best Fall album for starters

Extricate wouldn't be my first choice...Stephen, I wrote you an email back to yours and you didn't respond. Could it be in your spam folder? Sorry we keep missing each other!

If I was to blindly pick two, Extricate and Nations Saving Grace would be them.

The remaster of Ex is weird: The tracks that were not on the album have ben removed from CD1, and put onto CD2 along with the 12" versions and b-sides. Which is wrong.

What do you mean? The tracks that weren't on the LP, but were on the cd and tape? Like, um, Extricate itself in fact?

Exactly that, yes.

That is, as you say, wrong. I had the tape, and I always felt that Extricate was the perfect end of album song.

.. and the track "Black Monk Theme 2" the perfect intro to "Telephone thing", and so on.

that's how i will always listen to it, no matter what.

me too.

Extricate wouldn't be my first choice...Stephen, I wrote you an email back to yours and you didn't respond. Could it be in your spam folder? Sorry we keep missing each other!

It wouldn't be my first choice, either, but it happened to be the Fall album I had on hand that day. He loved "British People in Hot Weather" anyway, what a great song that is! Anyway... I received your email but hadn't bothered to reply since you'd be back on Friday. I'm having a busy week anyway. I'll get around to it soon, I promise!

This Nation's Saving Grace has been in heavy digital rotation for me lately. So that.

One of the wonderful things about The Fall is that any of the albums can be a great place for someone to start, really. Even the weakest releases have some odd, redeeming quality.

That said, I just got my paws on Fall In A Hole (the remastered version with the bonus disc), and might be my favourite thing ever at the moment.

Yessum, that version of CnC Black Night, wot I had not heer'd before, where he does the shotgun sounds, is just mahvlis.

Agreed about any Fall album being a good place to start. I'm not sure Seminal: Live would be top of anyone's list of their best, but who would want to be without HOW, Mollusic in Tyrol or Elf Prefix?

Fall In A Hole! Haha! I dragged my boombox into my bathroom and played that once while taking a shower! Hell, I should do that again somtime.

Don't get me started on Seminal:Live...

Let's get started, Bimble!

DETECTIVE INSTINCT

I'm not so big on the production of This Nations Saving Grace so I would either go for Live at the Witch Trials or Hex Education Hour.

DETECTIVE INSTINCT

― Hot Pants Floyd (Bimble Is Still More Goth Than You), Wednesday, October 15, 2008 5:37 AM (4 hours ago)

Ff ff.

I should have added that I never really got Detective Instinct until someone pointed out to me the intermittent 'ff ff's in the background of the song. What they're all about I do not know, but love them I do.

Fall in a Hole -- maybe my favourite live album of all time. That version of Fantastic Life that starts out the second disc (on the remastered version)! It's like I was hearing that song for the first time

I think I'd stand by 'Grotesque (After the Gramme)' as a great Fall starter album. The band's sound really began to evolve away from its earliest incarnations, and the lyrics are some of MES's best and most topical—a fantastic introduction to his worldview.

'Slates' would probably serve just as well.

'Hex Enduction Hour' is great, but it's a little dense and relentless for the uninitiated.

I think I'd pick Slates over Grotesque...I can imagine most noobs being turned off by C'n'C/S. Mithering...not to mention the diminishing returns
of the second side (sans NWRA of course)

Yeah I don't know why but Grotesque has never been all that high on my list of Fall albums.

Also you are right: Slates is better.

Slates = teh sequel to Grotesque's first side.

I love GATG now, but when I first bought it, it was certainly a challenge...

Side B suffers in its midsection, true. Swap 'WMC-Blob 59' and 'Gramme Friday' for almost anything else they were playing around that time, and it would be a lot stronger.

There's no denying 'Slates' is incredible.

Well, exactly, Drugs A. Money! I wouldn't kick Grotesque out of bed NOW, but I certainly would NOT give it to someone who hadn't heard the Fall before.

Also anyone who might want to have long conversations about The Fall's discography up through Extricate is especially welcome to send me emails and/or chat with me. Thank you.

hooray!

should have added that I never really got Detective Instinct until someone pointed out to me the intermittent 'ff ff's in the background of the song. What they're all about I do not know, but love them I do.

