Post a controversial music opinion

Yeah, I'm seeing a...LOT of praise lately that I don't get.

Anyway I missed the discussion earlier re the Cure and any imprecations lodged against Disintegration today are wrong and have been denied.

idk I don’t see anybody saying that about Frank, personally

But it is annoying to see people constant pursing their lips about him and being like “he’s not that great” bc I don’t know any other gay black men doing better, or how he could do any better

this is gonna sound nuts but I think he’s really great, without being the best of the best ever

I think there is an evanescence to his approach that is a very effective way of coding the intangibility of queerness and alternative versions of black masculinity, and that this evanescence also defies quantitative analysis— he’s not the best by any means but he’s more important than being “the best”

But dismissals-without-unpacking of his work (and “Moonlight” for that matter) just make me think “jeez what does it take for a black man to get elected president down there? a Harvard doctorate?”

I feel that, but I also get why people wanna push back when Ryan Schreiber says he has “bar none, the single greatest voice in pop music that I’ve heard this decade.”

I think there is an evanescence to his approach that is a very effective way of coding the intangibility of queerness and alternative versions of black masculinity, and that this evanescence also defies quantitative analysis— he’s not the best by any means but he’s more important than being “the best”

More than fair -- and I don't hate his work by any means. But I don't find myself coming back to it either.

...Ryan Schreiber said that? Um I think he's wrong and also missing the point (unless he means voice in the figurative sense)

Final entry in this list:

https://pitchfork.com/features/5-10-15-20/pitchfork-founder-ryan-schreiber-on-the-music-of-his-life/

speaking of Evanescence they fucking rock

xps I’m pretty sure he was talking about his literal voice

my objection comes from that dumbass gq editor’s letter where he asserts that frank will be remembered as the best of his time (this was after he said that writing about music and writing about fashion were the same thing)

Is this the new guy?

yep

There's Frank Ocean, of course. (I think history will exalt Frank Ocean. By which I mean: One day he'll be known as the best, most boundary-shattering and timeless artist of his generation. Duh.)

he’s not the best by any means but he’s more important than being “the best”

otm -- like Saul Bellow

the older the get the more i hate this monomaniacal fixation on who "the best" is. i don't want to go "late capitalism" about it necessarily, but increasingly it seems like if you're not the absolute best in the world at something the general attitude is that you might as well not bother. i say embrace imperfection! it's more interesting. if every album was fucking "dark side of the moon" music wouldn't be worth listening to.

dark side of the moon is very, very far from perfect

Both otm, but it's broader than music.

Sure, Rolling Stonish rankings like the best 100 albums or top 10 guitar solos ever!!!! Has always just been to generate disagreement and therefore attention. Why was this ranked so high, it's criminal that they neglected that, lather, rinse, repeat.

In art generally, in life generally, and in work generally, the pressure to be excellent (or else don't bother) is a stifling force that would kill loads of happy sloppy accidents that upholster the world with lovable bits of mediocrity.

maybe dark side of the moon is perfect, and that's why i don't like it much

Dark Side of the Moon is boring dreck

I was just about to post something like that but wussed out, thanks Οὖτις!

Rushomancy otm, just the idea of ranking stuff anymore I can't really be bothered

on a related point i think the indie ppl loving lofi aesthetics and 'imperfection' more generally were onto something and the criticisms of them were basic and thoughtless (esp when they used some notion fetishism)

This is not an opinion I share - I spotted it on Twitter - but MAN does it belong in this thread.

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DwzlOhVUYAEEn24.jpg

that is some good ass trollin'.

parody of this

increasingly it seems like if you're not the absolute best in the world at something the general attitude is that you might as well not bother.

Nah, it’s just a music nerd thing. AFAIK, actual musicians (most, anyway) don’t think that way; they just do their thing because they love it and are driven to do it, as artists.

(I think most interesting musicians seem to be fairly self-effacing in interviews, actually. Most, not all...)

I like overusing superlatives like “the best” because I seek to make my life as close to a series of breathtakingly beautiful experiences as I possibly can

lmao at that emo paragraph

MONOTONOUS, COLD and somewhat AGONIZING

Kinda like yer mom

dark side of the moon is surprisingly enjoyable

Dark Side of the Moon would've been improved with Bernard Sumner writing the lyrics imo

I don’t know any of the lyrics on Dark Side Of The Moon, unless “I have become.............. comfortably numb” is one, but that feels probable

xp - possibly so! It came on the radio the other day, and I thought to myself, "this is kinda okay, actually."

I’m pretty sure it goes MONEY ner ner ner nernerner

dope record but def improved if they'd left "money" off and just released that as a single

Having a “Berenstain Bears” moment, looking at the Wikipedia page for this album and learning that it is apparently titled The Dark Side of the Moon

woah..... that freaks me out

"Money" is such a crap song

Absolutely, it's plodding blueay garbage. Ugh.

... bluesy, that is. I hate it when Floyd play the blues.

"Money" is the best song on the album

^^^ My actual apparently controversial opinion.

Lyrical contributions by Bernard Sumner would not have improved it.

^^^ another bold stance on this iconoclastic evening

how dare you sir how dare you

I'm gonna throw in this possibly controversial opinion:

The Dark Side of the Moon is not one of the top 5 Pink Floyd albums

The Division Bell is way better than I remembered, that’s for sure

The Division Bell is also not one of the top 5 Pink Floyd albums

I'll bite - what are the top five?????