Favourite Member Of Fleetwood Mac

Her presence would have forced the excision of several blah Buckingham and Nicks songs.

Should vote Lindsay, voted Stevie.

stevie stevie stevie

nix nix nix

^^^^^ sorely missed on the otherwise excellent Say You Will.

Made more cruel by her audible presence in a lot of the Buckingham songs on that record.

I always get confused and think Stevie is the man and Lindsay is the woman.

LB

Lindsey w/o a second thought.

Christine. Her material is always underrated on ILM in all the pre-poll results banter but usually finishes at/near the top.

if I made a fleetwood mac pox stevie would probably do the best, but voted buck

i mean, i just wanna spread it around a little, so i voted for bob welch, because FUTURE GAMES is a really important song to remember here. i could have easily voted for peter green, mick fleetwood, christine mcvie, lindsey buckingham, or stevie nicks, though.

my brain says lindsey, my heart says stevie, my gut says the two guys who the band is named for. i think the rhythm section elevated this weird collective of smart singer-songwriters into something much more than a weird collective of smart singer-songwriters.

― fact checking cuz, Monday, September 20, 2010 3:46 PM (Yesterday) Bookmark

^^a really important point

Mick and John really do deserve some credit for keeping the thing going. Seems like there were a few different periods where they could have hung it up, but they didn't.

If this poll had a right answer the band would be way less interesting.

Favourite Member of T-Rex

Most hated member of Simply Red

Pretty hard to get past the Stevie/Lindsay/Christine triumvirate, and I'm not voting for him, but can I just...
http://www.fleetwoodmac.org/images/bob-welch.jpg

Automatic thread bump. This poll is closing tomorrow.

Lindsey Buckingham for his insane banjo-esque fingerpicking skills and confident tenor (I do not include his weird warbling on the reunion album)

Lindsey

mcvie!

er christine that is

lindsey

Well, Welch was in charge for my favorite album of theirs (M2M) and Kirwan was in charge for my second favorite (BT). Probably have to go with Kirwan, as he seems kind of crucial in helping them bridge the gap from blues to...other stuff.

And "Dust" is possibly the single best song they ever did...

Peter Green... but only just over Christine

This is the closest I have got to 'credits', I'm certain that it's Danny Kirwain who did the majority of OhWellPart2, but remained uncredited.

― Mark G, Monday, 20 September 2010 15:48 (1 week ago) Bookmark Suggest Ban Permalink

Funnily enough, over the weekend "Oh Well" was on TOTP2, and you can see it's Danny Kirwain taking the majority of the solos on Part1 as well!

Her presence would have forced the excision of several blah Buckingham and Nicks songs.

I bet Say You Will is one of those albums where everyone says "oh there's filler" but everyone means different songs.

lindsey obviously

well I love Stevie's songs in FM, but don't have time for her solo stuff...and Peter Green is a great guitar player, but I never liked Then Play On...fuck it, I'm voting John McVie.

I'm expecting John to get short-changed here. There seems to be no particular reason to pick him. You dig the r&b roots rhythm section? Vote for Mick, he's a bit more showy. Enjoy the melodic, driving chug? Vote for Lindsey's rhythm playing. Intrigued by the emotional turmoil? Go for any of the others. Want to pay tribute to the early days? Got to be Peter Green. Etc etc. John seems to be best at hiding baldness and having a red nose.

http://img153.imageshack.us/img153/7813/johnmcvie.jpg

on that recent bbc doc on the mac, the one where he's wearing whit UGGs, he comes across a bit tragic

Actually John would be my 2nd choice, his tone is enormous.

christine mcvie! best vocals, best lyrics, best songs

Lindsey

I mean I still check out his solo stuff, own all the albums he's on

all the FM albums I mean

christine <3

heard this on the bus this morning:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8jwxX4BtRv8

bassist solidarity fuck you Ismael!!!! John is very much responsible for making Dreams one of the greatest songs ever!

Uh? I like John, I play bass myself, I love his work. In 'The Chain' he's got one of the all-time moments. All time! I'm not going down as a hater on a FM thread, no way.

;)

Can't decide, didn't vote.

Actually fuck it McVie (J.)

John is very much responsible for making Dreams one of the greatest songs ever!

not what I meant; I meant second most responsible after Stevie...his basslines play a huge part in that song imo.

also Ismael OTM about The Chain.

I guess I'll go for Christine McVie, because she wrote most of the best songs on "Tango In The Night".

Dave Mason has made the best music, but that was with Traffic in 1967 and I would say that doesn't count.

Automatic thread bump. This poll's results are now in.

cripes

The purists who prefer their 60s work are not around here, obv...

srsly

http://www.theguardian.com/music/2013/nov/22/christine-mcvie-wants-to-rejoin-fleetwood-mac

If they were to ask me I would probably be very delighted … but it hasn't happened so we'll have to wait and see.

Her remarks were made in a Guardian interview with her and Nicks to be published later this year. During the interview, in which they discuss their friendship, their decadent 1970s lifestyle and experiences of sexism in the music industry.

!!!

That's great for her and fans, but it's kind of a shame she waited until they had to cancel their tour because John has cancer. Hopefully the band comes out at the end intact. This is one farewell reunion I'd be really excited about.

Could it be whispers about her rejoining brought on McVie's cancer?

^ha I felt that one coming.

While we wait for that Guardian interview, this silly little video is a pretty good document of their friendship and "decadent 1970s lifestyle":

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wZSp9TjVlKM

That video is lovely.

Amazed.

holy christ they're so fucked up

People will react to that differently, but for me, not all that different than another interview a few months earlier:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=raEXGXw5VJM

Creepy, not especially fun to watch.

Christine
So smooth...

Christine is the beating heart of the band, which is why I adore Tango in the Night and her contributions to it so much

Peter Green will always be my favorite (and even then, I think Danny Kirwan may even edge him out as their best guitarist). Lindsey Buckingham is also close behind (and IMHO, he's also had the best solo career of any member by a good margin).

But Christine is amazing. After they blew up commercially to gargantuan proportions, I think she and Buckingham probably wrote the best material, but she also wrote the best tunes after Peter Green left and before Buckingham & Nicks came on board - almost single-handedly, she made that stretch of time worth hearing. You can make a great LP out of the dozen best cuts she sung and wrote during those years. "Spare Me a Little...," "Remember Me," "Dissatisfied," "Did You Ever Love Me," "Why," "Heroes Are Hard to Find," "Come a Little Bit Closer," "Show Me a Smile," "The Way I Feel," etc.

“keep on going”, “prove your love”...

I’m posting in the wrong thread but that ‘03 doc just goes to show that Fleetwood and Mc are peripheral players to the whole deal

Nicks wuz robbed.

I made amends: her best Fleetwood Mac tracks ranked.

I would have voted Nicks in the past.. and still would tbh… but I just ran through the ST-Tango run again and it’s not so clear cut…

That is a ranking I mostly agree with. I would put “crystal” and “sisters of the moon” high up in the SOLID category

Well done, Michael Gambino. Well done.

woof at that #1

Hahahaha, bow down to a master - he even asked if FM would play together again! I wouldn't relish that...

LOL at guy saying it never happened. Dude, there’s a picture of them arm in arm together.

love the idea that him and Stevie ostensibly hate each other but every once in a while recommend landscapers to each other.