TOP 10 NOW: \/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\shawty got poll poll poll poll poll poll poll (part II: 2008 ALBUMS)/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/

plus, shit that will (and should) make it:

Erykah Badu
Gang Gang Dance
No Age
Portishead
TV on the Radio
Vampire Weekend
Lil Wayne

except gang gang dance. grime thing should make tracks, but album is colossal meh. will make it anyway, due to siouxie <3.

shit that will NOT make it:

james blackshaw
harvey milk
nobunny
:(

plus anyone who has listened to the bug for more than month should know that shit is HELLA BORING. poison dart notwithstanding. another one for trx only. shame on you, ILM.

It's not hard to define electrodribble. The Postal Service album was the originator of the movement, though some music it would apply to came before that. Nevertheless, The Postal Service can be made responsible for the musical zeitgeist that occurred in its wake.

And if that's not definition enough, without naming specific offenders, I don't know if I can make it any clearer.

dr. fever, layin it down str8

happy valentines!

grime thing should make tracks, but album is colossal meh.

so wrong. "princes" is good, but it's like my 7th-favorite track. you know what's great about that album (among other things), is the drummer. great drummer.

agree about the drummer, but most of the tracks remain more interesting than deeply compelling to me. i mean good, solid, intriging, but not quite great. but when mr. tinchy starts talking it's like a sudden transmission from a different, far better planet/record. the disjunction is just too massive and too awesome to ignore. good band, GREAT song.

"colossal meh" was some bullshit. i've had drinks. it's a good record.

happy valentines (again), tomorrow calls...

Lil Wayne

Duh, I meant to include him.

ILM top ten for 2009, my projected order:

10 Lindstrøm
9 Air France
8 Gang Gang Dance
7 Cut Copy
6 TV on the Radio
5 Vampire Weekend
4 Hercules and Love Affair
3 Lil Wayne
2 Erykah Badu
1 Portishead

I am 100% confident in the artists, not sure at all about the placement order.

Thoughts?

The order of the top 3 is probably right, the rest is up in the air. You're right about the artists, though.

Looks about right. Musically did mention something about suprises in placement order, though.

10 Lindstrøm
9 Air France
8 Gang Gang Dance
7 Cut Copy
6 TV on the Radio
5 Vampire Weekend
4 Hercules and Love Affair
3 Lil Wayne
2 Erykah Badu
1 Portishead

this would basically look like every other list i've seen this year. based on 50-11, i wouldnt doubt a couple curveballs are going to be thrown in there

The only one I think doesn't have a 100% chance of making it is Lindstrøm... but that's a stretch.

i wanna say air frince just because it's an EP, but two of its tracks placed and a lot of people liked it

doubts about lindstrom & air france. rest seem safe. cut copy?

shower running, can't stay away...

Air France, maybe not. The fact that Lindstrøm didn't place lower may guarantee it's in the top 10, though.

Unless everyone voted for it 20 out of 20 and it got a bunch of 1-point nods.

I just want to say again... But since it can't be adequately defined, it just becomes a big stick with which we can all merrily beat some unsuspecting (and often undeserving) artist. I mean, had it been a term back then, would somebody have used it to disparage Kraftwerk... or Tubeway Army... or Bronski Beat... or New Order? I just don't get it. Ridiculing electro sounds in pop/rock seems like a really pointless (and frankly weird) dead-end street to go down.

I mean, the edges keep creeping outward and the next thing you know, SOMETHING YOU HOLD DEAR is now... gasp... electrodribble. It's kind of dumb, really, isn't it?

Anyway, let's hope Vampire Weekend don't make the top 10, I think we can all agree on that.

Or TVotR, for that matter.

I love the VW record, so I don't agree.

I voted Lindstrom as my number one and i bet i wasn't the only one. >_<

can I say I don't get people who only lik3e"Poison Dart"? one of the most boring tracks on the album! wtf

man fuck a hater I hope Vampire Weekend and TVotR make the top ten

the upbeat afrofunk joints on the new tvotr are the only good things they have done imo

fuck yall btw

like i said it's the cognitive dissonance that intrigues me, like, i'm listening and thinking 'i have every reason in the world to hate this song" and i cant bring myself to it. pretty powerful thing imo

this happens a lot w/kanye! though not with 'robocop' for me, that shit sucks. i mean seriously, ROBOCOP? how the hell did that simile make it past the editing process? and the "spoilt little LA girl" chant is definitely the nadir of something or other.

