Polled At Last: STEELY DAN - ILM Artist poll #50

Peg's at least abt a guy who doesn't feel any real affection for a woman he's involved w unless he's viewing her thru a camera lens/onscreen, so kinda hard not to see it as p dark/sad without any inferences involved

xpost had Turn That Heartbeat Over Again in my head all last night, great closer

full results:

12 Lyrics ballots
31 different submissions

---------

8 ballots
full results for 33 solo tracks
total points, song, number ones, total votes

262 I.G.Y. 4-7
157 The Nightfly 1-5
156 New Frontier 5
94 Maxine 1-3
82 The Goodbye Look 3
73 Morph the Cat 1-2
64 I'm Not the Same Without You 2
58 H Gang 2
50 Slinky Thing 2
45 Circus Money 2
40 Paging Audrey 1-1
36 This Moody Bastard 1

33 Downtown Canon 1
33 Tomorrow' s Girls 1
33 Brite Nitegown 1
30 Junkie Girl 1
30 Ruby Baby 1
30 Somebody’s Saturday Night 1
30 Magic Smile (Rosie Zaza) 1
30 Walk Between Raindrops 1
28 Countermoon 1
27 Mary Shut the Garden Door 1
26 Miss Marlene 1
26 Security Joan 1
26 Hard Up Case 1
25 Weather In My Head 1
24 Century’s End 1
24 Down In The Bottom 1
23 Book Of Liars 1
23 The New Breed 1
23 Lazy Nina (Greg Philliganes) 1
22 Snowbound 1
25 What I Do 1

-----------

40 ballots
Full results for 16 Albums
Total points, album, number ones, total votes

1312 Aja 9-39
1198 Pretzel Logic 5-39
1191 Katie Lied 3-38
1180 Countdown to Ecstasy 7-35
1135 Gaucho 8-36
1096 The Royal Scam 5-38
1063 Can’t Buy a Trill 1-37
517 The Nightfly 2-18
223 Two Against Nature 9
166 Everything Must Go 7

89 Sunken Condos 4
45 11 Tracks of Whack 2
25 Circus Money 1
20 Alive In America 1
18 Morph The Cat 1
17 Kamakiriad 1

--------------

77 Ballots recieved (2 unranked)
84 Tracks received votes
Total points, song, number ones, total votes

1600 Deacon Blues 6-59
1515 My Old School 10-54
1314 Peg 3-57
1252 Doctor Wu 7-44
1203 Kid Charlemagne 5-50
1158 Rikki Don't Lose That Number 4-46
1129 Babylon Sisters 4-44
1117 Black Cow 3-45
1036 Any Major Dude Will Tell You 3-41

885 Hey Nineteen 43
808 Do It Again 1-35
806 Dirty Work 1-36
767 Bad Sneakers 1-39
761 Show Biz Kids 2-32
732 Aja 3-30
722 FM (No Static At All) 34
699 King Of The World 2-28
686 Pretzel Logic 3-33
678 Josie 1-32
669 Gaucho 2-27

646 The Boston Rag 2-27
644 Reelin’ In The Years 32
628 Third World Man 1-26
627 The Caves Of Altamira 25
575 Black Friday 28
556 Barrytown 1-27
543 Only A Fool Would Say That 22
540 Time Out Of Mind 24
522 Night By Night 24
513 Razor Boy 22
492 Rose Darling 24
478 Your Gold Teeth II (2-23)
475 Haitian Divorce 23
468 Your Gold Teeth 1-23
433 Bodhisattva 1-20
427 Glamour Profession 21
418 Don’t Take Me Alive 1-20
408 Home At Last 1-19
402 Midnight Cruiser 18
374 Any World (That I'm Welcome To) 1-15

308 Pearl Of The Quarter 14
304 The Royal Scam 16
302 Everyone’s Gone To The Movies 17
268 Charlie Freak 1-12
264 The Fez 13
259 Green Earrings 1-13
244 Here At the Western World 13
227 Daddy Don’t Live In That New York City No More 13
189 Sign In Stranger 10
179 Brooklyn (Owes the Charmer Under Me) 9

176 Jack Of Speed 1-8
171 Kings 9
156 My Rival 7
143 Through With Buzz 7
132 Throw Back The Little Ones 7
101 Everything You Did 5
90 Second Arrangement 5
79 Parker's Band 4
76 Almost Gothic 4
72 Monkey In Your Soul 3
60 I Got the News 3
59 West Of Hollywood 3
59 Fire in the Hole 3
56 Turn That Heartbeat Over Again 4
49 Change Of The Guard 3
47 Godwhacker 3
45 Everything Must Go 2
42 Gaslighting Abbie 2
39 Cousin Dupree 2
37 Things I Miss The Most 2
36 Janie Runaway 2
30 Mr. Sam 1
43 With A Gun 3
42 You Got The Bear 2
24 Were You Blind That Day 1
22 The Mock Turtle Song 1
20 East St. Louis Toodle-Oo 1
20 Two Against Nature 1
15 This All Too Mobile Home 1
15 Kulee Baba 1
14 Chain Lightning 1
14 Dallas 1
13 Pixeleen 1
12 Blues Beach 1

a worthy number 1. it's such an immaculately paced song, fluid and constant like a moving spectacle. sits on a comfortable groove for seven-odd minutes, but it could go on longer and i wouldn't mind.

