How good is 'American Boy' by Estelle?

Most of this album is great; I never came around to this track, tho.

I'm not even that into this song but I'm gonna be so depressed if it loses to Tyga in this silly poll: http://idolator.com/396653/your-summer-jam-tournament-update-voters-sure-like-shaking-their-coconuts

this album is pretty good if you take "American Boy" off of it

reread this thread and figured out the missing ingredient in the drifter/sensual seduction/i'm so high stuff is freestyle

this song has been in my head all morning

this album is pretty good if you take "American Boy" off of it

-- The Reverend, Thursday, July 31, 2008 7:13 AM (2 weeks ago)

"come over," "in the rain," "back in love," "pretty please (love me)" (!!!).. if she could sing a bit better i'd like the album even more. really good stuff.

The way Kanye says rrrrubbish with enormous quotey fingers and a hueg wink makes me so fucking angry every time.

-- Whiney G. Weingarten, Sunday, June 15, 2008 6:41 PM (1 month ago) Bookmark Link

Uh, there's a half dozen examples of Brit idiom here; why get mad at this one?

This song triggers some really hard realizations for me, In a lot of ways I see myself as that American boy.

so basically you're saying that whiney's opinion is rrrrubbish

Basically, yeah. I think Kanye's really funny and quotable on this track.

Like Mike at his baddest
Like the Pips at they Gladys

This song triggers some really hard realizations for me, In a lot of ways I see myself as that American boy.

-- If Timi Yuro would be still alive, most other singers could shut up,

lolz

Thanks, Brainwasher. Been tryin' to get that to catch.

this is one of those songs where ppl seem like they're trying real hard to come up w/ arbitrary-ass reasons to dislike it, aka 'some dude' disease

This, "YAHHH" or however the fuck you spell it and "Let the Beat Build" are my favorite songs this year. That's. It.

my arbitrary reason is that I wish I was listening to almost anything else when I hear it

Awww.

sorry dude, but I really fucking hate this shit

it makes me cuss

I see!

I do like all the other songs on her album tho!

haha the song being dumb (as in, it makes estelle seem dumb and childish) and annoying are arbitrary-ass reasons deej

it makes me proud to be an american boy

i get a halfy when she says "i'm gonna like whats underneath them"

also kanye on that song

what's your unarbitrary reasons for liking it

I get a cringe at said line. So clunky and unsexy. Missy would have handled that so much better. xp

Speaking as a well-known Kanye fanboy, this is the most annoying Kanye's ever been.

Yr a fanboy?

id consider myself a kanye fanboy but i really wish he'd gtfo of this song

http://www.jasonbarbacovi.com/images/fan_man_2_s.JPG

not a fanboy, not yet a fan_man

kanye is both funny great ("rrruuubbish") and funny awful ("before he speak his suit bespoke") on this

"tell 'em wha gwaan blud!" is the best pop moment of 08

"rrrruuubbbbish" and "ca-ah-assh" nearly ruin this but don't.

the cash line is the best bit of kanye's rap, it's reassuring and conspiratorial

this is one of those songs where ppl seem like they're trying real hard to come up w/ arbitrary-ass reasons to dislike it, aka 'some dude' disease

-- deej, Thursday, August 14, 2008 4:09 AM (4 hours ago) Bookmark Link

lol i was going to argue with this until I remembered that my biggest criticism of "American Boy" is that it reminds of the theme from Green Acres.

apple + f reveals that deej has yet to give a reason at to why he like this song

egchk my 9 am sentence construction and spelling are worse than normal

we do have this though

---

kanye sounds sad :(

-- deej, Friday, March 28, 2008 2:51 PM (4 months ago) Bookmark Link

he's a lot bloody happier on this than he is on 'put on' or like half of graduation

i don't mind this song so much but when it's high up on all the year-end lists i'm gonna whine and grumble. and possibly harrumph.

how does kanye sound sad!? is this one of those things where people hear every song since his mom died as being about that or affected by that even if his verse might've been recorded before that ever happened?

if you hate this song u hate fun sorry

Estelle needs to stfu with all this "When American rappers say that the UK can't be ghetto, I take them to HOLLOWAY ROAD" shit as well.

^^dont know what this means; dont care ♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♪♪♫

this song isn't remotely fun

Estelle needs to stfu with all this "When American rappers say that the UK can't be ghetto, I take them to HOLLOWAY ROAD" shit as well

Perhaps she took 50 Cent to the Swimmer for some seared duck breast and quails egg salad.

^^dont know what this means; dont care ♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♫♪♪♪♫

-- gr8080, Thursday, August 14, 2008 8:37 AM (2 hours ago) Bookmark Link

xp :(

this song isn't remotely fun

challopian boy

It's the number one challopian sound
Yeah, Estelle we about to get down