Leonard Cohen: Classic or Dud

Oh, CLASSIC btw, especially the first decade or so.

Suzanne is exempt from this, though. It's always great.

my fave is typically whatever i'm listening to at the point but i tend to listen to "love and hate" and "new skin" most of all

The lyrics to Avalanche are sheer genius. Ditto fer Dress Rehearsal Rag, Susanne, Lady Midnight and Story Of Isaasc. He totally fuckin' rocks dude.

Also other great songwriters seem pretty inconcise or repetitive compared to Lenny the Great.

The arrangements are good to. The eighties stuff is kinda weird. Although Tower of Song has a nice production effect. At least he didn't go techno.

-- Leonard Cohen, Rolling Stone interview 2003.

all-time classic, no doubt.

The ladyfriend is watching The Backwoods on TV now, which features a number of songs by Leonard (also features Gary Oldman...).

Got me back in the mood for him again.

I had the honor of interviewing him many years ago and what stuck out beyond his modesty was how when I transcribed the tape it read like third draft English. He spoke so eloquently and with a natural poetry. It didn't feel like a put on. He wasn't trying to be something or putting on airs (is that the right use of that word?). He was generous and really made it hard for me to interview a 20-something year old hipster after that without thinking, "listen, dude, you can't be giving me this much attitude if a man of LC's accomplishment can treat people with greater respect."

jazz police amazing

I had the honor of interviewing him many years ago and what stuck out beyond his modesty was how when I transcribed the tape it read like third draft English. He spoke so eloquently and with a natural poetry.

When I see questions like this I always think of the Steve Wright gag: 'I got a tape for my car, Best of Music. I only like the first side.'
Is there really anyone out there for whom Len is on side 2 of that tape?

he just played a 3 1/2 hour show, pretty epic

Love his music but it always bums me out when smart people fall for gurus.

He's a Buddhist monk. That hardly makes him the follower of some wacky new age guru.

Classic, of course. I'm Your Man is my favourite. I think Jazz Police is really funny. Great Thelonius Monk as derange cocktail bar pianist solo too.

Beautiful Losers is far and away the best novel ever written by a rock musician. Granted, the competition isn't exactly fierce, so let's put it another way: it's one of the best transgressive novels of the 1960s, up there with Burroughs, Trocchi, Baldwin et al and a great piece of postmodern fiction too.

This thread SUCKS

uh, yeah.

leonard cohen is basically god. so there.

oh man, confession time...i've tried really hard, but makes my skin crawl....someone direct me to something to change my mind

iago how much do you care about lyrics? I can't imagine anybody feeling more than "that's pleasant" about any LC unless they are very into lyrics.

yeah, i haven't sit down and focused, just put it on and did other stuff...always figured the way in was the words.

is it early stuff you've heard or later stuff? because I always kinda liked his so-called classic early stuff, but it wasn't til I dug into the 80s albums that I became convinced of his genius.

yeah I mean Leonard Cohen is specifically for people who are listening for the lyrics. The music can be quite compelling but it's only in the context of the lyrics.

iago how much do you care about lyrics? I can't imagine anybody feeling more than "that's pleasant" about any LC unless they are very into lyrics.

― gross rainbow of haerosmith (underrated aerosmith albums I have loved), Friday, July 30, 2010 9:03 PM (Yesterday) Bookmark Suggest Ban Permalink

i fucking hate this notion. lyrics and music ARE NOT TWO SEPARATE THINGS. they are fundamentally intertwined.

also the idea of people being uniquely "into lyrics" seems kind of absurd to me.

there's lots of ppl who dont care abt lyrics?

all i wanna say is that they don't really care about lyrics

naw some of the music's great - fuck it, all of the music's great; the arrangements on the first record are other worldly, the mellotron-rising strings, the jankity faraway fairground sounds, etc; there's a sensitivity and detail akin to the first nico record maybe. they're all such closely recorded, imtimate records, like it's a man's world or something. and there's such gallop to some of them - the partisan, fingerprints, the rowdy ones on love and hate.

