Best Orson Welles film (as director)

I'm also controversially putting It's All True in the "unfinished" category.

I've never seen Mr. Arkadin, The Fountain of Youth or The Immortal Story

I saw Arkadin and The Immortal Story on BBC2 back in the seventies. Liked the latter (well, you know, Jeanne Moreau...) and thought the former was a bit flip.

Don't think I've ever seen The Fountain Of Youth but apparently it was a short that he did in 1958, straight after Touch Of Evil.

Oh and Hearts of Age, don't know that that is.

I like all of these films!

lady from shanghai just to choose

Hearts Of Age was from 1934, and pretty much a home movie; I think he and his first wife play everybody in it.

well, i havent seen all of them, but 'lady from shanghai' is such a monster i may as well go for it.

Never seen any of them!

f for fake, for sure. it's a masterpiece, like a calvino novel in cinema, welles back in the editing room with a vengeance.

Citizen Kane. No apologies.

This is pretty hard, though I'd actually be pretty floored if Touch of Evil doesn't win in the end.

My vote's either going to be Ambersons or Chimes.

It's either Citizen Kane or Touch of Evil. But I think Xanadu clinches it.

the trial is pimp

I watch Touch of Evil most often these days, but what survives of Ambersons shames every period piece filmed in the 1940's (David Thomson: while most filmmakers turn Henry James into Booth Tarkington, Welles makes Tarkington look like James).

Ambersons almost got my vote, too late now tho

I've only seen a few of these, but I think I have to agree with Schlump.

The most sheerly entertaining of the bunch is still Citizen Kane, though.

Oh, I think I'd give that title to Touch of Evil.

Yeah I haven't seen enough to vote but I love love love F for Fake.

"Touch of Evil" for sure.

Never seen what remains of "Magnificent Ambersons", I was always put off by the story behind it getting cut to pieces, really depressing.

Lovely film. I cried. Always.

The chat between Joseph Cotten and Anne Baxter about Indians is as deeply weird as the Janet Leigh-Frank Sinatra train exchange in The Manchurian Candidate.

The latter being perhaps the greatest het exchange in Hollywood history.

What, no "garden fragment" from The Dreamers??? J/K

You can watch The Fountain of Youth here:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wKYw6aImTmA

And k*r*g*rg* has The Other Side Of The Wind.

I'm going with Ambersons today. I prefer my films broken anyway.

Actually, all these films are broken save for the first two.

ambersons!

I want to say 'The Trial', but 'Touch of Evil' just can't be beat.

Othello

easiest POO ever -- chimes at midnight, my fav film ever.

anyone who pleads ignorance can see it here:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oOhq0AyRNjY&feature=related

'filming othello' is a real film and shd be on the list.

Actually, all these films are broken save for the first two.

not true -- 'othello,' 'trial,' 'chimes,' and 'immortal story' all came out exactly the way welles wanted them.

ambersons by a wide margin
cool site: http://www.ambersons.com/

Chimes. At. Midnight. = because it's all Welles, untampered-with, at his peak.

Then Ambersons a close second.

there was an article in 'vanity fair' a while back about the search for the missing 'ambersons' footage, and there was an interview with a guy welles hired to look through the complete RKO archives about a year before his death -- no luck. heartbreaking.

Actually, all these films are broken save for the first two.

not true -- 'othello,' 'trial,' 'chimes,' and 'immortal story' all came out exactly the way welles wanted them.

By "broken," I didn't necessarily mean "not as Welles wanted them." I'm using it more to denote a kind of "inorganic" quality, e.g. the crummy soundtrack of Chimes which suits the film thematically and makes it all the greater.

But I don't see how you can say that Othello "came out exactly the way welles wanted (it)." For one thing, Welles clearly "wanted" it several different ways as he edited at least two different versions of it in the 1950s. For another, the various 1990s "restorations" created different artifacts, ones that most likely do not conform to how Welles would have wanted it.

All of which only augments the vertiginous pleasures of Welles fandom.

Automatic thread bump. This poll is closing tomorrow.

you know, in retrospect, Kane is the best, and you're all being contrarians.

contrarian, zing thyself

You voted for Othello, Morbs! It isn't even his best Shakespeare film.

Well I voted for Kane, so I win

Alfred likes Macbeth, easily his worst Shakes film!

I haven't seen either his Othello or his Macbeth, but they'd have to be serious best-of-all-time material to be any better than Chimes.

Macbeth is definitely not better than CAM.

the greatest het exchange in Hollywood history

which begs the question ...

You're up at bat, Eric.

ambersons is sooo close, but I have to go with f for fake.

