Savages

I fucking love the album (shocker)

The only record store near my job is Best Buy and they don't have it.

Predictable comment from Turrican coming up...

...I love this band, and this album :)

I love this record.

not great, better than good

re: comparisons to garage rock, etc.

garage rock is boring and useless when it's overly reverent or studied. it's boring when the music and sensibility don't bring anything new to the table. you can get by on sheer energy, but that's gonna limit your appeal to die-hard fans of the style you're copping.

retro garage rock bands catch the same shit that savages do. retread, played out, no tunes, etc.

I love the way that 'I Am Here' speeds up towards the end... a la 'Sin In My Heart' by The Banshees.

By the way, I love that whenever a new band of this ilk comes out, people are always quick to shout "Joy Division!!!"... yeah, because Joy Division were the only post-punk band. Yeah.

Anyway, I was obviously going to like this band/album. Everything about 'em seems to be a musical wet dream to me.

not got it yet, but flicking through a random pile of skinny promos in the archive today i found that i have had the first 'john and jehn' in the pile left unloved.

ok 4 tracks in - now i know why john stopped singing ...

anyone hear jennie beth's earlier band?

oh ha

One listen in and the whole thing doesn't knock me out like "Husbands" did as a standalone single last year. The album does feel curiously backloaded, too: "She Will," "No Face," "Husbands" and "Marshal Dear" are the definite standout tracks, for me. But yeah, still too early to know what I'm gonna end up thinking about it.

I'm on my third listen now... still loving it :D

By the way, I love that whenever a new band of this ilk comes out, people are always quick to shout "Joy Division!!!"... yeah, because Joy Division were the only post-punk band. Yeah.

I share your love of this phenomenon, but it's not a new thing. The Wake, Section 25 and other "new miserablists" got labelled JD copycats back in the day as well.

I bought the LP on my lunch break and am midway through Side 1's maiden voyage - I managed to hold off streaming it beforehand. So far so good, but I will defer judgement for a few plays. The pressing sounds really good though - I wonder who Matador uses? Modern pressings often leave me un...erm, impressed with loads of surface noise etc., but this is pretty quiet (besides the music).

It would not have occurred to me to liken this to Joy Division.

Shut UP is a phenomenal song, I love it when the reverbed guitar comes in. Very John Mcgeoch

Music sounds great. I thought all the little gifs of them in the pitchfork article on them were super cheesy though.

Yeah, they aren't the most original ever. Still they're definitely good, probably the first new rock album that I've been fairly excited about in a while.

this is really shaping up to be a phenomenal year for music

― Call me at **BITCOIN (DJP), Wednesday, May 1, 2013 1:42 PM (6 days ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

^ Completely agree with this... and the best thing is, we're not even halfway through the year yet so there may still some really really great stuff to come!

When you rip off the bass line from "Colony", people will compare you to Joy Division!

just the singer's look and dance moves and all those black and white live clips on youtube with the band all in dark uniforms made me think of JD.

they are obviously just stealing their sound wholesale from modern eon.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WbEX2NwPdsE

just kidding. (modern eon one of my fave 1981 JD rips though)

there is a part of one savages song that reminds me of The Sound. the band. can't remember which one though.

they don't sound nearly as morose or gothy as joy division though. they are more on the punk end of the post punk spectrum, i think: a lot of headstrong energy, the manifesto "turn off your cellphones" element that pitchfork made such a big deal out of... i think i like it.

they are more on the german end of post punk.

what are the german bands they sound like? that sounds cool.

"no face" sounds like something jay reatard would have written (closing the garage rock loop)

not saying they're copping his style. i imagined a blood visions version of it last time through. was p cool.

i listened the record a couple days ago. they remind me of erase errata!

going to dive in, will report back. the one song i have heard is wonderful in a Yeah Yeah Yeahs way.

do you guys like soft kill?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DMNGShVrDDM

Another view:

http://www.collapseboard.com/reviews/albums-reviews/savages-silence-yourself-pop-noirematador/

i am slightly baffled that this reasonably middling album is getting the hype that it is. it's alright but other than 'husbands' it's not especially moving for me. and joy division isn't exactly the first (or tenth) thing i'm hearing..

Listened all the way through yesterday - they strike me as one of those bands who will make an amazing second or third album but at the moment there's just something missing. They get a long way on sheer energy and at least they sound like they give a a shit but I'm not hearing much of THEM in it really.

Scott Creney might be the worst music writer in the entire world circa 2013

Tamsin calls it MAMOR — Middle-Aged-Man-Oriented-Rock. She’s a sharp one, that Tamsin.

exquisite combination of gender puppetry and "this ain't for you, gurls" rhetoric trying to pass itself off as a 'pro-woman' statement. hard not to tip the hat tbh

is it weird to prefer "Marshall Dear" to almost anything else?

I dunno but it's my favourite too

why do they look so moody in press photos

Jim DeRo ogling them

i did not enjoy this album much at all. the second-hand poses didn't bother me, the total lack of personality was what dulled it to me. erase errata is a v on-point comparison

i don't know if this is about me getting old or something but moody press photos are so silly to me now

i'm not asking that all bands make funny faces and clown for the camera

and being in front of a camera is awkward and out of that awkwardness come things that people wouldn't ordinarily do

so i should give them a pass

but part of me feels like, 'you guys make music, it's not all that grave'

fwiw this isn't the whole sexist 'give me a smile, honey' thing. i feel this way whenever i see a photo of the cure. lighten up, bros.

but i guess young people are often very self-serious (sometimes old people too)

the music is ok.

lolling at the idea that '80s revivalists are somehow these poor maligned underdogs. pretty much everything that pitchfork has liked for the past couple of years sounds completely '80s.

No one is an underdog on Jools Holland.

I don't know if I like this or not yet, but has anyone felt that the vocals sounded somewhat Geddy Lee at times? Kept thinking that, and thinking that it probably wasn't what they were trying for.

it just occurred to me i have no idea what geddy lee sounds like

this is probably still my fave 80's-evocative thing I've heard lately. rudi rockist posted it on ilm a couple of months ago. so cool.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QSWRgx8dATg

but has anyone felt that the vocals sounded somewhat Geddy Lee at times?

definitely