Finally... The Top 200 Extreme Metal Albums of ALL TIME!(results)

haha lj and pantera and what remains of the top 4 and i assume a certain brazillian band

i only have the results down to #21 fwiw

for all i know slipknot could be #1

Yeah definitely! (xposts)

lj you dont like slayer at all?

also where are the dopethrone fans (apart from me)

also not having seen he top 20 which Anthrax album is likely to place? I only ever liked Sound Of White Noise

Love Dopethrone. I want to shout too low but I didnt vote so feels unfair. Would have been in my top 3 for sure. Album still crushes me. Its perfect from start to finish.

I'd have voted for Dopethrone. Likely at least 2 other Wizards as well. This is probably going to be the highest though I'd imagine.

25. Darkthrone - Under A Funeral Moon (467 Points, 7 Votes, One #1)
http://i.imgur.com/2TGfhii.jpg

https://open.spotify.com/album/1DoUTU7FcKT5sy8w4PjsUs
https://youtu.be/Teb8KoyxQdc

This is where I admit that I've never listened to a Death album before. I'm liking Individual Thought Patterns. Nice lead playing.

Seasons is pretty much the sound of Slayer realizing they could just recycle Reign In Blood and South of Heaven forever, without much thought or effort.
― we salute you, our half-inflated dark lord (GOTT PUNCH II HAWKWINDZ), Saturday, February 20, 2016 6:48 PM Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

I don't get this. Seasons was one of its own beasts and while it had sonic similarities to previous albums I don't think RIB was one of them.

One of my favorite Slayer albs

wait, slayer have two more to come?
ffs
― odysseus (imago), Saturday, February 20, 2016 6:51 PM Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

FP

Funeral Moon just scraped onto my ballot - mainly for 'Unholy Black Metal'.

i wonder how imago would cope if 3 Pantera albums placed..

I wouldn't be too happy either to be fair but that's democracy for you

I like the next album, but i am shaking my head at it even placing nevermind this high. I cant believe this beat their best album by nearly 70 places either

24. Mastodon - Crack the Skye (469 Points, 7 Votes)
http://i.imgur.com/6ec0Ptf.jpg

https://open.spotify.com/album/2W2nqEKXWBorbq5yvm3jZg
https://youtu.be/fcvdkw6v3fE

Huh, didn't expect this. Leviathan still to come I guess?

didn't vote for this but remember rather liking it

Well it's my favourite Mastodon album, didn't expect to see it so high. What a strange poll.

Remission is so fucking dull I can't believe people like it. Not one memorable song on it. CtS easily their second best album, close behind Leviathan.

Keep reminding yourself we're talking about the difference between 7 votes and like 4.

I'm awaiting more Voivod and any Gorguts or Incantation. Surely.

(And Thorns but I don't have high hopes.)

xpost

Voivod and Gorguts did pretty well on my ballot.

23. Voivod - Dimension Hatross (489 Points, 7 Votes)
http://i.imgur.com/Z9poYDt.jpg

https://open.spotify.com/album/0KcktieHmhIoqknOh0HX2B
https://youtu.be/Zb8U38lTcq8

2 more for tonight after this

Oh well there we go, then.

I somehow forgot to vote for Incantation. If they miss the list I will blame myself.

Yay!

i assume a certain brazillian band

I hope it's Sarcofago!

I don't get this. Seasons was one of its own beasts and while it had sonic similarities to previous albums I don't think RIB was one of them.

Uh... really? I mean I was enthusiastic about Seasons when it came out but over the years it just kind of pales in comparison to Reign and SoH and sounds like reheated third-time leftovers.

Voivod are one of those ones where I hear how good they are, and they've influenced shitloads of music I love, but they do nothing for me. Will keep trying though.

I voted for sarcofago

Ultros, if you've never heard Nothingface, please try that one. If you have, nm.

22. Neurosis - Through Silver In Blood (493 Points, 8 Votes)
http://i.imgur.com/x183dxM.jpg

https://open.spotify.com/album/6HBRtTolIqgDVJXBwtyYPV
https://youtu.be/Yp7Dz4bh5UE?list=PL2Xyxl9ydrMukw-XJwOrCEjyof3WozT_k

I don't get Voivod either. And Neurosis are one of the dullest bands on Earth. I saw them live twice around the time of Through Silver in Blood - once opening for Pantera and Clutch, and once headlining over Eyehategod and Dead and Gone. Yyyyyaaaaawwwwwnnnnn.

I hated Voivod for a long time until I got drunk and listened to Angel Rat of all things which somehow completed a circuit in my brain.

Neurosis however -- yeah I can't do them at all.

Uh... really? I mean I was enthusiastic about Seasons when it came out but over the years it just kind of pales in comparison to Reign and SoH and sounds like reheated third-time leftovers.

I don't mean to say like it's them reinventing themselves, more that I feel that RIB was a well they didn't really go back to.

Seasons had a 70s rock vibe to it on quite a few songs ("Blood Red", "Expendable Youth") that lent them a nice touch. Plus "Spirit in Black" is one of my favorite Slayer tunes and "Born of Fire" and "Hallowed Point" are favorites.

Seasons wasn't an immediate favorite of mine...took me ten years or so to reevaluate it.

I rather like Neurosis but I prefer Times of Grace so I hope that places.

Voivod I think have the potential to click with me at some point - I HAVE heard Nothingface (I think it's meant to be their weirdest?) but it hasn't stuck as yet

Last one for the evening to go out on and I'm assured by people its a great last thing at night album.... any guesses?

Honestly, some of the faster, more aggressive material on Christ Illusion has more in common with Reign in Blood than anything on Seasons does.

xpost St. Anger

Alright, fine, Seasons sounds nothing like Reign In Blood, still bores the shit out of me. Is that acceptable?

TOO FUCKING LOW

On my ballot. Think I made it my #6. It should have been my #2. Think I penalised it for not being 'extreme' enough, which is ridiculous. It is on the edge of sense.

Guess it clears the way for wall-to-wall boredom in the top 20 tho

Xxxpost you can dislike whatever you want!

you dont know that

xp

21. Sleep - Dopesmoker (499 Points, 8 Votes)
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/__ukh6e8UkjI/TAHvhR02ImI/AAAAAAAAApE/tC3kjJdcWn4/s1600/IMG_2009.JPG
http://i.imgur.com/3hvF3QS.jpg

https://open.spotify.com/album/1u49hpxNCoTCWmJa1NXUZl
https://open.spotify.com/album/5DwHEOrCwvTNwG6H3wNaiU

https://youtu.be/hIw7oeZKpZc

Aww yeeeeeah

Hopefully frobisher will be back tomorrow to finish the top 20.

Here's hoping for a 1-2-3 of Celtic Frost-Bathory-Death SS