POLL YR. IDOLS: The official SONIC YOUTH RESULTS thread!

Just for balance, Total Trash was the only song I particularly liked off of DN for a very long time. I like the way the guitars slowly detune the main riff as the song heads off into noise territory...

Yeah, but that annoying bassline! And then it COMES BACK when the song should have been finished!

http://www.melson.nl/ILM/sypoll/015.jpg
15. Wish Fulfillment
Dirty, 1992
(297 points, 15 votes, 1 #1)

My #2!

The Butch Vig production really lets you soak in the atmospheric churn.

i was starting to wonder if that would show up, it always seemed popular but i wasn't sure.

i guess i should stop waiting for "Purr" :(

TOO LOW! My #1, was kinda hoping against hope it'd make the top 10.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FUMPKmLiTcY

Sadly "Little Jammy Thing" or the demo aren't on YouTube.

xp Wow, that's beautiful!

http://www.melson.nl/ILM/sypoll/014.jpg
14. Rain on Tin
Murray Street, 2002
(313 points, 18 votes, 1 #1)

way way way too fucking high

it's a good song and all, but sheez

Yeah, but that annoying bassline! And then it COMES BACK when the song should have been finished!

― ArchCarrier, Friday, May 17, 2013 4:57 AM (50 minutes ago)

nuh uh, the exhausted comeback is one of the best things abt the song

way way way too fucking high
Yeah, I don't understand it either. I even checked my spreadsheet to see if I hadn't made a mistake.

"rain on tin" = a decent late period sy tune, w/ a mid-song, half-power reminder of what they used to do on the reg without batting an eye

The point though is that the top twenty can boast unexpected entries -- and that's what polls are for, no?

they played "Rain On Tin" more times than any other song written since 1994, and with good reason, it smokes live.

i didn't even LIKE the song when i first bought the album, but the first time seeing it live changed that. and honestly, it would suck if this poll had no 21st century songs in the top 20, and if there was only gonna be one, "Rain On Tin" is a great pick.

http://www.melson.nl/ILM/sypoll/013.jpg
13. Brave Men Run (in My Family)
Bad Moon Rising, 1985
(329 points, 16 votes)

dang, hoped that would be top 10

Seven days and seven nights
I dreamt a sailor's dream at sea
Seven days and seven nights
I dreamt a sailor's dream of me
Seven days and seven nights
The world was made and lost again
Seven days and seven nights
Brave men run
In my family
Brave men run
Into the setting sun
Brave men run
Into captivity
Brave men run
In my family

Brave men run
Away from me

i don't really have anything against "rain on tin". i'd have preferred seeing other late SY songs in the top 20, but mostly i just like venting.

etc otm

whoa, looking through gerhard richter's wikipedia page, this section:

Sonic Youth used a painting of his for the cover art for their album Daydream Nation in 1988. He was a fan of the band and did not charge for the use of his image.[citation needed] The original, over 7 metres (23 ft) square, is now showcased in Sonic Youth's studio in NYC.

!!!

Sounds a bit big. Maybe they mean 7 square metres i.e. 2.65 m x 2.65 m?

http://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m3uu3owfWy1qc8wxqo1_1280.jpg

http://www.melson.nl/ILM/sypoll/012.jpg
12. (I Got a) Catholic Block
Sister, 1987
(342 points, 18 votes)

That's awesome! Didn't vote for it but knew it would do well.

Also, "Hey Joni" and "Pacific Coast Highway" TOO LOW! I don't know man, "Hey Joni" will always be my favorite Lee song, was definitely hoping for a top 10 for it. And "PCH" is great in any context, live and on record. Love the steamrolling bass that stops and starts. Just a great, unique sounding song, and then that breakdown ....

Big takeaway from my time spent with Sister for the rollout is that Lee just kills that whole record guitar-wise ("Pipeline" is great, but its his only song of course). So many great moments on that record, just super cool playing all over it.

the blood-curdling scream towards the end of "Catholic Block" is one of the great moments in SY's discography. who is that, Kim?

Some friends of mine are in a band and they have this song that - when they do it live - reminds me a lot of 'Catholic Block'. The thing is I'm 99% sure that they don't own a single Sonic Youth album between them.