anyway: thought this might've been bumped re: bird on a wire, the little seen thought-lost documentary that just got found and is showing again in a couple of weeks (dvd forthcoming etc). my mom saw it at the cinema in the seventies and - i forget whether this is from the docu or from something someone who saw him in concert said - still laughs at the memory of leonard's singers coming on stage to their 'ooooo's, and then leaving the stage until the next oooos.

oooh sweet didn't even know about that, thanks.

also, best comment on leonard's appeal came from the singer out of lamb, appearing in some documentary: "he's like isaac hayes, for poetry girls"

i fucking hate this notion. lyrics and music ARE NOT TWO SEPARATE THINGS. they are fundamentally intertwined.

that's a nice opinion, but it's not true; one can reproduce the lyrics of a song on paper, and there you go, the lyrics, all by their lonesome; one can do an instrumental version of a song, and what do you know, the music, a totally separate thing. you can argue that they're best together but your present argument is that there's no such thing as a hot dog or mustard, just a dog with mustard because the flavors intertwine

of course you could always say "for me, the two are fundamentally intertwined, and it's hard for me to imagine how people don't think of it that way," and who could argue with you there?

But was there ever a good version of"Bird on a Wire"?

Johnny Cash's and Joe Cocker's?

What's wrong with Cohen's original? If you mean was there ever a good *cover* version, Jennifer Warnes's is excellent.

The Lilac Time also covered "Bird on a Wire" in a 1991 tribute album called "I'm Your Fan" released by Les Inrockuptibles.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AiJTv92K5uU

That album is full of oddities like John Cale doing Hallelujah and Lloyd Cole doing Chelsea Hotel.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S2qisdKKMpU

Jennifer Warnes' "Bird on a Wire" is good.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0xsJXDwIL2k

I favour the Willie Nelson version, it sounds very natural when he sings it

I already mentioned that one. xp

Oh, haven't that one, thanks---seems likely, considering his refreshing version of "Hallelujah."
But otherwise, it's always seemed the most abject, sympathy or pathos-seeking dirgethon---the failed twin of "After The Gold Rush," a masterpiece, because it builds that "transcendent" fantasy of escaping ruined Mother Earth---then honestly keens," all in a dreeam"--earns its pathos like "Bird" doesn't,in my ears----but I'll check Willie and some of those others, thanks.

(Also "Gold Rush" honestly and still has the appetite for "There was a band, playing in my head, and I felt like getting high," and honestly, inexorably ties that into "I was thinkin' about what a friend had said, and hopin', it was a lie." What have we come to, when that's what we hope of our friends! It's--the 70s, a new mornin'.

"Bird On The Wire" ain't got none of that, or not enough.

This is the only Joe Cocker track I really enjoy, "Marjorine" (1968):
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NYtb5vEk3FA

"Bird on a Wire" is miles better than "After the Goldrush".

I think those two songs are attempting v different things, written in different songwriting languages. A closer cousin for me, to “Bird On A Wire”, is Buffy’s “Until It’s Time For You To Go”, ballads that occupy a space between Tin Pan Alley and country

“After The Goldrush” is charming in its hippie-ness, a song-length version of the last chapters of Canticle For Leibowitz (which I assumed was the song’s inspiration, and a Google concludes I’m not the only person to make that assumption)

xp Stoney Edwards has a pretty good version if you like 70s country

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZHxwyHr1kps

Stoney Edwards! I should have known that; he didn't get to make many records.
Wild about Canticle, I only knew that the song was named after (and maybe other connections to) Dean Stockwell's screenplay of same title. Thanks yall!

This thread led me to find this version with the 1979 Recent Songs band:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gDJ3Rts_XMA

And then that led to this:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fh6zyJyrrQI

there'll be fires on the road / and the white man dancing

— el Cohen (@ElCohenSincere) November 5, 2024

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DCF8ExQuIB8/

that's wonderful!

great stuff

It's the same location as this one:

https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/91dsne9AZsL._UF1000,1000_QL80_.jpg