Yo P&J, I'm really happy for you, Imma let you finish, but ILX had the greatest 2009 poll of all time! All time! (2009 ILX Trax Poll Results: TOP TEN TODAY)

anyway the thing is any halfway catchy Jay single had a good chance of being a ubiquitous Billboard/Pazz & Jop #1 at this point in his career, it just took this long because most of his post-retirement singles have been dogshit

I hadn't thought of it this way but it's totally true.

wrt esom i liked it a lot when i heard it on the radio @ my friend luca's house while he was making dinner but like it was just some song on the radio that you could listen 2 while chopping carrots but when its got all this bluster and "crossover hit" and I <3 NY stencilled all over it it seems kinda dead and gross and I liked it a lot more before all that

yeah the first few times i heard it i was all "hey this is great please make this the next single, anything to get Run This Town off the radio"

WE ARE YA I SAID IT WE ARE

yeah i guess a weird comp 2 make is this song Galway girl which is ireland's most famous accordion player(tm) and steve earl and was a massive radio hit when i went to college but bc nobody really talked abt it beyond yeah this song is alright the fact that i was allowed to internalise "this is where im from and they mention salthill in it" seemed ok and personal and mine but when I got back to galway and it was this horrible fist-pumping thing at the end of the night in student-ey bars it was just really distorted and gross and I guess some songs are able to take this much better than others like some songs become really tasteless and empty when they're anthems

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zFlfSeh-Ts8

is the song, i didn't embed cos isn't that the rule?

wait ok it ignores the url tag my bad

I understand what you're saying, Plaxico. I guess too much of the wrong kind of exposure to anything will make you hate it, even if you liked it originally.

20 -- Jay-Z - Empire State of Mind (ft. Alicia Keys) (13 votes, 144.5 points, 1 #1 vote/s) (1 in P&J, 44 in p4k)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0UjsXo9l6I8

just blew me away: the hook, the video, all Alicia's bits really. Jay's fine, although I wish he wouldn't chuckle at the 'bus route' bit. If I had to criticise it, it would be for the cliches: de Niro, Biggie, concrete jungle etc. It doesn't need them - it's epic already. -Ismael Klata

lol @ this placing immediately after all that

loooooooooool

Somehow I've managed to avoid hearing this song; should I bother?

I still like "Run This Town" a lot btw

Euler, you can click on the video and hear it. I love it, but then I'm not from New York. It sounds big and anthemic and a lot of fun.

"Run This Town" is v. underrated, "Empire" overrated.

xpost

yeah I know; I guess b/c it placed here I ought to bother. Basically all I hear about the song is "boo, this is boring, lame latter-day Jay-Z" and you know, attention is limited.

"run this town" and "empire state of mind" both suck, at least we're done with jay

Jay's comeback ranked (according to me): American Gangster >>>>>>>>>>>> Blueprint 3 >>> Kingdom Come

Jay's career ranked (according to me): every album before 2004 >>>>>>>>> every album after

otm

I just love the hell out of the American Gangster album, sorry guyz.

There have been very very few British entries on here so far. I count only Florence and Basement Jaxx (although I don't know where a lot of the dance tracks originate)

darkstar, fuzzy logik & egypt, crazy cousinz and guido are all UK too

AG is aight, things about the vox/production bother me but it holds together better than the other 2 (although I'd rank even Kingdom Come over BP3). Still I'm not convinced anything he's done the last few years even meets the low bar set by the Blueprint 2. (xpost)

Jay's comeback ranked (according to me): American Gangster >>>>>>>>>>>> Blueprint 3 >>> Kingdom Come

^ This is accurate, American Gangster is a hell of an album and I'd place it in my top 4-5 of Jay's.

should i even pick the fight of asking what pre-retirement albums you prefer it to? i'm thinking i shouldn't.

For my money, American Gangster is Jay-Z's best album since Reasonable Doubt. I like it even better than the Blueprint and the Black Album.

This is some crazy talk.

better than the blueprint!!!!???

O_O

For my money, American Gangster is Jay-Z's best album since Reasonable Doubt. I like it even better than the Blueprint and the Black Album.

co-sign

http://i44.tinypic.com/34gskdl.gif

1. Reasonable Doubt
2. American Gangster
3. The Blueprint
4. Vol. 1
5. The Black Album
6. Vol. 3
7. Vol. 2
8. Roc La Familia*
9. Kingdom Come*
10. Blueprint 2
11. Blueprint 3*

Though these are probably due for some re-appraisal.

one thing I have learned is not to talk to anyone on ILM about Jay-Z

better than the blueprint!!!!???

Yeah. Ignoring the historical significance, that is. There's a lot more depth of emotion and thought on American Gangster, whereas on The Blueprint he's more like a sociopath faking emotion. (Which is doubly funny because AG is the one where he's supposedly role-playing.) Plus, AG has ballsier production and just plain better songs--"Ignorant Shit," "No Hook," "Success," "American Dreamin'," "Blue Magic."

*supposedly = supposed to be

::throws up hands::

::waves them, doesn't care, exits conversation::

I mean, I could go on... ;)

well at least you agree BP3 sucks. moving on please, less crazy talk, more good songs

yeah what's 19!?!?!

1. The Black Album
2. The Blueprint
3. Reasonable Doubt
4. Vol. 3
5. American Gangster
7. Vol. 2
6. Vol. 1
8. Blueprint 3
9. Roc La Familia
10. Kingdom Come
11. Blueprint 2

stop stop

let's talk some more about how fucking wretched GIRLS is

Blueprint 3 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Girls

not really, lol

19 -- Future Of The Left - Arming Eritrea (10 votes, 147 points, 3 #1 vote/s) (301 in P&J, 98 in p4k)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4cmNy50dHzA

"Lust For Life" would be somewhere in the middle of a spectrum below "Real As It Gets" but above "Venus Vs. Mars" (xpost)

okay Future Of The Left is putting a big fucking ginormous smile on my face

awesome