GIRLS talk (the Lena Dunham thread)

Though commentary tracks with Dunham would be priceless.

would prefer commentary from Kirke and Mamet tbh

would prefer a commentary track from the Gallaghers

wld be hard to get liam and noel to collaborate on something

I'd like to watch the show (only ever saw the first season) and am winking at my loved ones re: this boxset but looks like the seasons are all piecemeal and most aren't even available

lol Simon

for Xmas xp

rewatch of the whole series is mostly just confirming my initial impression - there is a severe dropoff that sets in around season 3, and by season 4 we are in largely joke-free melodrama territory where every episode gets at least one terrible "emotional" musical montage moment of people being angst-ridden in bed or walking down lonely streets or whatever. Really goes off the rails by expecting us to have an emotional investment in a cast populated almost entirely by delusional narcissistic jerks.

Really goes off the rails by expecting us to have an emotional investment in a cast populated almost entirely by delusional narcissistic jerks.

https://pixel.nymag.com/imgs/daily/vulture/2018/11/07/always-sunny-dance/07-always-sunny-mac-9.w700.h467.2x.jpg

yeah I didn't like that episode either

yeah it's not so much that it obsesses on inconsequential things (which plenty of good entertainment and fiction does) as that it asks the audience to treat those things as much more consequential than they are

https://forward.com/schmooze/415469/lena-dunham-apologizes-admits-she-lied-to-discredit-alleged-rape-victim/

Lena and her wacky gaffes

Trump: “I dumped a bunch of old uranium in the refugee camp because I hate kids.”
DSA guys online: “He’s so funny.”
Lena Dunham: “I’m sorry for my mistakes. I guess I’m human.”
DSA guys online: “I hate that stupid woman. I am so angry. I am squeezing my medical rage ball.”

— Don Hughes (@getfiscal) December 6, 2018

you know he's being ironic right

but kudos for actually posting a tweet from a good poster that people actually follow for once

You’ve missed this one

Lol

Was that a good tweet? I don’t think it is.

Xp

seriously tho when you're a White Feminist really the only thing you have to do is not libel survivors, peak "you had one job" shit

Anyway, Lena’s actions here were harmful. I think she was trying to defend a friend and was probably in denial, but that in no way excuses it.

a lot of how celebrities act now is most entertainment is being made by rich kids is how i break it down to an extent

but she's not literally hitler so stfu

?

he's being ironic

Sounsa like Lena means that the guy accused told her stuff that wasn’t true. Headline is bad.

Yeah, but she said she had privileged information which proved it wasn't true. She now admits she made that up.

Think it through a bit more. I know he’s known for ironic posts but there’s a clear joke there and he makes fun of group think among people he politically agrees with all the time.

“While our first instinct is to listen to every woman’s story, our insider knowledge of Murray’s situation makes us confident that sadly this accusation is one of the 3 percent of assault cases that are misreported every year,” they wrote, concluding, “We stand by Murray and this is all we’ll be saying about this issue.”
Read more: https://forward.com/schmooze/415469/lena-dunham-apologizes-admits-she-lied-to-discredit-alleged-rape-victim/

“I didn’t have the ‘insider information’ I claimed but rather blind faith in a story that kept slipping and changing and revealed itself to mean nothing at all,”
Read more: https://forward.com/schmooze/415469/lena-dunham-apologizes-admits-she-lied-to-discredit-alleged-rape-victim/

Xp not really

Think it through a bit more. I know he’s known for ironic posts but there’s a clear joke there and he makes fun of group think among people he politically agrees with all the time.

― Nerdstrom Poindexter, Thursday, December 6, 2018 12:06 PM (eight seconds ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

his online personality is from the POV - feigned or real - of a trad cath and stalinist. he pillories the dsa regularly, usually in a clearly playful, but consistent manner

Yeah that means she believed her friend

no you are bad at reading

what does “I didn’t have the ‘insider information’ I claimed" mean in fucking centrist moron language?

She’s not coming back Jim

Xp “my friend privately assured me it wasn’t true”

i feel like literally every single one of her myopic fuckups was eminently avoidable

xp. “I didn’t have the ‘insider information’ I claimed but rather blind faith"

Probably

Her ability to repeatedly kick herself in the junk is incredible.

Okay. “I believed my friend who privately assured me it wasn’t true” . “she made up stuff” is reaching.

She misrepresented the quality of the information she had, implying it was more than just a private assurance. It was bad so she apologized.

if you're going to defend her at least read what it actually says nerdstrom. She admitted that she lied. She claimed to have some kind of specific knowledge that she didn't actually have.

if nerdstrom isn't 51'd some day soon I'm going to... do nothing at all

fp'd myself for troll feeding

That’s very big of you Jim I appreciate that

ironic revive given that I just re-watched the #metoo GIRLS episode (which was better than I remembered it tbh)

was one of the best girls episodes imo, like many of the eps where dunham gets the writing credit

the final shot of this parade of women going up to the guy's door was v good and maybe the only time the show deviated from its commitment to realism...?