American POLL Posse - ILM Artist Poll #91 - TORI AMOS - Results

sometimes this one is too heavy

it's too low, completely devastating song

Where does Honey originate from?

it's an under the pink b-side. originally slated for the album, replaced at the last minute by "the wrong band"

https://i.imgur.com/IVzwdyw.jpg
21. Blood Roses
144 points, 4 votes

Oh wow, never heard it before, I like it.

I found Blood Roses genuinely disturbing when I first heard it. Still shocking even now. I love it though.

it's a shame she replaced Honey for The Wrong Band which is easily the worst track on Under the Pink

I found Blood Roses genuinely disturbing when I first heard it. Still shocking even now. I love it though.

― piscesx, Thursday, September 13, 2018 8:50 AM (three minutes ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

saaaame

https://i.imgur.com/7BuIhdU.jpg
20. Beauty Queen/Horses
160 points, 6 votes

i was really fixated as a kid on music that was so Overwhelmingly Beautiful it gave me chills. Overwhelming Beauty is a pretty narrow aesthetic range, and i wish i hadn't focused on it at the expense of other music. but also: there was the first time i ever heard "beauty queen/horses," and i thought i was, at last, listening to the Most Overwhelmingly Beautiful Music Possible

https://i.imgur.com/IJamJCm.jpg
19. Icicle
176 points, 5 votes

oh wow i thought this'd be top ten

is there a better song about masturbating while your dad holds a prayer meeting downstairs

i think the good book is missing some pages!

this is definitely one that's up there in her most beautiful compositions, what an incredible bridge

nearly the entire top 20 was very much in flux the entire voting period

https://i.imgur.com/mxHBmAz.jpg
18. i i e e e
190 points, 6 votes

this is one that was in my top 10, sounds unlike anything else (except the potion shop theme from ocarina of time)

yeah it was in my top five

the chorus still gets to me

Ahhh these are all my favourite songs in the world. I voted pretty high for "In The Springtime of his Voodoo", "Icicle", "Playboy Mommy" and "Honey".

I'm glad that "Honey" is a b-side, it's such a self-contained perfect song (such great and unusually straightforward lyrics! "And you know what you're doing, so don't even"; "And I think I could leave your world / If she was the better girl").

Whereas "The Wrong Band" is a perfect piece of lightness in between "Baker, Baker" and "The Waitress" that would get lost outside of the album.

Actually Under The Pink was my first TA album when I was 13 and my favourite track used to switch around a lot but I think after initially being "Pretty Good Year" for a while it was "The Wrong Band" because of the sheer levity of the melody. Then for a while it was "Cloud on my Tongue" due to the soothing hypnotism of "circles and circles and circles again..." and then it settled on "Space Dog" for a long time. Coming back to the album now, "Icicle" was my easy favourite.

https://i.imgur.com/7rxRTo1.jpg
17. Jackie's Strength
192 points, 5 votes

i really didn't expect this to place this high, it's good but not really one of the standouts on Choirgirl Hotel to me

Jeez that’s crazy low.

Jackie’s strength showcases Tori’s ability to write empathically and directly, something she doesn’t always do. Love this song

https://i.imgur.com/QcIXSpQ.jpg
16. Cornflake Girl
208 points, 10 votes

last one for today

thanks for doing this ufo

cornflake girl way too low, but also a clear sign of how much quality tori has across the catalog

Way behind here but the #1 vote for Northern Lad was mine, up until recently I wouldn't necessarily have picked it out as a favourite but it struck me just how much of an incredible vocal performance it is from start to finish.

The top 5-10 could have a few surprises then I guess if the likes of Cornflake Girl are already counted for. Is anyone expecting a song from the post-Choirgirl years to still be ahead?

Great poll so far.

Hotel or liquid diamonds hopefully.

I was the #1 vote for "Girl," just a perfect song that never ceases to amaze me.

Indeed my man

Twinkle was my 1

Yeah 'Girl' was near the top of my ballot, i thought it should have been a big single. It gets sorta-forgotten in the sweep of all that great stuff in the top half of Little Earthquakes but i always loved it.

I find le hard to listen to objectively nowadays.
What a big record. Transformative. When I was a teen it perfectly mirrored my disillusionment with Christianity. I think UTP did this even better tho - icicle and god. And hell father lucifer and bliss later on. But like I find it annoying how LE is the cool tori album critically.

https://i.imgur.com/CGH6jdS.jpg
15. Marianne
216 points, 6 votes

what a song

Marianne is the peak of a certain type of Tori song (the ever-shifting piano with a little orchestration ballads)

The ultimate Tori song, in some ways.

Amazing song

Yeah a banger. No idea what the opening line means even now.

Some cool quotes here

http://toriforum.proboards.com/thread/4518

https://i.imgur.com/zquOSuE.jpg
14. Doughnut Song
218 points, 8 votes

How cool is it that pj references Tori’s “no angel came” lyric from Juarez on one of her new songs?

(Side point I know)

xp that looks like a decent site thanks Ross.

:) welcome

https://i.imgur.com/SWCG4I5.jpg
13. Hotel
230 points, 8 votes

I thought this was a lock for top 5

give me moooooooooooooore

Wow three of my favourites all in a row.

truly a track that sounds like no one else