I'm listening to Detective Instinct, now, though and I don't hear anyone going "FFfs" in the background. So I'm not sure what you were talking about. Can you describe the sound better?

xpost Bimble where were you when I was doing the whole Hotel Bloedel thread?

It's very subtle, and doesn't come through well on the copy I've got (sounds like a CD reissue mastered from vinyl).

Listen in the right-hand channel around 0:57, and again a bit later—I guess you could describe it as a faraway aerosol can being sprayed twice in quick succession. It shows up again intermittently throughout the song, in different places all over the mix.

Ah! The Hotel Bloedel thread. Shit, dude, that thread was WAY outta my league. I read it but I really had nothing to even begin to contribute.

Re: Detective Instinct - Ah! a CD reissue - hmm. I have Room To Live on vinyl. The version I'm listening to though is a downloaded version. I will break out the vinyl soon and see if I can spot the mysterious "FFs" sound there, thanks. You're sure it doesnt' mean "For Fucks Sake", this FFs sound? LOL

Shit, dude, that thread was WAY outta my league

lol, it was way outta my league, too.

No, I heard the sound! I gotcha now. It sounds like one of those...round things, whatever that musical instrument is that is round and you move it from side to side. Shaker? I don't know what they call those things.

Bimble do u seriously not rate any Fall albums after Extricate?!?! Cause there are many glorious sonic riches to be had there.

"MY RAZOR BLADES WILL CUT DOWN YOUR ENTRANCE."

Shit dude, we should bring The Fall into the children's classrooms. Start them off with good music early. IN-DOC-TRIN-ATE. Then by the time they're 20, they'll be musical geniuses and will start amazing bands.

No, that isn't true, Sleeve, re: after Extricate...I love Shiftwork...Light User Syndrome's quite good...and uh...well...I dunno. Steven Hanley was never adequately replaced in my book, but okay.

Steven Hanley was never adequately replaced in my book, but okay.

Agreed. Still, MES has come out with a couple amazing albums this decade alone (The Real New Fall LP, Imperial Wax Solvent) that should not be
passed up.

Plus, 2g+2 rox!

and The Unutterable!

I also think the highlights of the two Matador LPs (Infotainment Scan and Middle Class Revolt) would have made one of their best albums. Levitate is also quite good.

valid point about Hanley, you could say the same about Scanlon in my book. I think most of their successes in the last ten years have come from MES trying to move beyond the limitations of the rock band sound, but then again there are times like SParta FC where he just nails it all perfectly. The first time I heard that song I thought it was some lost classic from the 80's.

you could say the same about Scanlon in my book.

Yeah, see, I almost mentioned him when I did Hanley, but I thought I'd keep it lite and not go there yet, but I'm with you.

I can't remember if I've heard Sparta FC or not. I thought Imperial Wax Solvent was quite good, but nevertheless I didn't feel the urge to listen to it very much. Von Sudenfed I listened to more.

By the way, how come no one on ILX that I know of has mentioned this new MES project with someone named Ed Blaney? The album just came out yesterday???

"MY RAZOR BLADES WILL CUT DOWN YOUR ENTRANCE."

Shit dude, we should bring The Fall into the children's classrooms. Start them off with good music early. IN-DOC-TRIN-ATE. Then by the time they're 20, they'll be musical geniuses and will start amazing bands.

*************

This might be a good place to talk about my future plans to score "Solicitor in Studio" for marching band...

DAMN RIGHT

hey bimble btw you still have ur blog? what is it?

Well, my blog has kinda petered out aside from gratuitous You Tube clips, but I've met a new friend near here who is about to provide me with some fresh post-punk inspiration to post. He's got a post-punk compilation I've never heard before and am very curious about and he's gonna rip it for me. So we'll see.

Here's the link for my (now in decline, glory days long since past) blog:
http://windyweather-bimble.blogspot.com/

cool thx.

Ha, I've had that blog bookmarked for months now and never put two and two together to figure it was by THAT Bimble.

I'll show myself out.

LOL

Also anyone who might want to have long conversations about The Fall's discography up through Extricate is especially welcome to send me emails and/or chat with me. Thank you.

hey Bimble, you out there? What do you think of Dragnet?