Bang Bang You're Dead... POLL In Your Head - ILM Artist Poll #87 - SMASHING PUMPKINS - Results

My ballot; bolded didn't place:

Hummer
Cherub Rock
Soma
Hello Kitty Kat
Bodies
Quiet
Zero
Rocket
Today
1979
I of the Mourning
Geek USA
Mayonaise
Frail and Bedazzled
Rhinoceros
Porcelina of the Vast Oceans
Tonight Tonight
Thru the Eyes of Ruby
Thirty-Three
Stand Inside Your Love
Real Love
Love
Pissant
La Dolly Vita
Shame

Thanks ufo, this has been a really great poll, so much fun.

I was surprised With Every Light didn't place, that's one of the real highlights on Machina, so pretty even though it's all buried in the mix. also regret not voting for Jupiter's Lament, the barbershop version is probably my favourite discovery from doing this poll.

i think the only song i don't like in the complete results is the "dreaming" cover

Drown
1979
Cherub Rock
Mayonaise
Glynis
Soma
Today
Appels + Oranjes
Siva
Ava Adore
Starla
Obscured
Bullet with Butterfly Wings
Sweet Sweet
Let Me Give The World To You
Hello Kitty Kat
I Am One
Hummer
This Time
Rhinoceros
Zero
Perfect
Geek USA
Galapogos
Stand Inside Your Love

89 Here's to the Atom Bomb 50 1 1

ok i wanna see the "here's to the atom bomb at no. 1" ballot

There's my #1.

― The Harsh Tutelage of Michael McDonald (Raymond Cummings), Sunday, April 8, 2018 9:38 AM (five minutes ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

oh i missed this!!! ray!!!!!!!!

I was a a Drown #1 voter. Got the Singles Soundtrack the week it came out. Took it out to the swimming hole every day and played it on the boombox while we swam. On top of just being a mighty, majestic song, the feedback solo was probably the first thing like that I ever heard and just the way it moved around like the river flowing and the wind and sunshine through the trees. It was like natural and alien at the same time. I wasn't getting high yet - just this ultimate feeling of being 13 years old and totally free. That one and May This Be Love were my favorite tracks on the album - the aquatic tunes.

which version do you prefer xp

Hummer
Snail
Soma
Starla
By Starlight
Bury Me
Rocket
Geek USA
Porcelina of the Vast Oceans
For Martha
Thru the Eyes of Ruby
Luna
Obscured
Mayonaise
Farewell and Goodnight
Beautiful
Rhinoceros
Cherub Rock
Thirty-Three
1979
Muzzle
To Sheila
Tonight, Tonight
Drown
Crush

feedback solo at the end of drown is just... idk, it's so obvious to be like "just make the guitars sound like they're drowning" and yet it's the best. great post how's life

That was kind of beautiful, how's life.

89 Here's to the Atom Bomb 50 1 1

ok i wanna see the "here's to the atom bomb at no. 1" ballot

― flamenco drop (BradNelson), Sunday, April 8, 2018 11:44 AM (two minutes ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

There's my #1.

― The Harsh Tutelage of Michael McDonald (Raymond Cummings), Sunday, April 8, 2018 9:38 AM (five minutes ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

oh i missed this!!! ray!!!!!!!!

― flamenco drop (BradNelson), Sunday, April 8, 2018 11:44 AM (one minute ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

:(

POINTEDLY this is the New Wave version.

Some day I will write a huge essay about how and why this should have been the last Pumpkins song ever released.

My ballot, 20/25 placed:

Stand Inside Your Love
1979
Hummer
Here Is No Why
To Forgive
Rocket
Galapogos
Pennies
Drown
The Boy
Whir
Quiet
Mayonaise
Daydream
Crush
Set the Ray to Jerry
Muzzle
Obscured
Age of Innocence
Try, Try, Try
Perfect
...said sadly
Medellia of the Gray Skies
Tonight Tonight
Cherub Rock

POINTEDLY this is the New Wave version.

Some day I will write a huge essay about how and why this should have been the last Pumpkins song ever released.

― The Harsh Tutelage of Michael McDonald (Raymond Cummings), Sunday, April 8, 2018 9:47 AM (twenty-eight seconds ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

the new wave version is really the superior one yes. it's such a bizarre song, v monochromatic

i love it and i love that you love it that much of course

Yeah, for sure. I played it kinda relentlessly when Machina 2 came out, like I was searching for clues in it.

Obsessions are what keep us alive, right, Brad?

dammmmmmn what a top ten. would never in a million years have imagined "hummer" so high. it's such a great album cut, never think of it as one of the great anthems or anything but it is hard to find much wrong with it and clearly it has much to appeal both to Vig-era fans and the Gish die-hards. and i for one think "life's a BUMMER!" is an awesome moment and a major enhancement to the song. lol at "I like to imagine this song predicts the commercial failure of Hum." hot damn at Drown as #3. strong chance it would have been #1 if it'd been on an album?

mayonaise, which i had at #6, beating 1979, which i had way down at #23, is what seals the deal for me. this is an awesome countdown. thanks ufo, this rocks, and let me also join the chorus praising the rollout graphics and typesetting.

i almost had "here's to the atom bomb" in my ballot and then the only version i could find for my listening playlist was the one from the greatest hits which i'd never heard before and was SO WRONG that it kinda put me off thinking about or listening to the song.

i also like the o.g. machina version as a two chord raveup, it doesn't really work but it's interesting xp to ray

Where is the other version of "Atom Bomb"? There's only one on Machina II, right? (Going to admit that I don't remember what it sounds like.)
2xp I guess that's the answer but lol that it was on a greatest hits album.

