Bang Bang You're Dead... POLL In Your Head - ILM Artist Poll #87 - SMASHING PUMPKINS - Results

enjoying brad's alt.collie. good b-side inclusion, and the album really does benefit from fewer startling transitions. there are mid-track startling transitions anyway.

happy that disarm placed anywhere. was a necessary struggle to keep it on my ballot. lol @ flappy's #1, though I suppose he would choose the aperture to his favorite album which he can flap through.

and I love MCIS the song, too. not trying to criticize the choice.

'Real Love' is a really nice proto-Zwan track; 'Tear' I'm really not so keen on, too plodding, definitely one I'd cut from Adore.

"Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness" is so mournful, I once read something someone said about how it sounds like the end of a long, sad play- but it's the beginning of a two hour double album. the end is built into the beginning. as an overture, a thesis statement for the album's concept - that life is happy, life is sad, life is glorious, life is terrible, and everything in between - Billy somehow managed to convey all of that in less than 3 minutes on an instrument he wasn't even proficient in. it's so evocative on its own but also in the context of where the band was at in late 94/95 - they sensed the alt rock/grunge boom coming to an end, and MCIS was going to be their final rock statement before they moved on. and knowing everything horrible and amazing that happened in 1996, the song gains even more resonance. but above all, nothing else has spoken to me like this song as a summation of what life is like. wonderful, horrible, blessed, cursed, and won. nowhere and forever. without a care in this whole world. the beautiful, the tragic. mellon collie and the infinite sadness.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4p4UML8qJNc

did he write it in a higher key or is the pitch off bc of the tape speed on that demo

good post, flappy. alt.collie increased my appreciation for Cherry, Set the Ray to Jerry, and Tonight, Tonight Reprise. But to my ears, The Boy doesn't really hold its own when placed in the album.

i don't blame you for feeling that way sufjan but i gotta live my truth

perhaps 3 others out there on ilm living it with you

thanks sufjan

brad - it's a mystery ha! because there's this video of him playing it for the MTV Rockumentary where it's in D minor instead of C#. maybe they sped the tape up or down a half step on the album? don't know why though. anyway this performance features a really beautiful intro to the song that doesn't appear anywhere else.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MKo4eT38XS4

but yeah the tape speed on that first demo is probably running fast. given his limited piano playing abilities, it makes sense that he'd write it in a whole note scale (not that it's difficult to play in C# - though from what i remember of the Ravinia show recordings, he played it in D minor there too).

"Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness" is so mournful, I once read something someone said about how it sounds like the end of a long, sad play

It doesn't sound like this to me at all - I think it's a pretty, scene setting piece of music that sets up the thundering intro of 'Tonight, Tonight' amazingly, but when I think "mournful", I think of some of the more downbeat tracks of The Cure circa 1980-1982 or some of the selections from Adore rather than this. It's also nice to have a musical theme to riff on to help cohere an all-over-the-map LP.

the mournful quality of the song comes from how innocent and naively pretty it is in the beginning, before moving suddenly to E and G#. it's a jolt, a sobering reminder, acknowledging that nothing lasts forever, that life can be turned upside down or obliterated at any moment. the movement from C# to E and G# shows that clash. i hear all of life within those 3 minutes: optimism, purity, cynicism, sorrow, resignation, determination, love lost and won. Billy goes on to work through his existential issues for the next two hours, but before Tonight, Tonight even begins, he's said it all without words. it's just a remarkable piece of music, an ersatz Debussy ditty that distills so much into so little. it's a monumental achievement and functions perfectly as the title track, because it contains everything that will follow, the spectrum bookended by the romance of Cupid or Lily or Beautiful to the fury of X.Y.U. or Bullet or Fuck You.