Hey Nick, if you had waited just a few minutes with that awesome Richter picture...
http://www.melson.nl/ILM/sypoll/011.jpg
11. Candle
Daydream Nation, 1988
(375 points, 18 votes, 2 #1)

Rain on Tin needs more defenders, that shit is perfect

'Candle' was so close to being my #1.

It was mine!

i'm the cocker on the rock!

http://www.boomerpdx.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/Joe+Cocker++Dance1.jpg

I should've voted for "Brave Men..."

whoa, looking through gerhard richter's wikipedia page, this section:

Sonic Youth used a painting of his for the cover art for their album Daydream Nation in 1988. He was a fan of the band and did not charge for the use of his image.[citation needed] The original, over 7 metres (23 ft) square, is now showcased in Sonic Youth's studio in NYC.
!!!

― your holiness, we have an official energy drink (Z S), Friday, May 17, 2013 6:28 AM (1 hour ago)

I forgot who was questioning the wealth of Sonic Youth but that one painting alone may be worth 8 figures fwiw.

"Candle" strikes me as the sort of tune that most other bands would have played acoustically.

xpost

it's unclear (at least from that wiki) whether or not they own the painting or if it's just on extended loan from richter, though. but yeah, i assume if it was sold it would easily get 10 million+.

I love "Candle" within the context of the album, but somehow it suffers in comparison when I single out the songs for something like this. It was a late cut, but I just couldn't consider it over the other songs from DN that made my ballot. I get that comment about it leaning towards acoustic territory, it really is unique in feel on the record for me, the only song that doesn't seem to be trying very hard to be much more than a good song, which it assuredly is.

Also, glad that "Brave Men Run" placed pretty high (was my #11), such a great opening to that album. The transition from the intro into the song proper is just crucial SY to me, gets me excited for the record every time.

If people haven't heard it, "Brave Men Run" on the Smart Bar live disc is amazing.

always thought "candle" was a relatively boring song. good, but no standout.

me too, but then again Daydream Nation has never been a favorite. I only voted for one song off of it.

^yeah I kind of agree with this, jagged main riff notwithstanding

Apologize, making up for missing the early part of this phase of the run down. Great run of songs, even the ones I didn't vote for I felt bad about cutting (was sure they would crack the top 25 though).

In regards to this: Rain on Tin needs more defenders, that shit is perfect

I completely agree, was my #4. I have lobbied for it plenty, but will add a few thoughts. In particular, I totally get this sentiment:

"rain on tin" = a decent late period sy tune, w/ a mid-song, half-power reminder of what they used to do on the reg without batting an eye

But I also disagree. Not trying to single out Contenderizer at all, I would think that there are a lot of folks who agree with him, but to me there is nothing half-power or "decent" about it. I find it to be an example of a band operating on a supremely high level, and indeed one they would not have been likely to achieve without all of the experimentation they went through from EJSTNS to NYCG&F. I see it as the culmination of an extremely fertile period (with a lot of lows counterbalancing the highs) but the payoff is essentially a song like "Rain On Tin". To me it is joyous, surprising (well, especially the first time I heard it), really well crafted, and pretty singular in their catalogue as it existed up to that point. It is so comfortable in its own skin, which maybe doesn't sit so well with some folks, but the craft and ease with which they pull it off in no way diminishes the forward momentum and, to me, totally crushing group dynamics within the song/performance. I guess it just changed my perception of what kind of excitement SY could give me forever, and made me reexamine and appreciate those albums that preceded and of course those that directly followed it largely cause of its mightiness. Lastly, it just really set me down the road of thinking that there may never be a band like Sonic Youth again, and perhaps they are utterly singular even now, in regards to maintaining a quality and consistency to their catalogue over as long a stretch of time as they have. They never stopped putting out records that didn't suck (in my opinion of course, but at this point I at least like to love every damn one of them) for pretty much 30 years, which is truly just nuts.

Btw I was the #1 vote for "Rain On Tin"

The follow-up to that last thought is that "Rain On Tin" wasn't just a last gasp at being great, I think each album after Murray Street has some great shit on it too, certainly great for a bunch of folks well into their 40s and 50s who never really stopped putting out records. "Rain On Tin" was just the tipping point that got me thinking that they may just keep rolling along forever making good to great records that I wouldn't be able to ignore. Sad to be honest that that may not be the case.

http://www.melson.nl/ILM/sypoll/010.jpg
10. Theresa's Sound-World
Dirty, 1992
(378 points, 20 votes)