2017 Arcade Fire LP

Josh otm itt

Man the songs they haven't released yet from this are terribad. I get the rating.

Banksy Disco is one of the best things i've ever heard.

There was a moment during their show at Roskilde on july 1st where Win jumped down towards the crowd during Here Comes the Nighttime, and stood at the gate to the stage and sang 'they won't let you in' and he seemed so sneering, so condescending, so full of himself that he was on this side of the gate, and we were on the other side. It took me out of the whole experience, and I never really got back into it for the rest of the show.

― Frederik B, Friday, July 28, 2017 1:25 PM (yesterday) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

Perhaps satire? *strokes chin*

Problem is Will doesn't have the charisma to pull satire, he makes me cringe more than bono if that's possible.

Bono at least appears to be enjoying himself

it's got to be a tiring job

How much are you willing to bet that Arcade Fire release a different, good album today to admonish all those suckers who took EN seriously

— Laura Snapes (@laurasnapes) July 28, 2017

that would have been the only possible trick to make the anti-marketing marketing gimmick worth it, though IIRC Old Man Gloom and Akron/Family beat them to it

It's not a bad album really if you don't pay much attention to lyrics, there's at least 4 decent songs in there.

"at least 4 decent songs in there" a pretty weak endorsement.

Unless you're talking about, like, a single 30 minute song.

It's a short album

I'm not even a huge U2 fan but these chumps aren't even in the same league as U2, "I Will Follow" alone is worth more than every note of Arcade Fire and that's if U2 quit after their first big single

U2 > AF

Don't think it requires a poll but curious on seeing the arguments. Also why are we all comparing these two bands? Is it having a self-righteous prick as a frontman? Because musically speaking they seem to be more inspired by Springsteen.

U2 is aight but they would be much better if a little person ran out and punched Bono in the dick at some unspecified point during each of their gigs

arcade fire is more Eddie & the Cruisers

Ouch

You're not totally wrong:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nYDAF6NbgKc

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GEZockGkEyY

It's not a bad album really if you don't pay much attention to lyrics, there's at least 4 decent songs in there.

I judge an Arcade Fire album by how good the Regine cuts are, so Reflektor was already a bit of a disappointment. No leads from her, but 'Joan of Arc' was fun.

...so here we are, and omg I find 'Electric Blue' really grating???

no one was lying about how bad "Chemistry" is, wow

I sorta think "Sprawl II" ruined this band by making them think they should try for that sort of thing as the rule rather than the exception

Listened to this a couple of times now and really haven't liked it, for much the same reasons as other people are saying, I think. Poor lyrics, a lot of filler and some actually bad/embarrassing songs, a nasty smug, arrogant vibe prevailing.

this really reminds me of that terrible, disappointing Aeroplane album from a few years back.

I've been cold on a lot of AF stuff in an 'I'm not feeling this, but I get why people like it' kind of way. This is almost like they're actively trying to be crap.

Yeah, the filler is obviously filler-like, instead of just less good versions of the singles. But I'm still making my mind up, and at this point I kinda love Peter Pan and Chemistry. It really helps the rhythm group to go full dub, they never figured out how to play this stuff live.

this album is like watching a software tutorial on YouTube presented by some stoned guy who spends the first 5 minutes cracking bad jokes and humming to himself.

Arcade Fire are selling $110 fidget spinners
Novelty toy contains a copy of the band's latest album, Everything Now
https://consequenceofsound.net/2017/07/arcade-fire-are-selling-110-fidget-spinners/

Reflektor was pretty crap too though.

oooof

http://thequietus.com/articles/22936-arcade-fire-s-everything-now-reviewed-track-by-track

there are a few U2 comparisons upthread and my other thought on that is i think Arcade Fire these days seem to be making a lot of empty gestures that don't really hit very hard. i think the context for Achtung Baby and Zooropa was a lot more compelling as well, the whole European sensibility that permeated those two albums (plus Passengers) was genuinely fascinating and often very haunting. the songs were very personal for the most part but the sense of place and time was palpable.

I agree with that. They are also, as I've noted many times, not the least "ironic." They are indeed personal and often quite affecting in their emotionally honesty, imo.

quietus piece was good. much better thought-out than the rather cruel takedown of Animal Collective they did last year.

There’s an overton window of pop culture and we need to give it a good shove away from this pap. Or, to put it another way: we don't have to put up with this shit. It's really not good enough. You deserve better, we all do.

I'm very glad someone said it

But I'm not sure some of you really do deserve better?

heard the title track blasting out of a car window and would say it qualified as noise pollution

look forward to FJM getting this treatment

But I'm not sure some of you really do deserve better?

If you bought this album you certainly deserve better for the money spent

count me as one of those who never saw what was the big deal w these guys

the "concept" for this is weak as fuck. someone bought them some wind breakers with a logo on it? wow deep man.

If you bought this album you certainly deserve better for the money spent

― octobeard, Wednesday, August 2, 2017 3:38 PM (fifteen minutes ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

you deserve a one way bike lane into the middle of the ocean

Norman Records‏ @normanrecords · 9h9 hours ago
Finally listening to the new Arcade Fire. Full apologies if you are one of the people we sold it to.

Also, is there any excuse for using (a) woodwind that sounds like the panpipes on The Fast Show and (b) this combination of piano, strings and chanting choir that desperately demands we feel emotional in that Coldplay-Snow Patrol way

Didn't we establish earlier that Wake Up did it first and it's Coldplay and Snow Patrol and a trillion indie bands the ones copying the emotional peak choir thing (which I've always fucking hated btw)

it's all just watered down Hey Jude bullshit

Which is also a terribly annoying song.

Might be a bubble/perspective thing, but I've not seen a fall from grace in this spectacular car crash way as with this Arcade Fire LP for quite some years. And Joan Crawford was otm (reviewers telling a band simply "no, just no"). And not just that one review, or Dorian Lynskey's, but the Quietus review one-ups it and basically brands Win Butler as a misogynist creep (and Anne Wood makes a strong case tbh).

I suppose the fan base are praising AF for their 'daring' effort and sticking up for them fiercely? Regardless, this album is bombing in every respect, except for youtube comments by fans I suppose.

from the quietus:

This is a song of yelling that might have a distant ancestor in Billy Joel’s 'We Didn’t Start The Fire', but it is not as good.

damn

There should be a thread for when writers try to do a takedown and fail to realize they are describing a sample. I don't think anyone would call Francis Bebey 'woodwind that sounds like the panpipes on The Fast Show' if they knew it was Francis Bebey, not Arcade Fire.

was reminded of the Quietus review reading the YA book scandal thing... I can definitely relate to a lot of the reviewer's criticisms wrt Win's bad lyrics, but all the same perhaps it's a bit too personal in its mean-spiritedness? I dunno, Signs of Life is not a great song but maybe this is not a wholly fair description:

This is mean-spirited conservatism that thinks it’s edgy and cool, with the added bonus of sexist undertones

AF publicist boasted on Facebook when the album debuted at number, something like "three number ones in a row, suck it, haters!" Which of course invited people to post all these other shitty bands that have had multiple number one albums in a row.

the publicist is supposed to be some sort of meta "joke"

can't remember if i posted this in here already but that p4k review is an incredible piece of music criticism and one of the best things they've ever published. i haven't heard the record so my jaw dropped when the author mentioned a lyric about a fan "committing suicide to Funeral."

win butler ✔ @DJWindows98
Hey guys. Taking an extended break from this thing, will miss the opinions and the 1 liners :)))) talk later when I got something to say 🌐
3:00 PM - Aug 7, 2017