I hate ILoveMusic, it's got too many POLLS - Artist Poll #104 - THE REPLACEMENTS - RESULTS

My #1 - it's my favourite distillation of their rawness and Westerberg's heart-on-sleeve, although like 'Within Your Reach' it's not really representative since I think it's all Westerberg.

ahhhh my #3

i really really love this and I also am really into songs about telephones & related tech from the past

the frustration & longing is so palpable

Did you post that story on the borad before, tipsy? Seems familiar.

Not that I mind, seems worth posting twice.

(Jim Dickinson tack piano break)

Fwiw, Garu, I also had “Androgynous” at 14. And Karl Malone and I apparently hold “Kids don’t follow” in equal estimation.

i really really love this and I also am really into songs about telephones & related tech from the past

and letter writing! the replacements' letter writing oeuvre is a good one!

maybe my favorite paul vocal performance.

https://images2.imgbox.com/ee/94/M5262fYa_o.png

#6
Unsatisfied
from Let It Be (1984)
Score: 756
Votes: 29 (6)
Youtube: audio track

Bingo!

This would have been my assumption for number one - I was expecting Let It Be to dominate the upper reaches of the poll.

I suspect the rest will be from also be from Tim and PTMM.

my number one, just devastating

re: "answering machine," maybe it's because of current events but it feels to me like there's a little "ain't talkin bout love" in a major key about that guitar riff

I suspect the rest will be from also be from Tim and PTMM.

I think the top 6 will be evenly divided between Let It Be, Tim, and PTMM. I was expecting a top 5 dominated by Let It Be.

It's use in "Adventureland", of all things, really drove this song home for me. My #2.

I agree with your whole post
xp

I was the other #1 "Answering Machine" vote. I went back and forth between about 5 songs for #1, but that one really feels like the entire Replacements worldview distilled. "Unsatisfied" was also in the running for the same reason.

https://images2.imgbox.com/d9/03/HZgMnXlV_o.jpg

#5
Bastards of Young
from Tim (1985)
Score: 761
Votes: 30 (2)
Youtube: original promo video
Dailymotion: on SNL

what a fucking great song

This one I ultimately didn't vote for. It hasn't held up for me as much as my other Tim favorites. Some great lines, tho.

dream unfulfilled
graduate unskilled

4 words ..what a writer

Had that at #17. Getting colder!

I'll say this much about Paul, that guy exemplifies the phrase "turn of phrase," because boy does he have 'em.

anyone seen the doc about mats’ fandom by the same name from a few years ago? its really good imo, still streaming on prime i think

SNL is the definitive performance of this song. It’s just so powerful.

"unsatisfied" was my number one. uncharacteristically grand and nearly the entire track is that chorus but what a chorus!

"bastards of young" is good but not quite top tier for me so i'm glad that it's not higher than this

I like the top ten so far but Androgynous should have placed much higher

Top 4 all totally respectable choices, tho none were in my top 10.

i suddenly hate my ballot ;_; i didnt even vote for unsatisfied & put bastards at #28 #fail

but back to answering machine, a thing i really love about the Mats & paul’s writing especially is the minutiae of life that he includes. the songs feel like such a lived experience of the 80’s in a way that isnt nostalgic but factual

idk

bastards of young was my In into the Replacements. for a long time, i just associated them with that song. loved the SNL performance (one of the reliably more findable videos from early Youtube days), loved the toss-off video (bruce springsteen did a cover of the video a few years later with "brilliant disguise", but he added his a human body to the shot). the raw thrill of it has somewhat worn off through overplaying it through my 20s, but even now, the first verse still rips so hard

God, what a mess, on the ladder of success
Where you take one step and miss the whole first rung
Dreams unfulfilled, graduate unskilled
It beats pickin' cotton and waitin' to be forgotten

the songs feel like such a lived experience of the 80’s in a way that isnt nostalgic but factual

Which has to do with the details, like you say. Not just a lived experience of the '80s but a lived experience of the '80s for a lower-middle-class guy in Minneapolis who isn't sure what to do with himself.

I think "Bastards" was the only Replacements song I definitely knew was a song by a band called the Replacements for a looong time. The video popped up on Rage from time to time and I thought it (principally the video, initially!) amazing as a youngster.

https://images2.imgbox.com/2c/c7/MnHwOLlk_o.jpg

#4
Can't Hardly Wait
from The Shit Hits the Fans (live, 1985) and Pleased to Meet Me (studio, 1987)
Score: 828
Votes: 36 (4)
Youtube: promo video

Youtube: Tim version!

best part of bastards is the beginning, worst part is the end.

the middle is pretty sweet

There is one in the top 3 I'm drawing a blank on, but there goes my #1.

Left/Chilton/Dare in some order

the joe pera joke about “baba o’riley” applies to “bastards of young” too, i think. they realized they wrote a perfect song, panicked, and added that coda

Had "Can't Hardly Wait" at #16, despite issues with the officially released studio version.

Bacobits OTM.

Chilton is the one I'd lost track of, in the 20s on my ballot.

the line "i'll be home when i'm sleeping," with the iii chord on "sleeping," is absolutely everything. my #2.

I should say that:

- two "CHV" votes were emphatically for the Tim-era demo.
- The TSHTF version is contained in the Youtube clip of the whole album, near the start of the thread.

I'm glad Pleased To Meet Me is holding its own. It was my first Mats album - I rescued it from a bargain bin. I was prepared to take a chance on the 'Mats, even though I wasn't impressed by the only other Westerberg songs I knew - his two songs on my sister's copy of the Friends soundtrack.

XP: "CHW", even

lol there has got to be a short list of perfect songs with weirdly dumb or out of place codas. Bastards of Young, Baba O'Riley, Zep's The Ocean...

https://images2.imgbox.com/91/8d/pPvUt3lz_o.jpg

#3
Left of the Dial
from Tim (1985)
Score: 857
Votes: 36 (5)
Youtube: original promo video

is it weird that my favorite thing about "left of the dial"
is the stick clicks? wasn't going to vote for it. but then i relistened to make sure.

fucking anthem

can't argue at all with #1 and #2, one of which was my #1.