Stone Roses - Stone Roses: C/D?

Heard the 30s clip on Spotify. Oh dear. I'm saying that as someone who wanted it to be good.

Boy this is bad.

I've seen a lot of people saying it sounds way more like the return of The Seahorses than The Stone Roses.

more like the current line-up of Hurricane #1 meets the cast of Jossie's Giants

though its not even fit to stand on their shoulder

its nothing like either

It's fucking horrible. Like a really really really weak Shack. Uergh.

It sounds like a pub rock version of Donovan basically

feel like you guys are just making up x ___version of y combos now

if Love Spreads was their Hash Pipe, then this must be Back To The Shack

I WOULD VERY MUCH LIKE TO HEAR THIS

Please don't. It's awful.

THIS SOUNDS LIKE ARGENT COVERING BELLE AND SEBASTIAN

NO WAIT, JEFF BUCKLEY DOING AN EDDIE AND THE HOT RODS B-SIDE

its nothing like either

― Odysseus,

Hurricane #1's single from last year https://youtu.be/Rj-lcOfJuw0

ON ACID

its like beyonce meets embrace

tho the chorus is a bit front line assembly meets en vogue

Heavy Stereo covering Genesis 'Calling All Stations' prod. by Pete Stanley & Paul Wiggs

Neu! crossed with M People

It really does sound like The Bluetones, The Seahorses and Hurricane #1 though. It's not as if those bands all have really different styles. They mainly made music that sounded like a poor man's Stone Roses and that's exactly what All For One is.

KP where is that Shack album? postponed indefinitely it seems

Didn't know there was anything being released?

This was even worse than you'd made it out to be.

main riff reminds me of this
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gD4PJW4R1ec

Oh wow, good spot!

The drums are just foul. Can't believe that's Reni.

It's an intro track, that's what it sounds like.

Hey, come to think of it, are there any Reni backing vocals?

yeah, the drums are fucking terrible, although when i listened to a few live youtubes earlier he sounded shitty there too :(

the lyrics belong in a donald trump ad tbh

has any guitarist descended more completely and disappointingly from relatively tasteful playing to tedious LEAD GUITAR bollocks as john squire?

Should have broken into a "Mexico will pay" refrain instead of that shitty guitar noodling.xp

Can someone please, Please, PLEASE round up all of these old '90s indie relics and put 'em in a fucking retirement home or something, where they can sit around and reminisce about how they once used to be "mad fer it" and talk about their shoes for the rest of their fucking lives!?

(Yes, I know The Stone Roses came out in '89, but still...)

85

Oh wait you meant the album

Yeah, I meant the album... their mid '80s work doesn't feel like the same band to me.

this is horrible. and what is this an advertisement for the Trump campaign?

Trump pretty much owns the word 'wall' now

'Trump rally' was my first thought too. appalling music.

Lol yes the Roses are Trumplings of course, good work everybody excellent insights

don't let's be beastly to the gurners

I've heard this song one and a bit times and I seem to know it.

that's because it does pretty much the same thing all the way through. it really feels like half a song written as an unfinished demo. the drums are really really really bad.

Ummm ...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gD4PJW4R1ec

yeah zappi already pointed that out. some sort of subconscious steal? maybe the fall will become the new the beatles

Ah yes - should've checked the thread! I think it's a very conscious steal ...

all for one, one for all
if we all join hands, we can rip off the fall

NME are all over this

https://farm8.staticflickr.com/7648/26379507284_d7ac257b10_z.jpg

http://www.nme.com/news/the-stone-roses/93540

Related Articles

Watch Manchester United footballer Juan Mata give verdict on new Stone Roses track 'All Fo...

"And what a mighty anthemic return it is.. The classic Roses sound.. spine-tingling.. stunning.. "

http://www.nme.com/blogs/nme-blogs/the-stone-roses-all-for-one-first-listen