Automatic thread bump. This poll's results are now in.

dude wtf with the low Touch of Evil showing! guess I should've voted but I refrained cuz I haven't seen a bunch of these

Not only does Macbeth boast one of Welles' few good performances, the one by Jeanette Nolan is almost as good.

no, I do what's necessary and leave. xp

oh, you go envision Cary Grant as Titus Andronicus!

"one of Welles' few good performances"

Hah, OK, so that's what it looks like when I do that.

I get my jollies envisioning Archie as Rosalind.

Hah, OK, so that's what it looks like when I do that.

insightful?

i maintain that OW never made any bad films, but 'macbeth' is better than 'othello'

I, too, haven't seen a "bad" Orson Welles movie yet.

The Stranger probably.

Bad performances he's got, er, tons of.

If performances like his are bad, I don't really give a care about good ones.

He's hopeless playing a straightforward love scene (e.g. Tomorrow is Forever).

Well, yeah, who wants to see that? (Tho I was surprised at how rowr he was -- by his standards -- early on in Macbeth.)

I rewatched Ambersons last night; I always forget that's Anne Baxter as Cotten's daughter. She was allegedly 18 or 19. That scene where she faints in the drugstore AFTER Welles swings the lens away from her... who did THAT, ever, in Hollywood?

Tim Holt's fine as Georgie, as written at least. Love the way he says "Umph, strawberry shortcake" in the kitchen with Aunt Fanny.

The George-Mom relationship really isn't that compelling for an Oedipal drama tho. A near-great amputee of a movie, still.

Cotten is magisterial in a quiet sad way that's always killed me.

and that's after he's introduced slapstickily, exhibiting male fashion habits of 1900, then taking a pratfall.

the Baxter-Cotten chat about Indians is one of my favorite throwaway surreal bits in movies.

well, it's pretty thematically relevant, tho I'm not sure if the chief who gets set adrift is Morgan or George...

(I wonder if it's in Booth Tarkington)

there's a bit in the Thomson bio where he observes that Welles make Tarkington as deep as Henry James whereas most screen adaptations of James look like...Tarkington.

btw I still own this on VHS recorded from the local PBS station twenty years ago

The most beautiful (and most nostalgic) shot in the film has to be the iris at the end of the snow ride:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mJxgrxl5BRM

The George-Mom relationship really isn't that compelling for an Oedipal drama tho.

one of the most fucked-up things about what RKO did to 'ambersons' is that they didn't just cut stuff, they actually RESHOT a couple of scenes to make tim holt more 'sympathetic' and less of a dick. so it was probably more intense in the original cut.

sabotage and all, this feels like welles's...deepest and most resonant movie, somehow. so many little bits of it just stick with me.

Then he fades in on the wake of George's father. xp

Is there a list somewhere of the post-Welles changes that are in the film?

The Callow bio reviews them.

i probably woulda voted for amberson or chimes, but as pure entertainment, c.k. has never stopped being a hoot.

Yes--I couldn't remember exactly what it was, but I knew the iris shot got some of its power from the contrast with whatever directly followed.

Essentially saw The Lady from Shanghai for the first time the other night (part of the Godard series). I did see it once years ago, but it was one of those nights I was really tired and shouldn't have gone to a movie. I knew the finale very well--it used to be part of the opening montage for TVO's Saturday Night at the Movies, and I've also shown it in class.

Anyway, fantastic. I'd have to watch them back-to-back, but I think I'd take it over Touch of Evil. Probably just as strange, too, primarily thanks to Glenn Anders. His first appearance has to rank up there with Welles in The Third Man and Hopper in Blue Velvet for spectacular entrances. (Possibly a thread there.) At first I didn't think Hayworth was as beautiful as in Gilda, but once she started wearing those sailor suits, wow. And the big finale is show-offy genius. Can't disagree with my friend: you can imagine Welles working on the script, sitting there with the last scene written and trying to figure out a movie to attach to it. Loved Everett Sloane, too. Hayworth gets a little too talkative and philosophical in her death scene, but that'd be my only minor quibble.

Apparently it was cut by at least an hour too. At least as much of a pity as Ambersons' mutilation imho.

Digital restoration of Othello showing soon.

Glenn Anders' film career was almost non-existent--he doesn't even get a little thumbnail photo on IMDB. Seems he was much more of a theatre guy.

