Rolling Teenpop 2007 Thread

Probably not the same sort of easygoingness (at all) but emo-wise I think that MCR makes the difficult seem...I dunno, difficult-in-quotation marks. Like Mike Patton -- vocal dexterity with capital VD (huh). Except they strain and strain and out pops pop, instead of strained-pop (which I tend to like anyway). Whereas with FOB I get more strain than I get pop? Not that the pop's not there, just that I can't get past the strain. I dunno, this metaphor is wheezing harder than a Fall Out Boy track but there's something really ugly and congealed about Fall Out Boy's sound that doesn't seem to apply to MCR even when they're GOING for ugly. Which is also why I don't totally connect with them, either, with Tim Burton-style DEATH (too cute) -- at least Mike Patton is ugly when he wants to be, which is maybe too often but it's at least genuinely ugly. MCR is disingenuously ugly when it could be just tuneful (except then they might be McFly's "Transylvania") and FOB is disingenuously tuneful when it's mostly ugly. But those are only my impressions from this past year, I still don't know MCR (except "Helena," which I remember liking but don't really remember) prior to like 2006.

I'm gonna go to bat for emo here (particularly Fall Out Boy and MCR). I don't think the 'difficultness' of their music is a bad thing. In fact, I think it's integral to their music. They are thematically discussing issues of tension and trying to find a way through tough spots. But where teenpop finds a way through ease and lyrical searching, emo is a steamroller. Thematically ("So darken your clothes / Or strike a violent pose / Maybe they'll leave you alone, but not me!" or "This ain't a scene, it's a GODDAMN arms race") and also musically. Teenpop is looking for a way out. Emo is making one. Which is why they frequently come off as violent, angry, or misogynistic. There isn't time for subtleties. (dabug, I don't see this as ugly, or intentionally ugly - maybe incidentally so.)

I mean ugly in a much more visceral sense -- I think that the Fall Out Boy album sounds turgid and gross when it means to sound bright 'n' bouncy (regardless of what they're saying, since I haven't paid any attention to that anyway), like their entire album is swamped with...I dunno, some kind of sludge. Not like it's an intended effect, it just sounds like someone poured molasses over all their songs. It irritates me, in the way that people have described compression (or whatever) irritating them.

Re: MCR, I just think that they're playing death dress-up, about as "dark" and as "difficult" as the Rocky Horror Picture Show. I don't think this is necessarily a bad thing (and somehow they usually avoid camp in the process, which is kind of weird), but I certainly don't take them seriously. The only time I've ever taken them seriously, meaning thought about what a song might mean (or even remember any lyrics) ("Teenagers") is when I get the least sense that they have any idea whatsoever what it is they're really on about.

If you're problem is that you think they're going for bright n' bouncy, but it turns out turgid and sludgy, maybe your expectations are off. Genre conventions are closer to the latter than the former. They aren't a pop-punk band after all (like All American Rejects, or Bowling for Soup, or Boys Like Girls). They are a screamo/emo derivation. I don't think they are supposed to sound cheery.

The only time I've ever taken them seriously, meaning thought about what a song might mean (or even remember any lyrics) ("Teenagers") is when I get the least sense that they have any idea whatsoever what it is they're really on about.

Did Nirvana sound on Smells Like Teen Spirit like they had any idea what it is they were really on about? (I think the comparison is apt - MCR obviously cribbed a lot of the music video visuals from Nirvana, and there is a similar angst.)

you are a delight.

xp I have no use for either of those bands, or at least for a single song I've ever heard by either of them, which isn't to say that I might not someday be persuaded otherwise. (Actually, I thought the couple Panic at the Disco songs I heard last year were more entertaining than anything I've ever heard by either Fall Out Boy or My Chemical Romance -- not that I was even inspired to go seek out the rest of PatD's album, either.) Anyway, I just say that as a lead-in to saying that by far my favorite Hot Topic teenygoth album of the year (really, possibly my two favorite Hot Topic teenygoth albums of the past three years) came from the Birthday Massacre, whose album covers consistently seem to suggest they think purple bunnies and trick-or-treating are both scary and cute, and whose music is more cute than scary and really does pull off the bright n bouncy within turgid n sludgy trick. The fact that they sound like sweet like Book of Love (and maybe Missing Persons or Berlin, for all I know) used to and take melodies from "Crimson and Clover" (in "Movies") definitely does not hurt. Other favorite toons on Walking With Strangers include but are certainly not limited to "Goodnight" and "Falling Down," and they manage to get decent post-industrial stomp going in "Redstars" and "Looking Glass." Here they are:

http://www.myspace.com/thebirthdaymassacre

I also have a bit of a soft spot for Mindless Self Indulgence, if they count. Not that they're easy to keep up with (haven't heard a whole album by them in a few years, though their singles keep scoring on Billboard's 12-inch dance sales chart, also physical product based btw), and not sure how they fit into this discussion. They are certainly not humorless. (I guess part of my problem with Fall Out Boy and My Chemical Romance is my knee-jerk aversion to "rock where I can't hear any rocking in it." Though maybe I'd actually hear some, if I took more time. I probably still wouldn't like their singers, though.)