If someone called me a Robocop as we were on the verge of breaking up that would be the dealbreaker

brainwasher otm. i get that i'm not supposed to sympathise w/kanye, that the bitterness is part and parcel of his whole experience, and i'm down with that on most of the songs, but the problem with the 'robocop' lyric isn't so much that dude is being a dick as dude is being retarded and using 12-year-old schoolboy similes.

i didn't vote for it b/c there's no way it's one of the 20 best albums of the year but i'm glad it placed where it did - absolutely love 'welcome to heartbreak' (which is where the cog. dissonance that kevin talked about really works - yeah it's a spoiled multimillionaire whining about his luxurious life but he definitely captures the gilded-cage isolation of it - plus that synth line is just gorgeous), and 'heartless' works surprisingly well in a radio context, like hearing it in a clothes shop and stuff. also i like 'see you in my nightmares' a lot, may as well admit that in the middle of this long-ass paragraph where no one will see. apart from the "mrs PU" line obv! why can kanye and wayne not self-edit those moments. no wonder trina dumped his ass. trina and alexis need to get together and work on a single ladies clothing line or something. you just know they're more fun to hang with.

(also poor "Pinocchio Story", what a load of balls)

weirdest thing was that apparently this endlessly terrible thing was included on 808s at beyoncé's insistence o_0

anyway i am SO PLEASED that the recession placed higher than 808s. jordan's write-up was completely otm - "pitch perfect" sums it up really. hip-hop album of the year no contest for me, it's just got everything - clever lines, dumb lines (like ign'ant good dumb, not kanye retarded dumb), that zeitgeisty topical feel (without being too self-conscious or heavy-handed), moodiness and triumphalism and a ton of hooks.

also really pleased about the bug, though i'd thought it might make the top 10. so yeah overall i <3 the 20-11 section, the poll's really coming alive, good work to all, and maybe vampire weekend will miss out altogether, the audacity of hope and change and all that.

drunk rev! <3

man the prob w robocop isnt the lyrics but htat it sounds like some soul calibur 2 or final fantasy tactics bullsh

haha drunk rev <3 is right

10 Lindstrøm
9 Air France
8 Gang Gang Dance
7 Cut Copy
6 TV on the Radio
5 Vampire Weekend
4 Hercules and Love Affair
3 Lil Wayne
2 Erykah Badu
1 Portishead

too hungover to think of anything else which might/should make it - guess i can stop holding out for mariah, trus'me and jazmine now - but 20-11 will easily be the best section of the list in that case.

lex get on aim u muthafuka hit me up "reverenddollars"

#11 is kinda perfect 4 the bug tho

Haha I love how this has thread has become everyone sending hearts and congratulating one another on a job well done, interspersed with LJ frothing in indignation.

No T.I. then?

:-/

never really connected with the Paper Trails hype

tha carter iii would be a kickass #1 btw. prob not gonna happen tho right?

1. Erykah Badu
2. Portishead
3. Lil Wayne

stuff this poll to the gills with all the electrodribble you want; but if that's the top 3 it'll be the greatest poll ever!

So this Portishead album is good then yeah?

that edge-of-the-world beat really works for him - also added oomph from ye dropping the track before his verse comes in

yeah i love that moment, w/the howling wolves in the background and shit - it's like the inverse of that episodic pause before kanye's verse on 'put on'

EYES SO LOW YEAH I LOOK LIKE AN ASIAN

favourite hip-hop line in this vein will always & 4eva be "i wanna nigga that'll grab the weave and turn my eyes chinese"

It's good. It's way overhyped. It'd be a decent winner, given what else is apparently left.

Anyway, after that little interjection, I have sport to be watching. Adios.

i think lj might like the erykah badu album?

Lex, I solemnly promise you I will give it every chance :)

in my expereince, the badu album breaks down like this:

songs 2-4 are the most immediate winners, esp. 'the healer'
songs 5-7 take a little more time, but persevere; once they click the rest of the album falls into place.

don't know ab tthe portishead album...but me putting it at #2 was concessions; from all talk, it pretty much is surefire #1

I dunno, it took me a long time to *get* Erykah Badu. It involved waking up during a looong bus journey with The Other Side of the Game having come on shuffle on my mp3.

Just put on Portishead, from first 30seconds this is already better than I thought it would be. A lot better.

i think the portishead album is a really impressive piece of work but i never got as into it as i expected (they were my favourite group when i was a teenager) - i admire it from afar rather than loving it, so i didn't vote for it.