We Become Panoramic - THE KATE BUSH RESULTS THREAD (ilm artist poll #24)

hahaha, thanks mothers of the disappeared!

It's pretty sweet watching a deep cut take off as the ballots roll in - this placed on a straight run of ten consecutive ballots in the middle.

am glad that The Dreaming made it in full, of all the albums it deserves it most i think even tho it's not the era i go back to most at the moment

most of my favorite kate bush songs are horror movies, so this one had to make my list

I haven't been on all the polls, but it's the first time I can recall a whole album placing

I thought this happened with several of the Neil Young albums...?

The mule part gets all the attention -- understandably -- but the whole song is wonderfully psycho. I am the concierge chez-moi, OH-nee...

and we all indirectly have stephen king to thank for it

http://img253.imageshack.us/img253/3702/0005wutheringheights.jpg

5. Wuthering Heights
617 points, twenty-two votes, three no.1s
The Kick Inside (1978) (two votes for The Whole Story (1986))
debut performance

I voted for "Blow Away (for Bill) " as well : (

Surprised some of the stronger cuts from "Aerial"'s first side haven't made it in: "Pi", "Mrs. Bartolozzi"... (though I voted for neither. Would've done "Pi" if I had a choice.)

I haven't been on all the polls, but it's the first time I can recall a whole album placing

I thought this happened with several of the Neil Young albums...?

I don't think any of the Neil albums placed in full, but I'm pretty sure all of Innervisions placed in the Stevie poll.

I didn't vote in this poll, but this would have been my #1. Absolutely blew my mind when I first saw it on TV.

up there with the best debut singles of all time. thought it would place one or two higher though, but i can guess what beat it.

i'm getting a bit giddy that my number 1 might be the overall number 1 now, don't think it's ever happened on an ilm poll before.

came low in my poll and maybe shdn't've been there at all, or shd've been much higher, i dunno, i think i voted from "importance" slightly which is totally against my usual method. but it's unquestionably spectacular no matter what my relationship is to it on any one day

some of my absolute faves are not gonna make it

neither of my top 2 has placed yet

My intro to "Wuthering Heights" was the '86 version. Is it ok if I prefer it?

up there with the best debut singles of all time. thought it would place one or two higher though, but i can guess what beat it.

― Jamie_ATP, Wednesday, 29 August 2012 7:42 PM (29 seconds ago)

Yeah. I think I underrated this on my ballot as I figured it was a lock for the top three; love Tom's writeup on it for Popular:
http://freakytrigger.co.uk/ft/2008/07/kate-bush-wuthering-heights/

I was one of the #1 votes for "Nocturn" - everything I'd loved about Kate Bush ~The Ninth Wave with added balearic majesty; I think it was Tim in the OG Aerial thread that mentioned Talk Talk/Bark Psychosis/"Halcyon+On+On"/"Under The Sun" as reference points. I wish I'd had the chance to hear it at the end of some kind of Studio DJ set as the sun was rising.

we aren't here to judge

i'm really looking fwd to individual ballots, the order of some of this list has really surprised me (eg "suspended in gaffa" and "pull out the pin" respectively)

well, I am

For a horrible second I thought you posted 'will.i.am'

what poll you good people

As in, "good news, new KB album, bad news, produced by will.i.am"

I wish I'd had the chance to hear it at the end of some kind of Studio DJ set as the sun was rising.

you've just reminded me of that wonderful ewan pearson '...and so to bed' mix where he finishes with it, must dig that out.

ooh, link to that please

I wish I'd had the chance to hear it at the end of some kind of Studio DJ set as the sun was rising

I once saw Balearic Mike start off a boat party set with 'Nocturne', just as we started moving along the coast. It was a glorious moment.

xp i think i've got it on a cd somewhere, it's from several laptops ago. if i can find it, i will.

http://www.mixcloud.com/allezallez/048-and-so-to-bed-mix-by-ewan-pearson/

thanks

shd've withheld that until all the results were posted ;-)

ha!

http://img543.imageshack.us/img543/6862/swork.jpg

4. This Woman’s Work
663 points, twenty-six votes, four no.1s
The Sensual World (1989)
video

TOO LOW

Bum. My number 1, which I can't listen to without shedding a tear.

there goes my number 1

i know you have a little life in you yet cue uncontrollable weepiness

ha i typed that before i saw Boksen's post <3

the last time I listened to this song I was rushing to pick up my kid from preschool while my wife was having a miscarriage in the hospital and I cried like a fucking little girl. and now I will always associate this song with that moment.

"this woman's work" might be The Most Moving Song Ever

oh Shakey

Tremendously moving. She really tapped into something when she created this song. Love the Director's Cut version of this as well. Voted for that one.

toyed with voting Director's Cut versions of this and "Deeper Understanding" but in the end i didn't specify cos it seemed too challopian

This blew up recently due to some film or something iirc? It was a lot harder to find nice clips to choose from

Six albums already represented in the top 10, that's a wider spread than I would have expected. (Tho I'm guessing none of my Red Shoes faves are in the top 3.)

Yeah. I think I underrated this [Wuthering Heights] on my ballot as I figured it was a lock for the top three

i figured it would be much more drastically underrated, pleased to see it finish so high

The vastly underrated Lionheart is still going to be vastly underratted, isn't it?

Kinda wondering if the top three is all gonna be from side one of Hounds of Love.

amazing how TWW was written *specifically for* She's Having A Baby and directly inspired by the script! something else to thank John Hughes for.

was it?! that's remarkable. add me to those who can't listen to it without welling up a little.

aye. from NME: "It was written for John Hughes' film She's Having A Baby. Really light comedy about this young guy who gets married, very much a kid. His wife is pregnant and it's alright until they get to the hospital and the baby's in the breach position.
That's the sequence I have to write the songs about and it's really very moving, him in the waiting room, having flashbacks of his wife and him going for walks, decoration... It's exploring his sadness and guilt, suddenly it's the point where he has to grow up. He'd been such a wally up to this point."

still blows my mind!