I hate ILoveMusic, it's got too many POLLS - Artist Poll #104 - THE REPLACEMENTS - RESULTS

eh she irritates the shit out of me so i can't call it, JJ and LJG would be cool

Joan Jett did her own cover years ago. It's pretty good.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7dFu727az3o

eh she irritates the shit out of me so i can't call it, JJ and LJG would be cool

― Blues Guitar Solo Heatmap (Free Download) (upper mississippi sh@kedown), T

her covers are solid to excellen

i really can't stand her like at all but I'll defer to ilx 10 years ago

<ducks> who can forget Crash Test Dummies cover?

https://images2.imgbox.com/5c/7e/yCrcIRDf_o.png

#9
Favorite Thing
from Let It Be (1984)
Score: 629
Votes: 29 (1)
Youtube: audio track

“Androgynous” is one of maybe 3 songs I would sing to my kids when they were babies trying to put them to sleep.

"Favorite Thing" is so great and I can't even exactly figure out why. There's not much to it but it's pretty much my favorite rocker of theirs (my favorite thing). My #3.

So I have to tell this story about "Here Comes a Regular," even tho I can't vouch for it. I choose to believe it. It was told to me by a casual college acquaintance at a party, somehow the Replacements came up and we were a couple of beers in and bonded heavily over how much we loved them. He told me he had seen them on the Tim tour, at a college (maybe Ithaca), and the show was great but he was bummed they didn't play "Here Comes a Regular." (Which I'm not sure they ever worked into their live set?) He was a teenager and huge Mats fan and had had luck at some other shows hanging around the stagedoor, so he wandered down an alley right after the concert and found a door open and slipped in and came into a backstage area to find Westerberg sitting at an old upright piano that was stashed back there, drinking a beer and smoking a cigarette and noodling around presumably waiting for others. Westerberg looks up and sees this kid and says, "What are you doing here?"

The kids stammers a bit about how much he loves the band etc., and Westerberg grunts. Then the kid says, "I was really hoping you'd play 'Here Comes a Regular." Westerberg grunts again. The kid, not having been chased off yet, says, "Would you play it?" Westerberg, possibly amused at the audacity, says, "What'll you pay me?" The kid, who doesn't have much on him, says, "I can give you a dollar." Westerberg laughs and holds out his hand. The kid gives him a dollar and he starts the song and gets a verse or two in when a security guy wanders in and immediately sees that this kid shouldn't be there and escorts him out while Westerberg is still playing.

"Favorite Thing" my #1. I consider "Can't Hardly Wait" their masterpiece (lol), but of course the 'Mats are not about masterpieces! To me, it's all here: sloppiness and speed, hookiness and tenderness and joy. A song that spoke to me as a teenager and now speaks to the teenager inside.

XP: LOL, fabulous ending to that story.

"favorite thing" was an easy top ten for me, tommy's finest moment.

love that story, mothra. it would be a good treatment for a "here comes a regular" video!

Think big
think big
once in a while

favorite thing is great! my #11

https://images2.imgbox.com/23/e0/VBHFy5yJ_o.jpg

#8
Color Me Impressed
from Hootenanny (1983)
Score: 701
Votes: 32 (2)
Youtube: audio track

Ballot match bingo! Also my number #8. I guess that means I have to drink a beer now. Them’s the rules, no argument from me haha

Two entries in a row where I had to resist the temptation to insert a 'u' into the first word.

Love this shambles of a track.

my #12 ... love this one a lot, i find myself humming it around the house lately

The first time I heard Hootenanny (bought cheap on a whim) I was kinda bewildered until "CMI". "Well that one was good, at least" etc. :)

anyone seen the doc about mats’ fandom by the same name from a few years ago? its really good imo, still streaming on prime i think

color me impressed is sooo good

I forgot to include this one - should have been in my top 20, but I hardly ever feel like listening to Hootenanny.

“Androgynous” I had at #14, the Golden Age of Replacements fandom.

“Favorite Thing” at #4
“Color Me Impressed” at #9
So close!

I’ve got seven chances to beat you, rattle.

https://images2.imgbox.com/0b/f9/tyVwEqkm_o.png

#7
Answering Machine
from Let It Be (1984)
Score: 708
Votes: 31 (2)
Youtube: audio track

“Answering Machine” gave up its spot on the shuttlecraft to “Señor Video.”

My #1 - it's my favourite distillation of their rawness and Westerberg's heart-on-sleeve, although like 'Within Your Reach' it's not really representative since I think it's all Westerberg.

ahhhh my #3

i really really love this and I also am really into songs about telephones & related tech from the past

the frustration & longing is so palpable

Did you post that story on the borad before, tipsy? Seems familiar.

Not that I mind, seems worth posting twice.

(Jim Dickinson tack piano break)

Fwiw, Garu, I also had “Androgynous” at 14. And Karl Malone and I apparently hold “Kids don’t follow” in equal estimation.

i really really love this and I also am really into songs about telephones & related tech from the past

and letter writing! the replacements' letter writing oeuvre is a good one!

maybe my favorite paul vocal performance.

https://images2.imgbox.com/ee/94/M5262fYa_o.png

#6
Unsatisfied
from Let It Be (1984)
Score: 756
Votes: 29 (6)
Youtube: audio track

Bingo!

This would have been my assumption for number one - I was expecting Let It Be to dominate the upper reaches of the poll.

I suspect the rest will be from also be from Tim and PTMM.

my number one, just devastating

re: "answering machine," maybe it's because of current events but it feels to me like there's a little "ain't talkin bout love" in a major key about that guitar riff

I suspect the rest will be from also be from Tim and PTMM.

I think the top 6 will be evenly divided between Let It Be, Tim, and PTMM. I was expecting a top 5 dominated by Let It Be.

It's use in "Adventureland", of all things, really drove this song home for me. My #2.

I agree with your whole post
xp

I was the other #1 "Answering Machine" vote. I went back and forth between about 5 songs for #1, but that one really feels like the entire Replacements worldview distilled. "Unsatisfied" was also in the running for the same reason.

https://images2.imgbox.com/d9/03/HZgMnXlV_o.jpg

#5
Bastards of Young
from Tim (1985)
Score: 761
Votes: 30 (2)
Youtube: original promo video
Dailymotion: on SNL

what a fucking great song

This one I ultimately didn't vote for. It hasn't held up for me as much as my other Tim favorites. Some great lines, tho.

dream unfulfilled
graduate unskilled

4 words ..what a writer