The Sundays : C or D

just casting my vote.

http://www.phpbbforfree.com/forums/thesundays-about13.html

doubtful, though.

So yeah: very classic, and I'd love to hear another album.

http://www.sundays.secret-hideout.com/img/harriet01.jpg

the sundays are incredible.

the coda, the last four bars, of "hideous towns", are beyond music. they are magic.

the sundays are magic. too good to be true. incredible, etc., etc.

Oh yes, "Hideous Towns's" ending is great.

Yes.

"Hideous Towns" is one of the most perfect songs ever.

SO GOOD

I listen to my "Goodbye" b/w "Wild Horses" single a lot.

i love the five of you.

I just love Harriet's lyrics so much - "I joined the army/but it drove me barmy" - who else could sing that so earnestly????

Someone who's in Iraq right now? oh wait...

Sorry if this sounds snooty, it's not meant to and I wasn't trying to get political on anyone's ass either. I'm going to pull out Reading, Writing & Arithmetic right now. It's shine has dimmed over time somewhat, but I think a trip down memory lane with it can't be bad.

Also this will sound funny but it always reminds me of the chemistry lab I was in in college. I remember playing it on my walkman in that chemistry lab. It was absolutely stunning, couldn't get the songs out of my head.

>I listen to my "Goodbye" b/w "Wild Horses" single a lot

I went through a period last year of listening to Goodbye on repeat play - it would come round on shuffle and then I'd have to hear it several times in a row - by which I mean it's just heartbreakingly fantastic. The final section where Gavurin cuts completely loose and Harriet comes back in with "oh as the heavens shudder baby, I belong to you" makes this into pretty much the best single of the 1990s.

So erm, classic!

omg i'm breakin out the cassettes!

i used to imitate professional ice skaters in my basement on roller skates listening to the sundays - ah the life!

Reading, Writing and Arithmetic, to my ears, sounded like Cocteau Twins without Robin Guthrie's dreamy guitarscapes, but in their place something ordinary. Perhaps having listened to the Cocteaus before having heard of them ruined them for me.
-- acb (acb), Friday, 11 November 2005 22:24 (1 year ago) Link

OTMFM

That comparison always strikes me as a bit odd actually. Where is the commonality? Not in the guitars, the singing, the lyrics, the song structures... May as well say "The Sundays, to my ears, sounded like The Bad Seeds without Nick Cave's unholy raving, but in their place something ordinary..."

Better comparison would be The Smiths crossed with Sugarcubes' "Birthday", surely.

nah, i get the comparison. if liz sang clearly around the time of heaven or las vegas, it'd be a pretty similar thing, i think.

and, what acb said and stephen quoted, i'm about to say this as a sundays obsessive (have their entire discography and about 10 bootlegs), that might be about right. but, that might also be part of what makes them great. but, hm, that's one to chew on.

i always loved the Sundays much more than the Cocteau Twins. the performance worked better for me, and i was happy to not have the guitarscapes on Reading, Writing and Arithmetic. easily a favorite album from my youth.

i heard sundays before the cocteaus, by the way. if that might matter.

i think the less lush design of Reading Writing and Arithmetic (sans guitarscapes) made it feel less cluttered and more pure to me. i liked that it wasn't doused in ambient guitar.

my post before my last is silly. replace 'heaven or las vegas' with 'four-calendar', even though the syllables were clearer then, too.

this needs remastering!

and where can u get a cd-quality copy of DON'T TELL YOUR MOTHER in this day and age.

You can get it in most any dollar bin on the DGC Rarities volume 1 cd.

Or on Amazon.com for one penny.

wow! DGC rarities eh? really? that's genuinely brilliant advice. great stuff thanks!

hahaha, dgc rarities is CLASSIC! deserves it's own thread.

The DGC Rarities disc (volume one-and-only) is kind of great, actually! I found my copy a couple years ago and was surprised by how much fun it was to listen to. Teenage Fanclub, what might be Weezer's best song, a good That Dog track, St. Johnny sounding more like Dinosaur Jr than ever, a great weird Sloan thing, the only Hole song I've ever really liked ... I seem to remember even liking the CELL track on this.

Wait, I must have found a NEW copy, as I'm pretty sure I had this on TAPE back in the day?

Beck's maybe best song ever, "Bogusflow"

um. yeah. i wasn't kidding about fucking dgc rarities.

My January band for the last few years.

Good choice. :-)

I'm in a "I Kicked a Boy" kind of mood.

Haha, I was born in that born.

????

in that MOOD!

You were born twice. A special birth.

The rebirth of slick, like my gangsta stroll.

I Kicked A Boy!!!! gooood call

that album = this weather to the t

Yes, "I Kicked A Boy" is a damn good call! I tend to forget about that one. I should dig out that cassette download...

I Kicked a Boy is easily in the favorite three songs on the debut.

I especially love "My Finest Hour" (esp. the end, SHIIIIT!) and "Can't Be Sure".

Classic, i.e., I liked them and have since forgotten all about them.

xcept of course I Kissed A Girl is like echoing in my brain whenever i think of I Kicked A Boy