Yo P&J, I'm really happy for you, Imma let you finish, but ILX had the greatest 2009 poll of all time! All time! (2009 ILX Trax Poll Results: TOP TEN TODAY)

people went WTF at Girls, Jordan said hey Phoenix will be all over the poll too what's the big diff, people went um there's a pretty huge diff

grouping together girls & phoenix is no different than grouping together every band that makes up GAPDY, which we even created a nice acronym for

GAPDY just means consensus praise, but there's not much stylistic homogeny among them.

out of the loop on GAPDY

girls are in that same conversation

GAPDY poll

i think it's funny there's so much objection to the girls guy's voice, because by the standards of white indie guy singing -- which is pretty much my least favorite current vocal genre -- i sort of don't mind his. but i guess it really comes down to, i like nasally voices. when dylan and petty are two of my favorite rock singers, i'm not gonna complain too much about a dude singing through his nose.

zvookster: You really don't think that one Girls track sounds like Mote?

I know, Jordan, I'm just saying that as homogenous as the fanbases for all these bands are, you picked the 2 that, based on the chart I linked, have virtually the least fan overlap possible (and are, imo, on opposite ends of that admittedly not terribly wide aesthetic spectrum).

Morning Light is the song.

I know, Jordan, I'm just saying that as homogenous as the fanbases for all these bands are, you picked the 2 that, based on the chart I linked, have virtually the least fan overlap possible (and are, imo, on opposite ends of that admittedly not terribly wide aesthetic spectrum).

― as genuine a white mainstream talent as you are going to get (some dude), Friday, January 29, 2010 10:35 PM (29 seconds ago) Bookmark

right, okay

which is to say that if you said Animal Collective instead of Phoenix way upthread there wouldn't be any of this quibbling (xpost)

WELL IF ONLY I HAD KNOWN

but in that case, not like i think this is gonna change anyone's opinion, but people didn't react to "summertime clothes" like someone took a shit on the thread. was it just bcuz people had heard that already? or those who hadn't didn't even bother bcuz it's anco? it can't be because people like it better, considering the placement.

ppl are h8ing on that girls track bcuz theyre dead inside

I'm no AnCo stan or anything, though I think MPP is nice to hear on occasion (and is pretty much the only AnCo album I'm ever inclined to hear voluntarily), but I think there's a wide style gap between Girls and AnCo too.

lol, sure

Having heard Girls a few times I wanna say Evan is OTM. His description describes indie-landfill pretty perfectly, too.

It also reminds me of Simon Reynolds recent blogpost about indie-fill, where he memorably says "who were these faceless bands? how could they not know they're shit?"

idk what kind of music evan likes or what kind of music you like, cunga but describing the 'indie landfill' as merely replicating beloved forebears can surely be applied to uh... every genre of music

as for the "girls are famous bcuz of the dude's backstory", well i think that's pretty much BS, but we covered that ground thoroughly in the girls thread imo.

what evan said about girls & vampire weekend & pop barely scans as sensical

Blogs and bands are mutually corrosive.

There's a thread on Girls?

yes, and it's long

GIRLS - ALBUM

Jordan, I was trying to analyze why they've blown up. I feel like without the elements I went over they would be a very typical indie band many people would not have heard about or would have gotten very excited about initially.

'lust for life' is really relatable and beautiful and has a gr8 aesthetic who cares if it sounds like something else from history

also lol @ the idea that girls has 'blown up'

And I mentioned Vampire Weekend in that last example because I thought it may have something to do with their backlash in the hip/indie community.

'lust for life' is really relatable and beautiful and has a gr8 aesthetic

This is the kind of thing that makes me think people are lazy about looking for music to like.

Well you know what I mean, Lamp. They were a big deal last year.

ppl really want to listen to this guy whine over "classic pop" chord changes?

― call all destroyer, Friday, September 25, 2009 6:53 AM (4 months ago)

is it not possible that lots of people think that the song is actually good? and anyway, this is kind of rehashing territory from the p&j thread, but where is lazy in 09/10? i like girls a lot-- i found out about them because pitchfork and the fader wrote about them, i checked them out and digged their music. now, did i go seek other 60s throwback cali rock like girls this year? no i didn't, but that's cuz i was seeking out tons of other music. i don't think i was being lazy. if i sought out albums that i thought could be better versions of every album from 2009 that i like/love then i never would've left my house.

ugh, those videos make me feel so dirty for living in san francisco

― psychgawsple, Saturday, September 26, 2009 12:03 PM (4 months ago)

But why not bypass a band like Girls and be proactive about looking for better things in the same realm? Don't wait for PFM or Fader to alert you to interesting subsects of genres... that's how GAPDY gets made in the first place.

Did he sing a song about how they couldn't have pizza?

― Evan, Thursday, October 1, 2009 8:26 PM (3 months ago)

But why not bypass a band like Girls and be proactive about looking for better things in the same realm?

i think i answered this already in my post -- also, i really like girls a lot! i'm not a junkie of the type of music they make, i was fine with enjoying that album and that album only, unless something else came along. certainly everyone has genres/records on their lists that occupy this role for them. (tons of dream voters who didn't listen to all the other great r&b albums that came out this year, for instance)

lol at the rabbithole this thread's gone down

im not generally "looking for music to like" fwiw - i already like lots of music - but lol @ liking girls bein somehow 'lazy'

no well adjusted person cares if a thing the like isnt the actual best version of that thing to like

also no1 i no irl cares abt or likes or has heard of 'girls' the band

Would immensely prefer listening to Glenn Beck moan over classic pop chord changes

― WARS OF ARMAGEDDON (Karaoke Version) (Sparkle Motion), Thursday, December 31, 2009

3 weeks pass...

wow this is way fucking worse than i expected

― iTote 2.0 (electricsound), Friday, January 22, 2010 6:20 AM (1 week ago) Bookmark Suggest Ban Permalink

hahahahah

― call all destroyer, Friday, January 22, 2010 7:09 AM (1 week ago)

lust for life is one of the best songs of the year imo

― ianmaxwell, Saturday, September 19, 2009 7:04 AM (4 months ago) Bookmark

here's another possible "lust for life" voter -- find the 9 others and round up the firing squad

But that's the thing. The-Dream's last album opened my ears to a lot of slick r&b that I never would've given a minute to before, and I've been devouring a lot of it since then, seeking out things and figuring out what I like about some artists and don't like about others. xp tp JOrdan

more annoyed by the fact that they're called Girls tbh, ugh.

What do my top 10 last.fm songs tell about me, Steve Shasta?

i recognized one other ilxor in the P&J voters for this song and peeped his ballot and it's like filled with all this kinda girls/gapdy stuff, i semi-lol'd (muffled half-smirk tbh).

johnny, me too! (referring to love/hate, as i think you are) but usher & r. kelly are much more important to me than the beach boys

The Gyrls - All I Want To Do (Is Eat Pizza In My Beach House)

i clearly understand why tons of people didn't 'bypass' "trap goin ham" for other trap rap songs from 09 that i liked better

Hi everyone.. I like this countdown so far. Wish I had voted..

Way better than the 2008 list (so far).. probably because singles were generally a lot better this year than last year.

& rev, aren't these threads just a continuous cycle of circle jerking & rabbit holes anyway?

The Gyrls - All I Want To Do (Is Eat Pizza In My Beach House)

prophet

I'm down with Usher, but I've always thought R.Kelly was total joeksville. Either way, at least we agree there's great stuff beneath the surface in all genres. I just get absolutely frustrated when I see people unwilling to look for it and settle for the watered-down versions.