Prog Rock

have a really hard time getting into them.

i dig Family. roger chapman is a beast. they're up there for me with Audience, Comus, and (not the NYC one) Spyrogyra in deep woods british yodel folk prog

totally unrelated by prins thomas' remix of dungen's häxan is the hot stuff

I've been trying to get people here interested in Family for ages! Are they really a prog band though? They seem pretty unclassifiable to me.

― Wewlay Bewlay (Tom D.), Sunday, August 27, 2017 7:15 PM (yesterday) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

yeah...I guess I feel like they are but they def don't fit in a way, but where else do you put them? They are definitely too complex and eccentric to be just another 70s hard rock band

Is Jethro Tull considered prog by most?

yes, jethro tull is prog

also it's always better than you think it's going to be, like the simpsons (but less good than that)

Tom you know I like Family!

actually thick as a brick is about as good as a good simpsons episode and probably contains a similar level of decent satirical humour

oh shit, this actually happened

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vmWq6yTcXNo

wanna check out one record each from a.) Patto and B.) Family that shows 'em at respective peaks etc etc…help me ILM…

oh shit, this actually happened

Ha, wow

this isn't 'the best' by any stretch but given what's going down with harvey . . .

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zwzSB_Mcr6o

Family Entertainment is very good, and stylistically diverse, although the band had no input on the final track listing or mix. That's the only one I'm familiar (har!) with.

Family - Music In A Doll's House is the one to start with

I started there but I was a little underwhelmed after hearing it's such a classic.
"Mellowing Grey" was totally worth it though, great song.

I love Family. I only first heard them when their stuff was reissued in late 90s. I like 'em in this order:

A Song For Me (Reprise, 1970)
Music In A Doll's House (Reprise, 1968)
Fearless (Reprise, 1971)
Entertainment (Reprise, 1969)
Anyway (Reprise, 1970)
Bandstand (Reprise, 1972)

Thanks for the heads up on the Wobbler release. Right after it's released on Oct 21 they play down the street from me at Reggie's for Progtoberfest III. I won't get to see Motorpsycho so this'll have to do!

Alas, I thought the Weigel book was ultimately a missed opportunity. Besides the occasional (and avoidable) factual errors, it just kind of peters out to an almost dishonest "death of prog" conclusion, conveniently ignoring the fusion of prog and metal in all but the most cursory of ways (there's a bit on Opeth, but I think Iron Maiden earns just one mention, as a favorite band of Dream Theatre, and I'm not sure Metallica gets mentioned at all, major oversights when odd time signatures and epic suites are constantly cited hallmarks of prog) and also ignoring (entirely?) a vital prog pump primer like "OK Computer." Also weird how it gives maybe a sentence to Krautrock, or how it focuses so much on Vangelis but not how new age (a la Vangelis) was really just a watered down form of prog, via vectors like Yanni, Mannheim Steamroller, etc. Maybe that's for a different book, but as for this book, it felt like a hunk was cut out (or ignored) in search of a narrative shape.

I hate it when they do that.

yeah, the book seems cursory, or severely edited. i was expecting so much more.

for me, the best part of the book was the fripp narrative weaving in and out

I agree, as sort of progs prickly conscience.

i would have liked to have seen legit reckoning with contemporary prog (glass hammer, battles, thinking plague, these new puritans, teeth of the sea, motorpsycho, godspeed, wobbler, etc) but probably it's asking too much that a guy who's fortunate enough in other ways to wind up a 'washington post' reporter would win the karma lottery twice and be clued into the really good new stuff too. not a lot of people are in on the secret that prog started not sucking again a while ago. he's a pretty smooth writer though and it's a nice read for what it is

There's a really good column in (I think) Prog magazine called "Prog or Not Prog" iirc, where they address bands like Talk Talk, say, and sort of theorize around whether or not they fit the bill.

Still say overlooking the impact of OK Computer was kind of weird. Or even (going backwards) the Fairport et al. folk-rock stuff, which definitely played a huge part in prog.

Anyway, clearly (per the title) the book was structured around the rise and fall of ELP, with Fripp as a sort of purist through line.

There's a really good column in (I think) Prog magazine called "Prog or Not Prog" iirc, where they address bands like Talk Talk, say, and sort of theorize around whether or not they fit the bill.

