party Out Of Bounds 463 19 3
12 Strobe Light 406 18 1
15 Dirty Back Road 342 16
24 Devil In My Car 220 10 1
28 (tie) 53 Miles West Of Venus 128 7
28 (tie) Quiche Lorraine 128 7
37 Runnin’ Around 99 5

Roam (#3, 2742 points)
4 Roam 796 30
9 Deadbeat Club 501 21 2
13 Topaz 400 16 2
16 Love Shack 338 16
21 Channel Z 262 12
26 Bushfire 178 9
31 Dry County 121 6
42 Cosmic Thing 75 5
50 Follow Your Bliss 39 2
51 Junebug 32 2

Bouncing Off The Satellites (#4, 1370 points)
18 Ain’t It A Shame 294 12
19 Girl From Ipanema Goes To Greenland 289 15
20 Summer Of Love 282 14
23 Wig 246 12 1
33 (tie) Theme For A Nude Beach 108 6
43 Detour Thru Your Mind 70 4
44 (tie) She Brakes For Rainbows 68 4
58 (tie) Housework 13 1

Whammy! (#5, 1296 points)
11 Legal Tender 432 18
14 Song For A Future Generation 394 17 1
35 Whammy Kiss 107 6
38 Queen Of Las Vegas 96 6
40 Butterbean 85 5
41 Trism 79 4
44 (tie) Work That Skirt 68 3
55 (tie) Moon 83 22 1
58 (tie) Big Bird 13 1

Mesopotamia EP (#6, 1165 points)
8 Mesopotamia 618 25 2
27 Cake 176 8
32 Nip It In The Bud 115 5 1
36 Deep Sleep 105 5 1
39 Throw That Beat In The Garbage Can 92 5
47 (tie) Loveland 59 3

Good Stuff (#7, 274 points)
30 Is That You Mo-Dean? 122 7
46 Revolution Earth 60 3
47 (tie) Good Stuff 59 3
57 Hot Pants Explosion 21 1
61 (tie) Dreamland 12 1

Funplex (#8, 102 points)
49 Juliet Of The Spirits 51 3
53 Funplex 26 2
58 (tie) Eyes Wide Open 13 1
61 (tie) Deviant Ingredient 12 1

Other Releases
54 Debbie 25 1
55 (tie) Meet The Flintstones 22 1

The only thing I had that didn't place was "Too Much To Think About", an attempt at having one off every album.

oh, speaking of, i meant to tell you, i didn't include your 21-25 on your ballot! i probably could have left it on but i wasn't sure what to do since everyone else submitted 20 max. similarly, alfred submitted a top 6 albums and i left his #6 off.

please do not sue me for a recount, or to prevent a recount

terrific results, terrific list of songs, and possibly the best images in any ilm poll ever? would type more but am headed out for drinks.

god "private idaho" is great, probably the song that *really* hooked me on the band. that wild riff, that super-tight playing overall, the crazy hooting, the delicious chewing into 50s b-movie stuff (which i already knew from mst3k, and in the case of radioactive swimming pools, maniac mansion). but it's also a sexy party pool "full of strangers." they're on fire on this track.

also fun to think about that pool as the live-in-the-late-70s version of what stipe is brushing up against and remembering on "nightswimming."

Karl Malone excellent job, thank you so much for taking this over for me. You did this poll and band justice. Told you that you would have fun.

More later.

lol, I'm just glad the poll got completed, and I go back and forth about whether 6060-842 is a great track or not.

I approve these poll results and commend Karl, Bee OK, and we participants on our excellent taste

Paypaled a fish to Karl.