It's also the song where I miss Roger Nichols' participation on Aja the most.

ah, I Got the News just missed out

Dr Wu
Deacon Blues
FM
My Old School
Black Cow
Rikki Don't Lose That Number
Black Friday
Don't Take Me Alive
Bodhisattva
Do It Again
The Fez
Reelin' In The Years
Josie
Pretzel Logic
Bad Sneakers
Your Gold Teeth
Home At Last
Show Biz Kids
Time Out of Mind
Dirty Work

----------

The Royal Scam
Katy Lied
Aja
Countdown To Ecstasy
Gaucho
Can't Buy A Thrill
Pretzel Logic
Two Against Nature
Everything Must Go

----------

Semi-mojo
Who's this kinky so-and-so?

--

Show biz kids making movies
Of themselves you know they
Don't give a fuck about anybody else

--

Children we have it right here
It's the light in my eyes
It's perfection and grace
It's the smile on my face

thx 2 B OK & pp
and for the circus money video

No votes for What A Shame About Me, Negative Girl, The Last Mall, Slang Of Ages, Green Book, Lunch With Gina- I think that's all?

I came v close to voting for Slang Of Ages, feel bad it missed out now

Every track on the first seven albums got at least two votes, except for "East St. Louis Toodle-oo" and "Chain Lightning," which got one vote apiece.

So I have the distinction of being the strongest supporter of the least-liked track of the Steely Dan '70-'80s era. My vote was the lone one for "Chain Lightning."

(Remember, least-liked is not the same as most-disliked.)

SlimAndSlam, can you explain the appeal of Chain Lightning to the rest of us? (I like Chain Lightning but I guess it feels like one of their least essential tracks to me)

oh man i love lunch with gina, sorry lunch with gina

Home At Last
Third World Man
Rikki Don't Lose That Number
Aja
Pretzel Logic
My Old School
Babylon Sisters
Doctor Wu
Deacon Blues
The Boston Rag
Hey Nineteen
Razor Boy
Black Cow
Dirty Work
Peg
Rose Darling
Gaucho
Barrytown
Things I Miss The Most
Parker's Band

xpost it feels so good iirc

oh man i love lunch with gina, sorry lunch with gina

― emo canon in twee major (BradNelson), Sunday, April 6, 2014 9:54 PM (

I usually imagine it as brunch over a crisp white wine

Re: Chain Lightning:

Two reasons:

1. I'm a sucker for variations on the twelve-bar blues, and that song has one of the most off-kilter takes on that particular form.

2. Those harmonies!

Sorry, East St. Louis Toodle-oo, see you in the Duke Ellington poll (if there is one)

Pplains this is hall of fame level work

1. Black Cow
2. Razor Boy
3. King of the World
4. Reelin’ In the Years
5. Rikki Don’t Lose That Number
6. Babylon Sisters
7. Doctor Wu
8. Josie
9. Show Biz Kids
10. Third World Man
11. Rose Darling
12. Aja
13. My Old School
14. Kid Charlemagne
15. Bad Sneakers
16. Peg
17. The Second Arrangement
18. Pretzel Logic
19. The Royal Scam
20. Time out of Mind

1. Peg
2. FM
3. Aja
4. Do It Again
5. Dirty Work
6. Your Gold Teeth II
7. Reelin’ in the Years
8. Pearl of the Quarter
9. Rikki Don’t Lose That Number
10. Deacon Blues
11. Don’t Take Me Alive
12. Time Out of Mind
13. Black Friday
14. Any Major Dude Will Tell You
15. Josie
16. The Fez
17. My Old School
18. Kid Charlemagne
19. Bad Sneakers
20. Everyone’s Gone to the Movies

Favorite discovery of the poll for me was "Your Gold Teeth II" -- if I was making out a ballot today it would probably jump to my #1.

Thanks Bee OK for polling and PPlains for images, both great.