Hmm. E to G# isn't a change I'd normally describe as jarring, but still I'm glad you get all of that out of it. For me, the stuff that truly moves me comes much later on.

it's the movement from C# to E that's jarring. E and G# are the basis of the second part of the song.

flappy these are lovely words but there's no point in discussing this with Turrican. He's right about everything, even your own subjective POV

also wait lol who voted for X.Y.U. as their #1?? props. I think it was #15 or #16 on my ballot. So brutal and messy, one of the very few songs they recorded completely live, vocals and all. such a thrilling performance. a fitting apotheosis of rage followed by the gentle comedown of the final suite.

y'all it is dangerous to talk about chords

bang bang you're dead...chords in your thread

hahahaha

LOL

heh

lmao

also wait lol who voted for X.Y.U. as their #1?? props. I think it was #15 or #16 on my ballot. So brutal and messy, one of the very few songs they recorded completely live, vocals and all. such a thrilling performance. a fitting apotheosis of rage followed by the gentle comedown of the final suite.

― flappy bird, Thursday, April 5, 2018 6:22 PM (two minutes ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

YES! Absolutely OTM, 'x.y.u.' (as I've said before) was one of those tracks that grew on me over time, and sequencing-wise it really is the last gasp of the more angry stuff on the record. Talking of moments that are jarring, the transition from the intensity of 'x.y.u.' to 'We Only Come Out At Night' is a real sudden jolt in mood.

while we're waiting for the next batch of songs i've been watching this and enjoying it a lot (i never bought the sd deluxe edition so i didn't know it existed)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kHrabsv1JSg

All of these shifts in style and mood are part of the beauty of the record, of course, I just don't hear the title track the way flappy does. I'm not going to tell him he's wrong, though!

Are we done for the day? It has been a very good one for songs that *almost* made my ballot.

show i just posted might also be ground zero for billy trying out stupid irritating shit vocally

show i just posted might also be ground zero for billy trying out stupid irritating shit vocally

ooh thank you

Super relieved and stoked that Tear made it; late cut for me, one of my favorites from Adire. I remember one review comparing it to the Waterboys. It has a real nightpunk vibe

*Adore

the way he sings “I love you” in Hummer from that 3/15/93 has that Gish yodel

I am very much enjoying reading this thread. One of those threads where the discussion of the music is more interesting than the music itself. Except Gish of course but that album and the amazing songs on it have hardly been posted about. One thing I don't like about the albums after Gish is Corgan's vocal delivery which I have difficulties to digest as it seems so theatrical. On Gish I somehow buy his kind of angsty vocals.

I've often thought the vocal lines on Gish were almost additional guitar melodies, they kind of sit in to the tracks along with the other instruments. SD / wider exposure needed a "front man" type approach and the vocals were foregrounded. Probably why I think of Gish as a goth album and the others as rock.

Glad to see "Glass and the Ghost Children" place - the first of my votes to do so.

XYU - if we'd had a 50 track ballot limit I might have voted for it.

Missed today's roll-out, but off to a flying start! So happy to see 'Farewell and Goodnight' place <3

going to do a few more now:

https://i.imgur.com/W0CmQ9W.jpg
56. Ava Adore
142 points, 6 votes
From: Adore, 1998

https://i.imgur.com/mbFgYxT.jpg
56. Spaceboy
142 points, 6 votes
From: Siamese Dream, 1993

https://i.imgur.com/KyFhTho.jpg
56. Wound
142 points, 7 votes
From: Machina/The Machines of God, 2000

WOUND!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Cool seeing "Wound" place. late cut on my ballot.

https://i.imgur.com/GA5kP5y.jpg
53. Pug
150 points, 6 votes
From: Adore, 1998

oh cool, i'm not at work and can follow this live right now.

haven't said this yet but great job ufo!

"Spaceboy" for the Mellotron love

Ava Adore is SO LOW

Wound was a Machina track that I'd previously overlooked but it's one of the best from it now I think.

Ava Adore is a weird one, I sort of wish the drums were a little more forceful or something? do love the solo onwards though

and another three-way tie

https://i.imgur.com/SvPQIrK.jpg
52. Age of Innocence
154 points, 5 votes
From: Machina/The Machines of God, 2000

https://i.imgur.com/GYaTCOE.jpg
52. I of the Mourning
154 points, 5 votes, 1 #1 vote
From: Machina/The Machines of God, 2000

https://i.imgur.com/LgySnqZ.jpg
52. Crush
154 points, 6 votes, 1 #1 vote
From: Gish, 1991

is there a Spotify playlist? i don't see one, i will make one and post it in a few minutes.

I haven't made one, but that's much appreciated, thanks