You're right. They do have REALLY precious covers. :)

Wow. I'm listening to "Kill the Lights" off the new album. Chuck, this is gorgeous stuff.

The fact that they sound like sweet like Book of Love (and maybe Missing Persons or Berlin, for all I know) used to and take melodies from "Crimson and Clover" (in "Movies") definitely does not hurt...

Will definitely check this out. Book of Love are without question my favourite 80s/90s band I didn't pay nearly enough attention to at the time.

Words cannot express how much I loathe that "Arms Race" song, though. (MCR, from what I've heard, are much, much better, though still not nearly good enough).

Another sort of likeminded band I keep trying to get into but who go right past me: the Hives. Anyone here recommend something by them that doesn't sound so, I don't know, boxed in or monolithic? Or maybe that's the entire point of them? (It has to be more than the boxed-in or monolithic quality that bugs me about them, because there are lots of things I could describe that way which I do like... Maybe it's the combination of sounding boxed-in + the irritating scrape of the vocals?)

Did you dislike (or hear) "Hate to Say I Told You So"? It's the only track they've done that I can actually distinguish from their other tracks.

ACtually, that one's kind of catchy, I admit. Though I hate the gurgle that ends each chorus.

I mean, the vocal gurgle/tick/whatever you want to call it (I think I need to listen to it again to see if this makes any sense).

I like the Hives fine! (At least partially because I can hear rocking in their rock.) And their new album might actually be the best one I've heard by them. Here's the review I wrote for Billboard:

THE HIVES
The Black and White Album

Seven years after breaking worldwide out of Sweden’s eternal garage-revival scene, this color-coordinated quintet have somehow managed their liveliest, most playable album. Its cartoon-tuneful energy pogos all over the place: An opening volley blowing stuff up (“Tick Tick Boom”), an expert AC/DC homage about being broke (“Square One Here I Come”), equestrian Pixies new wave (“Giddy Up!”), 1966 frat-rock party voices, Motown basslines under laughs and cackles and yelps. Howlin’ Pelle Almqvist has an awesome knack for repeating simple declarative mantras into hooks: “I was right all along,” “I can’t go on and I gotta get goin’,” “Whatcha gonna do? Here he comes for you,” “No job! No skills! No money! No nothing!” And when tempos occasionally downshift (Eric Burdon baritone verses in “Won’t Be Long”; creepy crawly keyboards in “Puppet On A String,” even a robotically falsettoed Prince-circa-“Kiss” attempt in the Pharrell-helmed “T.H.E.H.I.V.E.S.”), the fun still doesn’t drain away. C.E.

I do want to hear this now. I clearly haven't given them a fair shake.

"Tick Tick Boom" is the only Hives song I've heard in about six years (not counting a background listen when their album was streamed several months ago on AOL Music), so if they're only repeating the same song, it's a good one, because that one's a blast (though rather weightless, as blasts go).

Frank, I actually mailed you my extra copy of the Hives CD last week (along with my extra copy of Little Big Town, Hurricane Chris, and a couple other stray things.) Watch your PO Box...

Miley Cyrus's "See You Again" is up to 933 spins on Top 40 radio, which isn't tremendous but is significant and beats any recent Disney product that I can think of other than Plain White T's. Is in the top ten on WHTZ in New York.

But Ashlee's "Outta My Head" only got nine Top 40 spins in the last six days. I told you radio wouldn't touch it. Its only hope is massive download action convincing radio guys to give it a chance; or if/when a video appears, strong play on TRL and Launch Yahoo and AOL Music.

Britney's "Piece Of Me" jumps to 2,132 spins, possibly stimulated by the new video, in which she seems awake and happy. (OK, is the video released or just being "previewed" on selected sites (and all over YouTube)? I'm understanding release schedules less and less these days.)

Taylor Swift's "Teardrops On My Guitar" up to 4800 spins (which puts her at number 11 on mainstream radio); not sure which version is getting the top 40 play: there's the original and there's a new version with added harmonies and guitars (though same amount of teardrops), which is what's getting played on Disney.

Ashley Tisdale's "He Said, She Said" up to 881 spins on mainstream Top 40. I hope it goes higher but I'm afraid it's topping out. Minor play in New York and Philly, not getting any other major markets.

