Twin Peaks: Classic or Dud?

i can't even believe someone would pose this question. twin peaks is so obviously one of the best television shows ever created that anyone who thinks otherwise automatically gets written off, by me at least.

I feel the same about cheese.

Got Season 2 last night. The next few weeks bode well.

For a supposed "best TV show ever," TWIN PEAKS goes downhill pretty far, pretty fast. Remember the stuff with James and the vixen (which just... ends, as if the writers knew how awful it was and pulled a plug somewhere)? Or super-strength Nadine? Or anything with Josie Packard? The Dick Tremaine/Andy/Little Nicky thing actually comes across as one of the better subplots during the show's worst dry spell, just subsequent to Leland Palmer's death.

And if you don't think I'm hardcore enough, just read upthread. I am O.G. TWIN PEAKS.

supernadine was sooooo lol!!!
yeah s2 gets really soap opera!
i actually never finished it!

is because so many different writers, so many different directors, mark frost and david lynch having less direct involvement iirc

supernadine was sooooo lol!!!
yeah s2 gets really soap opera!
i actually never finished it!

what site am i on again? youtube?

kinda wishing you were

hey fu amateurist!!

ok!!! yay!!!

I've said it before & I'll say it again: Even "bad" Twin Peaks is great camp (& wicked parody of soap-opera-type drama, even in unintentional) and the black lodge storyline segue into wtf finale totally makes up for whatever shitness claims might be directed at the second-season lull IMO.

http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_jJSCzAHbXm4/R2YlSUlldOI/AAAAAAAAAkQ/TEvUq0vwBm0/s400/FinderScreenSnapz001.jpg

amateurist, i get breathless when josie is on screen. and i suck dick.

gay guys love joan chen

i guess that i sort of enjoy the descent into campiness. i think the only sub-plot i truly loathe is the one involving the woman and james, but i also hate everything involving james, so that's a given.

• his hair
• his face

<3 that subplot. The one I can't quite get with is the Andy/Dick/progeny-o-Satan storyline, but at least that one only lasts a couple episodes.

I'll admit that James is, in general, very punchable.

yes, with a brick.

joan chen is a pretty woman, but after the first season all the plotlines with her go nowhere (er, she shot agent cooper why exactly?), and her acting is consistently painful.

actually, the whole mill/ghostwood thing, on a recent reviewing, is pretty dull from the start.

i love all that local politics shit!

when it's purely humorous it's funny, but all the machinations with catherine/ben horne/josie/hank/leo/etc. get pretty dull--and incoherent--pretty fast.

i guess that was their "plot B" all along, but it never seemed worthy to me. (or maybe "plot B" was james/donna, and this was "plot C"--i dunno if they theorized TV like that back in 1990; sure do now.)

IMO of course.

you hate pretty much everything about this show afaict

yeah why don't you just stfu

Laura Palmer was on an episode of House recently and it was so strange to see becasue I haven't really ever seen her in anything else.

*sigh*

tehresa and roxymuzak, you can read upthread for my more positive thoughts on TP, dating back to 2003 ... as i welcomed you to do a few posts above.

also, if i'm not mistaken, isn't roxymuzak like a 40-year-old single mom or something? then why is she posting like a 12-year-old who hasn't had her snack yet?

because im 29 and havent had my snack yet

oh wait, you're the one who was at the pilot light in knoxville when i was there. never mind. i get ILX people mixed up.

no kids btw. why are you being such a bitch today? its just twin peaks dude!

kinda wishing you were

― kid cruti (roxymuzak), Monday, August 3, 2009 1:03 AM (2 hours ago) Bookmark Suggest Ban Permalink

hey fu amateurist!!

― tehresa, Monday, August 3, 2009 1:04 AM (2 hours ago) Bookmark

you hate pretty much everything about this show afaict

― kid cruti (roxymuzak), Monday, August 3, 2009 3:41 AM (10 minutes ago) Bookmark Suggest Ban Permalink

yeah why don't you just stfu

― tehresa, Monday, August 3, 2009 3:43 AM (8 minutes ago) Bookmark

hstencil left ilx, someone had to fill the void.
xpost

you realize those are by two different people, correct?

xpost hahaha

yeah, sorry roxymuzak, i guess tehresa was being more of a pain. but i felt a bit abused. peace.

i'm sorry my posting style = being a pain.
fuck off you gigantic twat.

tehrbota

what

sometimes the SB feels good

I'll say it: James is hot. Minor league hot, but still hot.

And, yeah, not much of a fan of season 2.

"Just You" - Classic or Dud?

ONE OF THE MOST CLASSICALLY LOL THINGS IN THE HISTORY OF EARTH

that's one of the better moments in the 2nd season, and not surprisingly it's a david lynch-directed episode.

i wouldn't call it LOL (at least, it doesn't make me LOL), it's certainly odd but quite beautiful in its way.

i'm sorry my posting style = being a pain.

your posting style was just asinine. it's telling me to "fuck off" that qualifies you as being a pain. but as a wise man once said around these parts, i don't even know who you are.

one thing that makes that sequence so odd = do we ever see james with a guitar, or singing, prior to this episode or after it? i don't believe you. it ties in, i suppose, with his whole persona ("wild one"-style biker, hair that hints at an elvis pompadour), but it just announces itself as a conceit so forcefully. why does this out-of-nowhere moment please me so much when others irritate me? i suppose because it doesn't pretend to be of any consequence to the plot.

i don't believe SO.

sorry for typos! writing fast.