Doctor Casino I feel this

Gish IS Vig-era!

the other version of Atom Bomb was a Machina b-side

Sund4r this is the greatest hits version, which has always seemed like the wrong version to my ears.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GjUklMu7H3I

Bolded ones are the ones that placed in the top 66.

Here's to the Atom Bomb (New Wave)
<b>Zero</b>
<b>Rhinoceros</b>
<b> Appels + Oranjes </b>
<b> Pug </b>
<b> Wound </b>
Jupiter's Lament
<b> Galapagos </b>
The Imploding Voice
Crestfallen
<b> Spaceboy </b>
<b> Beautiful </b>
<b> Bullet with Butterfly Wings </b>
<b> For Martha </b>
<b> Glass and the Ghost Children </b>
<b> Today </b>
Landslide
Tarantula
Jellybelly
Try, Try, Try
Let Me Give The World to You
The Everlasting Gaze
Dross
Medellia of the Gray Skies
The Pistachio Medley

Man, I can't do HTML to save my life

lol duh oops abt Vig. sub "SD era"

came close to this being my first ILM poll where my entire ballot placed. "This Time" at #25 (73 in the results) was the exception. "Rocket," my #1 made it to 13, and all of my top ten made the top twenty except for "Muzzle" which I had at #2 and "Where Boys Fear To Tread," my #5.

your HTML is fine but sadly ILX uses bbcode (trust that button next to "Submit Post" on desktop)

and let me also join the chorus praising the rollout graphics and typesetting.

Oh yeah this as well! Always really liked the band's choice of similar-but-different fonts across the SD/MCIS/Adore art so was really happy to see them being used on the rollout images.

Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness
Luna
Porcelina of the Vast Oceans
Galapagos
Meladori Magpie
Rotten Apples
Blank Page
1979
I of the Mourning
Snail
Jellybelly
Here is No Why
Hummer
X.Y.U.
Thirty-three
Rocket
Beautiful
Today
Cherub Rock
Vanity
If There is a God
Tales of a Scorched Earth
Hello Kitty Kat
Marquis in Spades
Wound

My list, bold didn't place:

Mayonaise
Thirty-Three
Whir
To Forgive
Perfect
Starla
Soma
Spaceboy
1979
Medellia of the Gray Skies
Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness
Stand Inside Your Love
This Time
Tonight, Tonight
Cherub Rock
Galapagos
Luna
Pulseczar
The Imploding Voice
Silverfuck
Thru the Eyes of Ruby
Cupid de Locke
Daydream
Bury Me
X.Y.U.

84 Fuck You (An Ode To No One) 58 3 0
100 Landslide 34 4 0
120 The Everlasting Gaze 8 1 0

sadly not the locks on the top tier that some thought. who on earth voted for "The Beginning is the End is the Beginning"?!

no one else voted for Blank Page?

I like the cover of "Landslide" fine but that would have been a hilarious pick for a top 10 entry.

Blank Page was 45

blank page placed flappy

Oh shit lol my b

Dang i must’ve missed that round

i even posted the live video in your absence

Ha, I actually prefer the GH version of "Atom Bomb".

The GH version isn't horrible - it's probably just that thing about preferring the first version I heard of a song.

i even posted the live video in your absence

Whoa, that was a near-perfect Top 10. Only problem I have with it is 'For Martha' isn't in it.

To elaborate: the M2 version of "Bomb" feels like some heartsick, washed out, electronic end-of-the-world. It's as far removed from the band's beginnings as possible; it's barely human except for the singing, super programmed, cybernetic, weird. So when Corgan's voice cuts out at the end there it's as though he's been deleted, and the vocal or lack thereof becomes the gap he's been singing about for the length of that song (though the song itself seems to be about Corgan himself, or the persona he put forth, and being older but still kind of being the same outsider figure, etc). It's a quietly devastating ending to this song.

The GH version has this sunny, twangy guitar that lends it feel that's totally different and somehow less sad and final.

He's been deleted, or he's deleted himself - that's another way to think about it. This is probably the only Pumpkins song I've spent time overthinking this way.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cwWcO_oLLCM

i associate "atom bomb" strongly with kid a and amnesiac-era radiohead bc i was listening to both a lot at the time so i definitely understand the "lead singer erasing himself" vibe you get from it

Interesting angle - I wonder if Corgan was/is a Radiohead fan?

suspect he liked the records but hated their success. critics always putting him in the back.

Made a playlist of my ballot, which I think will be a v enjoyable way to listen to this band: https://open.spotify.com/user/1297256761/playlist/6EaySAiougJgnxwZdXSaiQ?si=UpkfjWPRT0OLWa92NJ7zDQ