Lip Gloss placed on PFM's singles list (#27). Umbrella hit #5. The top 4 are predictable indie choices (LCD, Battles, Panda Bear + M.I.A.).

On a cooler note, Christgau's list (http://www.slate.com/id/2179977/entry/2180085/) has Piece of Me at #2. Every time I hear the song, it seems better and better to me. My friends and I have started blasting it, or singing it, whenever we see each other.

Best part from Christgau's article: Let's get this party started quickly. Journey sucks. They sucked in 1981, they'll suck in 2033, and they suck now. Who gives a fuck what Tony Soprano thinks?

But Toto's on my list.

"Africa" was, like, everywhere this year, wasn't it? Well, it was on the JoJo song as well as a Mims remix I heard (neither of which I loved, but both did make me hear how gorgeous the original is--totally a dead ringer for MJ's "Human Nature," which makes sense given the band is essentially the same, no?). Someone on facebook pointed me to another hip-hop version of "Africa," but I think it was a bit older and I forget now who it was.

I actually liked this from Xgau's essay:

naming your favorite albums of the year before the year is even over is impossible by definition. I really need till Feb. 1 to get the year under my belt.

But with pop-culture news cycles sped up beyond anything that anybody with any sense (or who doesn't get paid for it) would want to keep up with, those days are long gone -- Scores of publications have published best-of-the-year lists already, and Pazz & Jop and Idolator ballots are both due this week, which basically means year-end music (inasumuch as it exists anymore, given slimmed December release schedules) gets the shaft unless it hits you right away; either that, or you vote for albums without actually having had time to live with them (just like how now it's mandated you review them everywhere without living with them first.) (Not that I'd expect my ballot -- which I already filed this weekend -- to change in the next few weeks. But then, I never do. And if I have three more weeks, it always changes anyway.)

Also, just noticed this on his (tentative, I assume) year-not-quite-end album list:

23. Soulja Boy: Souljaboytellem.com (Interscope)

Billboard's top 10 singles of the year:

1. Beyonce - "Irreplaceable"
2. Rihanna ft. Jay Z - "Umbrella"
3. Gwen Stefani ft. Akon - "The Sweet Escape"
4. Fergie - "Big Girls Don't Cry"
5. T-Pain ft. Yung Joc - "Buy U a Drank (Shawty Snappin')"
6. Carrie Underwood - "Before He Cheats"
7. Plain White T's - "Hey There Delilah"
8. Akon ft. Snoop Dog - "I Wanna Love You"
9. Nelly Furtado - "Say It Right"
10. Fergie ft. Ludacris - "Glamorous"

Not a lot with a teenpop flair there. Last year's #1, "Bad Day", didn't get a single vote in P&J or Jackin Pop. This year's top 2 figure to do better.

I still think that "Gimme More" and "Get Naked (I Got a Plan" and "Freakshow" are all better than "Piece of Me".

Blackout has now taken over as my #1 album of the year.

Also, just noticed this on his (tentative, I assume) year-not-quite-end album list:

23. Soulja Boy: Souljaboytellem.com (Interscope)

I noticed this...has he written about it anywhere? It's hard for me to listen to the album all the way through, even though I do like it. Kind of begs to be scattered around to other places/mixes. It's REALLY annoying all in one sitting (kind of in a good way, but annoying is annoying). I also like the idea that kids are probably using this album to bug the hell out of their parents.

CELEBRITY NOSES! Ashlee Tisdale now looks like this.

Apparently Fall Out Boy was nominated 4 times by different PFM writers, but they all nominated different songs from each other (Hum Hallelujah, Thnks fr the Mmrs, I'm Like a Lawyer and The Take Over). MCR's Teenagers only got one nomination. Aly + AJ got two nominations for PBS (14 on one list and 20 on another). I don't know how the aggregations work, but I would've thought that would've been enough for them to place

Greg, it's funny but outside Piece of Me, the one song that keeps sticking out to me on Blackout is Radar (where "On my radar" starts to sound like "Amaraida," a far more exotic annunciation.)

mord otm re: "radar". i like to here it as "amaretto" with an a at the end instead of an o. favorite song on a pretty okay album.

The Britney Spears, she be sippin' amare-TTA

Jessica Poptastic heard "Radar" as "Because I got you gonorrhea."

I note that the Britney got album votes in P4k in a Ewing/Finney/Trousse trifecta.

Fall Out Boy also polled pretty well on the P4K list and must have just missed the top 50. It had two #4 votes and a #13 vote (I think).

FYI, This is what Ashlee Simpson currently looks like.