I've never felt closer to ilm

yeah this was fun, my big discovery is "The Boston Rag", how did I miss that in my life?

you gotta bring it on home

Doctor Wu
Any Major Dude
The Caves of Altamira
Mr. Sam
Here at the Western World
Peg
You Got The Bear
The Boston Rag
Rikki Don't Lose That Number
Bad Sneakers
Black Cow
Reelin' In The Years
Pretzel Logic
My Old School
Charlie Freak
Deacon Blues
Time Out of Mind
Green Earrings
Third World Man
Josie

Thanks Bee OK and PPlains

ok pplains fess up: where did you source all the graphics from

My Old School
Kid Charlemagne
Black Cow
Night by Night
Deacon Blues
Home at Last
Pretzel Logic
Doctor Wu
Razor Boy
Bodhisattva
Dirty Work
Any World That I'm Welcome To
Kings
Bad Sneakers
Show Biz Kids
Pearl of the Quarter
Midnight Cruiser
Peg
Do It Again
Rikki Don't Lose That Number

Great poll, still kicking myself for leaving off Josie. It was murder to make this list, but "My Old School" never left the top spot, and it wasn't even close.

Stopped at my very favorites.

1. "Pretzel Logic" (40)
2. "Rikki Don’t Lose That Number" (36)
3. "King of the World" (33)
4. "Reelin’ in the Years" (30)
5. "Dr. Wu" (28)
6. "Midnight Cruiser" (26)
7. "Sign in Stranger" (25)
8. "Dirty Work" (24)
9. "Any World That I’m Welcome To" (23)
10. "Barrytown" (22)

Does Becker write any of the SD lyrics at all? Co-write? I've only ever seen reference to his "sensibility" in the lyrics

1. Kid Charlemagne
2. The Caves of Altamira
3. Babylon Sisters
4. Throw Back the Little Ones
5. FM
6. Josie
7. Pearl of the Quarter
8. Your Gold Teeth II
9. Deacon Blues
10. Green Earrings
11. King of the World
12. Third World Man
13. Any Major Dude Will Tell You
14. Bodhisattva
15. Black Friday
16. Rikki Don't Lose That Number
17. Your Gold Teeth
18. The Royal Scam
19. Through With Buzz
20. Charlie Freak

Dude that played bass on peg deserves a Nobel prize. The fact it's named after someone called Entwistle is hilarious

1. Bodhisattva
2. Midnite Cruiser
3. Reelin' in the Years
4. Kid Charlemange
5. Do It Again
6. Doctor Wu
7. Black Friday
8. My Old School
9. Deacon Blues
10. Any Major Dude Will Tell You
11. Haitian Divorce
12. Babylon Sisters
13. Jack Of Speed
14. Jose
15. Peg
16. Hey 19
17. Everyone's Gone To The Movies
18. FM
19. Fire In The Hole
20. Here In The Western World

been really into jack of speed and this moody bastard

dude who played bass on "peg" is chuck rainey, session man extraordinaire.

Awesome poll, missed the live rollout of the top 5 to watch Wrestlemania with future brother-in-law (sure Fagen and Becker would appreciate that somehow)...anyway, wanted to thank Bee OK for an awesome poll, and pplains, seriously A+ job on the graphics.

Pretty sure my top 3 would be the same if I had voted today but the rest is totally in flux and there are a ton of songs that I kinda felt dumb for excluding, but seriously, best fucking band ever.

My Old School
Razor Boy
Deacon Blues
Show Biz Kids
Third World Man
Any World (That I'm Welcome To)
FM (No Static at All)
Kid Charlemagne
Aja
Bad Sneakers
Gaucho
Home at Last
Peg
Your Gold Teeth II
Doctor Wu
Dirty Work
Glamour Profession
Your Gold Teeth
Everything You Did
Rikki Don't Lose That Number

nice, razor boy @ #2!

I made a feeble attempt to boost "Razor Boy" on the noms thread; was thrilled to see it place as high as it did tbh. Such a beautiful song.

So is someone going to send a link to this thread to Messrs. Fagan and Becker?

Poll 1

1. Deacon Blues
2. Caves Of Altamira
3. Babylon Sisters
4. Night By Night
5. Peg
6. Josie
7. Black Cow
8. Aja
9. Kid Charlemagne
10. Haitian Divorce
11. Pretzel Logic
12. Hey Nineteen
13. Any Major Dude Will Tell You
14. Throw Back The Little Ones
15. FM
16. Bad Sneakers
17. Rikki Don't Lose That Number
18. My Old School
19. Reelin In The Years
20. Do It Again

Poll 2

1. IGY
2. The Nightfly
3. Tomorrow' s Girls
4. Magic Smile (Rosie Zaza)
5. H Gang
6. New Frontier
7. Maxine
8. The Goodbye Look
9. Lazy Nina (Greg Philliganes)
10. Snowbound

Poll 3

1. The Nightfly 
2. The Royal Scam
3. Katy Lied
4. Pretzel Logic
5. Aja
6. Gaucho
7. Countdown To Ecstacy
8. Can't Buy A Thrill

That whole Rosie Vela album is really great!