You always want to have access to the director's original film, especially Welles, but it's hard for me to imagine where he would have gone with the extra hour--it really did seem close to perfect as is.

http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-4aduA-eWwAg/UKWOli6MGXI/AAAAAAAAvAM/RibsFQ9JpfA/s400/a+Orson+Welles+The+Lady+from+Shanghai+Rita+Hayworth+DVD+Review+PDVD_014.jpg

well, sure it's hard for US to imagine...

http://www.filmcomment.com/article/a-face-in-the-crowd-glenn-anders

I've tried LFS several times, each time bored. I dunno if it's Welles' performance or the movie itself that's attenuated.

it's very funny!

Someone take Alfred out for a little tarrrrr-get practice.

(Kidding. I'm often on here expressing ambivalence about famous films. I must have been in exactly the right frame of mind this time.)

Essentially saw The Lady from Shanghai for the first time the other night

Me too! If, over the past several decades, you had asked me if I had seen it, I was certain I had. But I really only knew the hall of mirrors finale; everything else was new to me. What a crazy movie.

The Lady from Shanghai would be vastly improved if he didn't have that shit Irish accent, but still it is brilliant. The opening sequence of The Stranger is awesome, I quite love it but it is a failure of sorts. Both CK and the Ambersons are movies I will continually re-watch until I die.

Just noticed that The Lady From Shanghai soundtrack has a quote from "Amado Mio," one of Rita's big numbers from Gilda.

This tune: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2czNzWnkOcI

trying to go through all the ones I haven't seen yet and if there's a worst one I think Alfred is right, it's the Stranger

love everything else to varying degrees. still need to see Othello, the Immortal Story and the Fountain of Youth

The Stranger is the most nakedly commercial, and i always found it totally fine. Mr Arkadin and The Trial, while more ambitious and... stranger, take some getting used to.

it's not that The Stranger is bad, it's just that everything else is better! Or at least has more interesting things going on. Welles' performance isn't remotely convincing, and the rest seems fairly standard.

Mr. Arkadin is bonkers and a lot of the cast is appropriately scenery-chewing (my favorite being Welles drunkenly staggering around on the swaying boat) so although it is a mess in terms of narrative and pacing I give it points for being fitfully engaging instead of just boring.

Visually the Trial is fantastic. The constant jabbery overdubbed Welles' dialogue gets soporific though.

just saw lady from shanghai (part of a double feature — touch of evil is next). as I’m sure everyone agrees, the ending is fantastic. welles’ accent didn’t bother me nearly as much as the sound editing (unless it was just the theater?). I thought the courtroom scenes were probably the weakest part of the movie, and while she is very easy to look at, all the closeups of hayworth were a little distracting, but overall a really good film. agree with clemenza about grisby’s entrance

imo, F for Fake is hugely overrated. The idea was clever, but not enough to carry a full length film, and certainly not a full length film as poorly executed as that one was.

alright touch of evil fucking ruled

the opening long shot, wow, I need to find that and watch it again

some incredible performances in this — welles especially, heston, andthat fortune-teller lady

a really unnervingly charming blend of camp and menace

andthat fortune-teller lady

touch of evil gets better every time i see it, there isn't really another movie that's anything like it

otm

the opening long shot, wow, I need to find that and watch it again

some incredible performances in this — welles especially, heston, andthat fortune-teller lady

a really unnervingly charming blend of camp and menace

― k3vin k., Sunday, June 23, 2019

I had the pleasure of showing it in my film class last Thursday, and I was delighted that half the class rode the groove even when it unnerved them. The idea of Heston playing a Mexican amused them; the quasi-rape scene did not.

I was a little more nagged-at by The Lady from Shanghai's filler when I watched it last night: the courtroom stuff (although Everett Sloane's soliloquy about Welles's fate is memorable), and, if I'm honest, just a lot of the film when they're not in the aquarium and not in the funhouse. The story is convoluted and absurd (hardly an anomaly in the world of noir). But those two scenes and Glenn Anders as Grisby make up for everything (Rita Hayworth in a sailor suit, too). Grisby is like Timothy Carey in The Killing, or Joseph Wiseman in Detective Story (or Dennis Weaver in Touch of Evil)--it's hard to say if Anders is even trying to remain in sync with the film you're watching, or if he's simply off doing some other movie known only to him, and if the two happen to intersect, all the better. Visually, the aquarium scene is somewhat of a practice run for the funhouse later on, and the funhouse sequence was the clip I showed my last few primary classes in trying to demonstrate what a film director did. The original trailer for the film is on YouTube--there is conspicuously nothing from the funhouse sequence, suggesting that Welles wanted to extract every last iota of astonishment from anyone who went to see the film. (There's a fan trailer that uses the funhouse liberally.)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R3lW5UKsbP4

k*r*g*rg* has The Other Side Of The Wind

Strange way to spell "Netflix".

Tbf that post was made 10 years before it was on Netflix.