Post a controversial music opinion

I'd take "Fallen Angel" over "The Night Watch", and "One More Red Nightmare" over "The Great Deceiver", but not by much.

Yeah, KC were definitely way better after Muir & Cross left. Cross's violin lines on LTiA and S&BB are just weedy and Muir's percussive freakouts add little.

Completely disagree with this. I definitely hear the connective threads between Islands and Larks, though. All the albums between Court and Larks (yes, even Earthbound now that it's been expanded) are well worth hearing and stand up well.

Just one?

the foo fighters really reached a new level of musicality in the 2010s

doolittle is the closest but the second side is still a big step down from the first - "hey", "no. 13 baby" and "gouge away" are all fanastic but "mr. grieves", "crackity jones" and "there goes my gun" are all only fine and "la la love you" and "silver" (sorry kim but it's pretty far from your best) really shouldn't have made the album at all

Otm….this is where Pixies are QUIRKY rather than engaging ly offbeat

Red probably my favourite KC album.

jeez this went from "post a controp" to "discuss shitty inexplicably canonized music" real fast.

leo kottke is a better guitarist than robert fripp.

Lol, praising the guitar chops of Leo Kottke is truly where controversy resides.

just trying to get things back on track.

"Crackity Jones" might be my favorite pixies track, though the version I prefer by far is the one off the "Death to the Pixies" live disc:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1fUTzBbF69k

So much energy in a 1:35 track!

trying to work out whether austin is really good or really bad at this thread

also amazing live versions of Rock Music, Broken Face and Something Against You from that same live album, far superior to the studio versions in my controversial music opinion

just trying to get things back on track.

OK but unperson's KC opinion actually was controversial, which is why discussion resulted. "Leo Kottke > Robert Fripp" is just a pointless apples and oranges. They're both highly accomplished and well-respected guitarists who do entirely different things.

trying to work out whether austin is really good or really bad at this thread

― imago, Tuesday, January 18, 2022 9:14 AM

https://i.imgur.com/4sJ7mTw.jpg

sund4r i counter that king crimson's discography is pointless. now what?

it seems completely obvious that side b of doolittle (except hey and gouge away) is markedly inferior, the controp would be that side b is in the same ballpark of quality yeah

side b is my favorite part of doolittle

side b has "no. 13 baby" ffs

anyway i'll stop posting completely uncontroversial opinions

also austin if you post controversial opinions about shitty canonized music you get discussion about shitty canonized music

"No. 13 Baby" > "Hey"

Austin, Leo Kottke vs. Eddie Hazel?

Applause to Austin for leveling up his shitposting game in the past 30 minutes, and also for saying the things I was struggling to articulate. /a single tear

Lol, praising the guitar chops of Leo Kottke is truly where controversy resides.

― The sensual shock (Sund4r), Tuesday, January 18, 2022 11:10 AM (twenty-four minutes ago) bookmarkflaglink

leo kottke's biggest flaw is he's too good of a guitar player tbh

xp

*”their” sorry. I really need to completely nip assuming genders in the bud. And that’s no shitpost!

Austin, Leo Kottke vs. Eddie Hazel?

― Halfway there but for you, Tuesday, January 18, 2022 11:24 AM (thirteen minutes ago) bookmarkflaglink

willie nelson vs. metallica
slick rick vs. erik satie
dawn richards vs. chuck berry
zz top vs. the modern jazz quartet

Guy Mann-Dude vs The RZA

Is ILM finally dividing into proggist vs punkist sects? Has this division always been here and I missed it?

americana vs thrash
jazz vs house

this thread is basically at the level of some 16 year olds arguing about xbox vs. playstation on a gaming forum 15 years ago i wouldn't draw many conclusions

Britney Spears vs The Music

sly cooper vs. gentle giant

J.S. Bach vs. Sebastian Bach

lol ums

I never listen to the Pixies b/c the Breeders exist but their best is their last and their best song is "Tame."

TS: ums vs. YMP

Yeah I know this thread is devoted to provocative opinions but I’d be surprised to see ~2005 gaming forum fites rise to this level of pretentious smugness.

It astonishes me that a band as dull as the goddamn Pixies can still provoke this kind of discussion.

My controversial opinion of the morning: King Crimson's 1972-74 lineup started great…

Tame! I'm gonna live torever

tame
makes a man take things harder

sund4r i counter that king crimson's discography is pointless. now what?

Kind of whatever unless you're a prog rock fan otherwise (beyond the stuff that gets classic rock airplay).

yammering on about the oldies bugging you? in two weeks we'll have had the EOYs and a whole load of brand shiny new controps will be primed and ready

i counter that the median value of this unmeasurable is sleven

TS: ums vs. YMP

― Presenting the Fabulous Redettes Featuring James (James Redd and the Blecchs), Tuesday, January 18, 2022 11:47 AM (eight minutes ago) bookmarkflaglink

i would never do a thunderdome with such a quality ilx poster!

and all the posters sayyyyy....

xp

rong, ums adds value, I just do drive-by quipping and stupid puns

Not a KC fan but I like Red and Discipline in equal measure, even if I file the latter next to Belew solo albums. Fripp's guitar orchestra thing is all-time also

Yeah, Discipline and ItCotCK also S tier

I mean, I kind of agree that the Pixies aren't great in that I don't own any of their albums any longer, in any format, and associate them deeply with getting very stoned when I was in high school. Like many people, certain bands have been confined to that period of life for me— I just have no desire to hear their music any longer, though once in a while I get a hankering to hear "Bird Dream of the Olympus Mons"

The Malady album from last year was really good if you like early KC.

jesus christ, i go for a walk and clean the house and this is how you guys behave???

(also thank you everyone for playing along. my ultimate point i was trying to make in here the past few days is that everyone and everything is ultimately pretty fantastic and absolutely terrible all at the same time. none of it actually matters, no matter how passionately we feel about any of it. isn't that funny?)

yammering on about the oldies bugging you? in two weeks we'll have had the EOYs and a whole load of brand shiny new controps will be primed and ready

― imago, Tuesday, January 18, 2022 9:54 AM

count me in!

eddie hazel, btw.

my ultimate point i was trying to make in here the past few days is that everyone and everything is ultimately pretty fantastic and absolutely terrible all at the same time.

good point that i really did not get from anything you wrote

maybe b/c just saying something is absolutely terrible is not as persuasive as pointing out what's terrible about it?