― Josh in Chicago, Friday, 22 September 2017 02:40

I liked it when they profiled Sparks because they were actually interviewed about it and they said they were surprised more people hadn't picked up on their prog influences.

have we talked about the Physics House Band?

I guess you could say they were math rock, like Battles or something, but they feel more prog in some way to me than Battles...I dunno, it's a fine line. Dudes are monsters though and I like it

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DgLB_t2DcfU

I don't know--you guys keep bringing up all these recent bands, but how many of them wear capes?

street prog

How many prog guys who aren't Rick Wakeman wear capes?

Last time I saw a cape was maybe ... Jason Falkner when he was backing Air? Am I remembering that correctly?

the dude from Gong had angel wings when i saw them

David Crosby
James Brown
Screamin' Jay Hawkins

also iconic rock n roll cape wearers

james brown is the proggest of all

have we talked about the Physics House Band?

― Universal LULU Nation (upper mississippi sh@kedown)

these fuckers spell "imipolex" wrong

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O1Q7Wj8IQTQ

I like this weird old school Italo/prog electro thing. It's got a good message.

yes, they named themselves after the henry cow song

It's funny that Rick Wakeman got a reputation for wearing capes and his flamboyant keyboard style and for being a guy that is often held up as some sort of figurehead of prog excesses when of all the members of Yes circa Close to the Edge he was probably the most straight-ahead, no-bullshit, down to earth member who hated what he perceived to be the very indulgent nature of Topographic Oceans and Relayer...

How many prog guys who aren't Rick Wakeman wear capes?

― Robert Adam Gilmour, Friday, September 22, 2017 3:03 PM (three days ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

quick image search gives me caped Chris Squire, Peter Gabriel, Pete Hammill

Fripp used to wear one a lot too according to Tony Banks

I presume Fripp wears one in his down time. Gabriel cape was part of Watcher/bat creature costume, right?

Roger Waters used to wear one in the Syd era.

A be-caped Keith Emerson:

https://i.ytimg.com/vi/pf3ywR5DERA/hqdefault.jpg

It's funny that Rick Wakeman got a reputation for wearing capes and his flamboyant keyboard style and for being a guy that is often held up as some sort of figurehead of prog excesses when of all the members of Yes circa Close to the Edge he was probably the most straight-ahead, no-bullshit, down to earth member who hated what he perceived to be the very indulgent nature of Topographic Oceans and Relayer...

― more Allegro-like (Turrican)

his "no-bullshit" nature didn't keep him from smothering "tales from topographic oceans" in indulgent birotron solos. and the dude can hate "relayer" all he likes. he wasn't on it.

I thought Tormato was the one with the Birotron

OK, had to google Biroton.

ok, i guess it wasn't a birotron on tales and the album was really just smothered in plain ol' mellotron solos. if it had been a birotron i'm sure the album would've been yards better, as the birotron is to a mellotron what the vako orchestron is to the optigan.

from wikipedia: 'Wakeman played it backstage noting it sounded "more mellow than a Mellotron"' - but was it more chamber than a chamberlin?

here's mellotron advocate mike dickson playing the beach boys' "prayer" on birotron samples. it sounds fucking awful.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0SqLl5fOokA

I assume this is some Wiki vandalism in progress:

The Birotron (pronounced by-ro-tron) is a tape replay keyboard conceived by American musician and inventor Dave Biro of Yalesville, Connecticut, US, and funded by English keyboardist Rick Wakeman, Campbell Soup Company-Pepperidge Farm Foods in the 1970s.

Last time I checked Wakeman loves Relayer.

I don't know what instrument he uses but some of the atmospheric washes in Topographic are gorgeous and among the highlights. Worthy of Tangerine Dream.

for real, robert. those synth washes rule, especially in and around howe's acoustic picking and strumming in that 'second movement' / 'sidelong epic', up there imho with "close to the edge" and "the gates of delirium"

Yeah the way the vocals are mixed in the washes is especially beautiful. One of the most spinetinglingly awesome Yes moments. I haven't heard all the 70s prog yet but so far I haven't heard much quite like it from that time.

Have you guys heard the Bubblemath record (Edit Peptide)?

It's like Gentle Giant (minus the medievalisms) through a Rundgren New Wave/AOR hyperprism. Or something. The songs take off on some fairly dazzling mathy instrumental diversions but it's catchy and fun with lots of cynical wordplay.