Ashlee bounces off wall in new vid, Sigmund provides no help

Very silly in a good way, ambitious too, though I still think the song is about her mom. Of should be. (I know little about her mom except that I found her very appealing berating Ashlee for not knowing how to mop the floor in episode one of the Ashlee Simpson Show.)

In MTV's description of the vid, Timbo plays the psychotherapist, but either the vidmakers replaced him or there's a longer version that isn't up on Launch Yahoo.

Maybe Timbo couldn't get permission from his studio to be in the vid.

My ears and eyes and everything but the airplay numbers tell me that "Outta My Head" is a hit. How can it not be? (But I'm still afraid it won't.)

Of should be = Or should be

Teenpop Hava Nagila from Lauren Rose:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wgdHjWPuCrI&

Bullshit! They don't show the feet during the so-called hora! I contend that it's a fake! (But it sounds good. And she looks like Ashlee used to, except she smiles too much.)

I love how (her own?) YouTube page calls it a "Christmas single release" and calls it the "re make of Hava Nagila" (a remake of the Will To Power original version, right?).

Omg. I totally picked up on the Ashlee thing too. In fact, when my editor sent me the link and asked me what I thought, I said I thought she looked like Ashlee Simpson.

Dear Lauren Rose, who I have barely heard of, please do not have a nose job or I will be very unhappy.

Your devoted fan.

Frank

I think she's exactly 50% old-Ashlee and 50% old-Ashley (Tisdale).

Fergie's Glamorous as sung by the Constance Billard Choir on Gossip Girl:
http://cwtv.com/thecw/images/music/gossipgirl/Glamorous.mp3

Also, if I can find it, they sang Santa Baby on last night's episode.

Dear Lauren Rose, who I have barely heard of, please do not have a nose job or I will be very unhappy.

I could easily turn that comment into a question about Ashlee Simpson and Jewish physical stereotypes. But I won't.

Hm, Ashley Tisdale is Jewish.

Yeah, dabug, on Monday, March 19, 2007 7:38 PM (9 months ago) on this thread, I linked to an American Jewish Life article about her Jewishness and her Bat Mitzvah (or lack thereof).

Radio report: Miley Cyrus's "See You Again" at 1,109 spins on Mainstream Top 40 stations (puts it at #35 in that format); added in Roanoke, Portsmouth, Saginaw, Lansing, Burlington VT, Augusta, Knoxville, Buffalo; rising in Atlanta, Philly, and Miami; holding strong but not gaining on Z-100 in New York. Radio Disney still not playing it (insanely having chosen "Start All Over" as the next Miley track to push (not that it's a bad song, but don't the Disneyans notice they have a potential breakout hit in "See You Again"?). Although New York numbers indicate the song will peak in several weeks, the adds suggest that it has the potential for a steady climb up the charts à la Pink's "U + Ur Hand." (But the Pink song had a video and was by an established Top 40 radio act.) Taylor Swift's "Teardrops On My Guitar" has gotten its second wind on Top 40 stations and is at #11 with 4,904 spins. Britney Spears' "Piece Of Me" is at #28 in the format with 2,199 spins but doesn't seem to be tearing the place up. Ashley Tisdale's "He Said, She Said" has climbed to 906 spins and was added in Wilkes-Barre, McAllen (?), and Canton but won't go much higher, since it's falling on almost as many stations as it's rising - unless Rolling Teenpop's discussion of Ashley's nose reinvigorates airplay. Ashlee Simpson's "Outta My Head" got thirteen spins in Phoenix and two in Reno. None on Radio Disney ("L.O.V.E." got about three). So a whole lot depends on response at TRL and Launch Yahoo, I'd think. Or maybe someone who doesn't post on this thread or Poptimists will also notice that the song is catchy.

Billboard Hot 100: Jordin Sparks' "Tattoo" is #8; Sara Bareilles' sub-sub-Tashbed "Love Song" is rising fast at #16 (Tash's "Love Like This" f. Innocuous Roly Poly is holding on at #19, one behind Innocuous Boy's "Take You There"); Taylor Swift's "Our Song" at #21 and "Teadrops On My Guitar" at #24; Britney's "Piece Of Me" is #45 (#20 in downloads); Miley's "See You Again" is #78.

Frank, what stations in Atlanta are playing "See You Again"?

WSTR 94.1 FM ("See You Again" is #33 on their playlist with 18 spins)

Also, if you're in earshot:
WHHD in Augusta 98.3 FM (#27 with 17 spins)
WCGQ in Columbus 107.3 FM (#26 with 21 spins)
WFBC in Greenville 93.7 FM (#24 with 31 spins)
and WZAT and WAEZ in Savannah (2 spins each)