Tindersticks : classic or dud

http://www.boomkat.com/item.cfm?id=21814

quite shocked to see my own post from just a year ago where i claim that only I and II are essential. i don't think i could live without any of their albums now.

LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE SO SAD LOVE LOVE LOVE

Trouble Every Day ~ El Diablo En El Ojo ~ A Night In ~ Buried Bones ~ Tiny Tears ~ If She's Torn ~ Can Our Love ~ People Keep Coming 'Round ~ I Know That Loving ~ Cfgf

yup, it's their best.

Dusted off their first two albums, reminded of why I loved them so much etc.
Also, their cover of Kathleen is something to die for.

New Tindersticks, anyone as excited as I am?

http://graphics8.nytimes.com/images/2007/10/12/arts/12lars600.jpg

^loved that film.

looking forward to a new tindersticks but it's a bit soon after the last one to actually get excited. i liked the last one a lot though.

Is that the one about the love doll? I did like that movie.

I actually thought the last one was a career lowpoint. The loss of three members including Hinchcliffe did them no favours. I've been a fan since the early days, it was great to see them come back after the split but it's just not the same band I fell in love with anymore.

Loved the last album after a while, this one's a disappointment. Two or three keepers and a lot of dreck.

the idea that i didn't know there was a new album makes me feel oddly sad. any details?

what's the film above?

Lars and the Real Girl but i'm not sure of its significance here.

perhaps it's a pointer to stuart staples current image?

the idea that i didn't know there was a new album makes me feel oddly sad. any details?

You're forgiven – we're getting ahead of ourselves here, it's not actually out yet. Release date 25/1 in Europe and 16/2 for the rest of the wide world.

i can't believe i never contributed to this thread. the first album ruled my world when it came out, after that the returns diminished quickly. i didn't listen to anything past the third album, i think. what attracted me to them was a blood and flesh like quality of the music. i had not heard something like that before. perfect night time music. i also loved the length of the album. it must have been 78 minutes or so, every second of the cd format was used. and additionally there was no inessential song. after that it could only go downhill. i especially got bored by the singer's voice.

i didn't listen to anything past the third album, i think

Sadly for you, you jumped ship at just the wrong time. The fourth album is an absolute delight, brimful of short, snappy and soulful tunes. I love the first album as well but I wouldn't say there were no inessential songs on it. same goes for the second and third albums, both of which top 70 mins if I recall correctly.

It's wasn't until Curtains that I really started loving the Tindersticks, Simple Pleasure, Can Our Love, and Waiting on the Man are my favorites. The Hungry Saw sounds almost uninspired, like band just wanted to put an album out. The new one didn't surprise me much either. Not as bad as the last one, but I guess they aren't the same band anymore.

yeah the fourth album is the best, i think. everything after that has been increasingly dull. some of it verging on self-parody (though honestly they were flirting with that with their 2nd album).

and yeah the big change for me was after they lost their drummer, who i think was the best thing about the band.

first is still my favorite. a vague hazy late night bar concept album cohesion maybe based on the cover painting still haunts me the way only some isolated tracks do from the subsequent ones. and i could swear the national, especially the boxer, springs from the brow of that first one. not much difference in the vocal performance between and lyrical sentiment of say "city sickness" and "brainy"

national have much more conventional Rock arrangements though. the whole "chamber pop" thing is a big part of what tindersticks were.

People write off The Hungry Saw at their peril - it's really a pretty neat little album, not really much like any of the others but with lots of memorable songs and mood pieces ("The Other Side of the World," the title track, "Boobar," "The Organist Entertains.")

which is the 4th album? the last one i bought was curtains. i don't even remember listening to it. it was a big deception. always the same sound but without the enthusiasm, the pathos and the exuberance of the first album. just plain dull.

the only time I hear em now is when I see a Claire Denis film.

which is the 4th album?

Simple Pleasure. Naughty but nice cover shot.

they maybe have gone on too long but they haven't offended me in any way. they don't thrill me quite the way they did when the first album came out and it was all I listened to for a year.

the new albums maybe would have been better presented as further stuart staples solo albums since thats what they kind of are (and I like his solo records also).

The Hungry Saw is superb. one of their best records.

new album out.

Anyone seen the Asphalt Ribbons album for sale recently?
Or have a copy for sale, either CD or vinyl?

this dude sings like Basehead

the national guy sings like this dude

saw them last night in SF, accompanying segments of Claire Denis films as part of the SF International Film Festival. They aren't doing many of these shows so if they do another one near you, go, was exceptional.

http://www.filmlinc.com/film-comment/article/claire-denis-and-tindersticks - review of clarie denis sdtks box

LOL @ "we all have our croissants to bear"

New song!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5v1eFVOj4is