MAD POLL, LOST YER WAY – ILM Artist Poll #16 – The Rolling Stones RESULTS THREAD

side 2 is killer, as I hope we'll have time to discuss on the songs thread

side 1 pretty ace too except for "My Girl", which isn't a horror at least

uggghhh

fuck I am a moron, I didn't vote for an album!

bleh

Little Red Rooster was muzak in a shop I was in yesterday. Kind of an odd choice.

can't believe I didn't vote for Flowers! but then, Beggars Banquet (or Exile?) was my number five. not much room in the top 5.

42 ballots

number 10 has only 2 votes?

Uh yeah, that sounds a bit wrong. That makes 210 votes if everyone did a full ballot - either there's massive consensus on the top five, or there's no consensus at all.

what are the odds of Freejack placing in the comedy films poll?

A rarely appreciated element of Freejack is that Mick Jagger AND David Johansen are in the film.

Never heard Flowers but know most of the songs from the UK versions of Between the Buttons and Aftermath. So many Stones compilations...

That #10 ballot result doesn't sound too crazy to me. Led Zeppelin #10 was

10. How the West Was Won - 20 points (5 votes, 1 first-place vote)

and that was with only 13 albums to choose from.

one of its best songs, "Ride On, Baby", wasn't on either, so Flowers is essential.

Flowers > Between The Buttons

Also, I was the other voter for Flowers, yay!

Mick on Between the Buttons: "(That album) I never really liked. (Back Street Girl)'s the only decent song. The rest of it is more or less rubbish."

Mick hates an awful lot of good Stones stuff

I'm not sure I trust his judgement, lol

Yeah I should probably work out which songs I'm missing and d/l them from somewhere. I just get confused by the early discography (xposts).

why are US grab bags like Flowers eligible for the albums poll?

WWII

The same reason The Pink Opaque will be (should be) eligible for the Cocteau Twins poll. It's a solid album that half of the electorate is really familiar with.

I was gonna say Allen Klein's ghost, but I like buzza's explanation better.

why are US grab bags like Flowers eligible for the albums poll?

― Iago Galdston, Monday, April 2, 2012 1:27 PM (6 minutes ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

because they are albums

Flowers also only got two votes, can't imagine we'll have a bunch of people going "YAY HOT ROCKS!"

Now watch as "Midnight Rambler (Live)" fans prove me wrong.

Aftermath (US version)+ Between the Buttons (UK version) + Flowers = best music ever

my favorite, at least

I think there were higher highs before and (esp) after that period, but yeah, that's my favorite Stones era for consistency.

multiple x-post: "Indian Girl" rhymes "larder" with "raped her". No defense is possible.

hahah

At this rate we can stretch the results out until August ;)

I listened to Flowers again. Like it better than Between the Buttons for sure.

One of the very first albums I ever pilfered from my parents' pile in our basement rec room. That copy is long gone, although I did replace it at some point.

I listened to Flowers again. Like it better than Between the Buttons for sure.

hybrid of the UK and US versions of between the buttons is better than flowers sez i

9. Tattoo You - 11 points (5 votes, no #1 votes)

http://i40.tinypic.com/2a62luu.jpg

1. Start Me Up
2. Hang Fire
3. Slave
4. Little T&A
5. Black Limousine
6. Neighbours

7. Worried About You
8. Tops
9. Heaven
10. No Use in Crying
11. Waiting on a Friend

:/

No shame! It's a solid fucking album.

ya who! is my "2nd favorite". the sincerest form of trolling.

trollery

and for the older contributors I can understand why it means more than, say, Aftermath.

"ya who" ?

I love "Hang Fire" & "Heaven", & enjoyed listening through the whole album for this poll, a lot more than I remember enjoying it. It's one of my better rediscoveries for this poll (I hope the other will place higher.)

you know what else is solid...

Still don't care for "Slave" or "No Use in Crying," but "Little T&A" is yet another example of how Keith redeems execrable sexism with courtly growls (and how their rhythm section can enliven anything with a slight tempo change).

7 or 8 great songs on tattoo you. i mean, they were basically cherry-picking the best of their unreleased shit, had a clear vision and sympathetic production. much better than its rep suggests.

Still don't care for "Slave" or "No Use in Crying,"

for shame, those are maybe the best songs on the album.

to be a kid in the early eighties and digging albums as solid a Some Girls, Emotional Rescue, Tattoo You. Stronger than the previous three.

damn near had 3 songs from it on my ballot, first stones album i can really remember in a contemporary sense.

alfred and balls otm

xxpost THERE'S NOTHING WRONG WITH GOAT'S HEAD SOUP, you terrible man

"balls otm"

^ can't stress this enough

xp: yeah, alfred notm abt goats head soup, but i feel i've made that point with sufficient vigor elsewhere

he will laugh on the other side of his 80's face when Winter and Star Star poll highly in the results.