Polled At Last: STEELY DAN - ILM Artist poll #50

even though i actually voted for it, i was shocked this actually made the overall Top 10.

Aw, that's totally a major dude! ace fucking job, pp.

I'm starting to be either pleased that my #1 made it so high or worried that it didn't make it at all

me too.

there's a fine line, in this poll, between #1 and #61.

nah, no fine lines, the band already snorted them

Squonk: A mythical woodland creature, originating in Pennsylvania. Squonks spend much of their time crying due to their ugliness, and when captured, will dissolve into a puddle of tears. Also the subject of a song on the 1976 Genesis album A Trick of The Tail.

a fine genesis song it is

https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-ZRYQ4e2sPJI/U0G1DUvGpxI/AAAAAAAAAzE/Wl_wvFxWjjI/w640-h320-no/Black+Cow.jpg

8. Black Cow
From: Aja
Released: September 23, 1977
1,117 Points, 45 Votes, 3 Number Ones

uptown baby

so outrageous

love both of these and voted for AMDWTY. My Old School should come next. it's great and all but not really top 5 Dan (or number one CTE)

chain lightning surprise no. 1

high five to the 2 fellow Major Dude For Number 1 fans.

My #1 still has a shot, which is not usually the case.

uptown baby

― °ㅇ๐ْ ° (gr8080), Sunday, April 6, 2014 4:21 PM

i knew about that song when it was on mtv, but never knew about the sample until a few years ago.

will throw a minor fit if "kid charlemagne" is no. 1, but i'm about deacon blues/doctor wu/my old school/babylon sisters taking it

also the horns in the lord tariq and peter gunz song are also in "hips don't lie"

that's my contribution to the thread

xpost

this is one I've never got--too astringent? lyrically kinda meh? who knows, but.....never dug it.

I fear one you haven't mentioned yet, Brad....

didn't vote for it i think this is a great song lyrically. phrasing is exquisite, "surely will screen out the sorrow," "you will stagger homeward to your precious one"

I think our little wild time has just begun

I fear one you haven't mentioned yet, Brad....

oh yeah i guess it's possible that "with a gun" is up there

yeah, the lyrics are great! Had it at #8 myself, but I'm happily surprised to see it in the top 10.

xp there are more possibilities

Hey Nineteen was the last song cut from my ballot. And if I can I'd like to use my "Too low!" card, belatedly, for FM, which I thought would place way higher.

xp he's thinking of East St. Louis Toodle-Oo

I'm saving my "too low" card for my #1, and I will play it if it winds up any lower than #1. (And if I'm at my computer in time to play it.)

Rudy's Bar and Grill, a popular drinking establishment in New York City. Located on 9th Avenue & 44th Street in the heart of the formerly-infamous but now-gentrified "Hell's Kitchen" district of Manhattan. Rudy's is a lively and informal "dive" bar best known for its cheap drinks and free hot dogs, and regarded by many as the perfect place to get legless after work.

Two of mine are left--either could be #1, or not. I really hope the other five aren't Aja/Groucho.

Black Cow: A type of soda. Depending on who you ask, a true black cow consists of either Coke or root beer mixed with either milk or ice cream (with optional chocolate sauce). There's even an alcoholic version, containing Grand Marnier and cold coffee.

xp they can't be. not enough songs left!

"_____" is such a bizarre hit i can't begrudge it placing high or even hitting #1

Okay, that's good. (xp)

i taught myself how to beatmatch using 2 copies of aja by practicing a live loop of the first 8 bars over and over for days

it's great how one can buy 2 pristine copies of these albums for cheap at most record stores.

that is rad as hell gr80

https://lh4.googleusercontent.com/-O6_FD-TXCN0/U0G9CVfdalI/AAAAAAAAAzg/oizL5QN0-KY/w640-h320-no/Babylon+Sisters.jpg

7. Babylon Sisters
From: Gaucho
Released: November 21, 1980
1,129 Points, 44 Votes, 4 Number Ones

TOO LOW

one of my all-time favorite songs.

My #1. Too low. I can't cry anymore.

xp I mean Black Cow not Babylon Sisters

I thought this had a shot at #1.

ilx's absurd overcorrection of Gaucho's traditionally bad rep continues to bug me, but it least y'all got the best song right

of the remaining 6, there's only one mayyyybe two songs that i wouldn't be happy to see at #1

song is the ultimate desultory beach (or pool) party jam in my personal experience

i mean, c'mon:

drink kirschwasser from a shell

Babylon Sisters works so well as the final track on the 'Reelin' In The Years' compilation

Gaucho doesn't have any more of a "traditionally bad rep" than Royal Scam

Gaucho doesn't have any more of a "traditionally bad rep" than Royal Scam

― Euler, Sunday, April 6, 2014 5:09 PM (16 seconds ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

back in the 80s and 90s? no way

too low! (i didn't vote for it)

in my ~1990 red Rolling Stone album guide, Royal Scam gets 3 stars & Gaucho 2 1/2 stars. seemed like both were widely considered the closest to duds in their catalog

xp