1. Barrytown
Only a Fool Would Say That
Night by Night
The Caves of Altamira
Deacon Blues
Rikki Don't Lose That Number
Your Gold Teeth II
King of the World
The Boston Rag
Kings
Your Gold Teeth
Third World Man
Bad Sneakers
Rose Darling
Black Cow
My Old School
Here at the Western World
Home at Last
Green Earrings
20. Midnight Cruiser

My ballot would definitely be different if I redid it today but I always knew that would be the case. I should've had 'King of the World' in my top 5, my favourite SD song changes all the time but that's always been a contender.

Big thanks to Bee OK and PPlains, have really enjoyed following this. I think I started reading ILX not too long after I first got into Steely Dan and I've always appreciated how widely-loved they seem to be on here.

Went deep cut heavy

1. Show Biz Kids
2. Monkey In Your Soul
3. King of The World
4. Bodisattva
5. Daddy Don't Live That New York City No More
6. Time Out of Mind
7. The Boston Rag
8. Sign In Stranger
9. Rose Darling
10. Your Gold Teeth
11. FM (No Static At All)
12. Charlie Freak
13. Josie
14. Green Earrings
15. Your Gold Teeth II
16. Turn That Heartbeat Over Again
17. Pearl of The Quarter
18. Everything You Did
19. Home At Last
20. Midnight Cruiser

Albums:

1. Countdown To Ecstacy
2. Katy Lied
3. The Royal Scam
4. Pretzel Logic
5. Aja
6. Can't Buy A Thrill
7. Gaucho

Ups to Bee Ok and PPlains for putting this together and succeeding with this most precious of polls.

yeah, great job guys. very enjoyable rollout

Great work, fellas. Very exciting poll. My ballot:

Green Earrings
Peg
Gaucho
Caves of Altamira
Your Gold Teeth II
Aja
Any Major Dude
Dr. Wu
Glamour Profession
Kid Charlemagne
Razor Boy
Do It Again
Barrytown
Bad Sneakers
Showbiz Kids
Night By Night
Home at Last
Babylon Sisters
The Fez
Everyone's Gone to the Movies

1. Pretzel Logic
2. Charlie Freak
3. Aja
4. Do It Again
5. The Royal Scam
6. Throw Back The Little Ones
7. Only A Fool Would Say That
8. Kid Charlemagne
9. Night By Night
10. Home At Last

11. The Caves Of Altamira
12. East St Louis Toodle-oo
13. Josie
14. Third World Man
15. Deacon Blues
16. Babylon Sisters
17. Black Cow
18. King Of The World
19. Kings
20. My Old School

Aja was the only album I knew well before this poll - I've probably marked its cuts too high, because on listening it turned out to be their poppier and blusier cuts I dug the most. The band's basic perversity sits nicely among very complicated bubblegum.

Enjoyed following this enormously. Thanks to Bee OK. And amazing work, pplains.

Does Becker write any of the SD lyrics at all? Co-write? I've only ever seen reference to his "sensibility" in the lyrics

― Iago Galdston, Sunday, April 6, 2014 10:48 PM (Yesterday) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

it's always been my impression that they collaborate on lyrics. and of the handful of songs that have been anecdotally linked to their own lives, about half of them seem to be about Becker's life, not Fagen's. plus his solo albums maintain the SD sensibility about as much as Fagen's.

Yeah, I spotted the differences when I bought The Nightfly.

Tracks:

My Old School
Time Out Of Mind
Bad Sneakers
Black Cow
Any World (That I’m Welcome To)
Daddy Don’t Live in That New York City No More
Dr. Wu
Haitian Divorce
Show Biz Kids
The Boston Rag
Glamour Profession
Caves of Altamira
Pretzel Logic
FM
Babylon Sisters
Pearl of the Quarter
Peg
Hey Nineteen
Kid Charlemagne
Here at the Western World

Solo Tracks:
Donald Fagen - Morph the Cat
Donald Fagen - I.G.Y.
Donald Fagen - Brite Nitegown
Donald Fagen - H Gang
Donald Fagen - The Nightfly
Donald Fagen - Mary Shut the Garden Door
Donald Fagen - Security Joan
Donald Fagen - New Frontier
Donald Fagen - Slinky Thing
Donald Fagen - The New Breed

i would just like to say "My Old School" is a masterpiece and it tickled me to see so many people flabbergasted that it made it to #2

ok pplains fess up: where did you source all the graphics from

― °ㅇ๐ْ ° (gr8080), Sunday, April 6, 2014 10:38 PM (Yesterday) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

^ this, plz

excellent poll, thanks everyone

The thing about My Old School is that, even if you don't like searing raucous soul songs about love and loss and minor vice, you have to at least acknowledge that Jeff Baxter's fills and solos in this thing are absolutely indomitable.