Damon Lindelof's Watchmen

This sounds dumb and bad and unnecessary and I can't understand why anyone beyond the people making money off of it would want it to happen.

Those issues are sacred ground

"The wishes and moral rights of Mr. Moore and Mr. Gibbons, however, are worthless shit that I will spend many, many millions of dollars to disrespect and dishonour."

word

This is basically 'okay, I know there was already a film adaptation of (let's say) A Confederacy of Dunces a decade ago, but I think it would make a really great TV show. No, we're not re-adapting it or formulating a sequel. We're taking the beats, the essence of the novel, and we're gonna shake things up a little. Like what if Mr. Ignatius J. Reilly was actually disgruntled blogger Ms. Ignatia ORLY? What if that? I envision a minimum of five seasons. I've already picked out a yacht. Thank you, HBO.'

he explicitly says Gibbons has given his blessing (although I don't blame you for not reading the entire thing)

Watchmen is an obsessively-detailed, hermetically-sealed world where pretty much everything worth exploring is explored within the text itself and which is tailor-made for its specific medium. I'm hard-pressed to think of a work less in need of adapting, let alone adapting twice (and let alone everything DC has done to strip the corpse down to the bone over the past several years).

he explicitly says Gibbons has given his blessing (although I don't blame you for not reading the entire thing)

I didn't know there was anything to read, but am doing so now. "Dave said he would offer me his blessing if I really felt I needed it to calm my soul" is even less of an endorsement than Gibbons' PR statement on Before Watchmen, "You know and I know that these are worthless wastes of paper, but I got paid already."

speaking of which, some high-quality endorsements on Lindelof's instagram:

jimmypalmiotti RED THE SILK SPECTRE MINISERIES that came out a few years ago...you will fall in love with it.

we all know what happened to Jack Kirby and yet we're first in line for every Marvel film

uh no, ppl who know what happened to Kirby explicitly refused to see even Marvel films by directors they were intersted in while Marvel was actively suing Kirby's heirs

yeah I was not down with that shit.

I saw Guardians out of interst in Gunn, but only once Mantlo's brother had made press statements of "I'm not allowed to publicly say that Marvel gave any money towards the care of my permanently brain damaged brother because they will not create any kind of precedent for creator credit or royalties or charity or health care, but WINK WINK Bill would be happpy WINK WINK if you go and see it WINK"



we all know what happened to Jack Kirby and yet we're first in line for every Marvel film

^ this is an open declaration of "I don't actually get it"

I read it as an admission of guilt

Lindelof's description of this make me think of the first season of Fargo, which was quite good.

On the other hand, Damon Lindelof is not Noah Hawley.

Correct, his last series was way better than any Hawley stuff

Tbh FARGO probably is a great comparison point in terms of spinning off a great isolated, self contained work into a longer, expanded format, I just personally think it sucks shit

in the tradition of the work that inspired it, this new story must be original

chef kiss

Nice catch. Although maybe Lindelof is totally aware of what he's saying and the show will actually feature slightly altered Watchmen characters in the same way Watchmen features slightly altered Charlton characters.

(Narrator: Lindelof has no idea what he's saying.)

not here for the lindelof slander by people who haven't seen leftovers

like the mother of a murderer cryin that hes changed hes changed hes a good boy my boy, mfers sitting here in 2018 telling me i have to see the latest thing this cunt was involved in before i judge

a lot of people whose opinions i respect tell me the leftovers is good and i’ll def get around to watching it at some point but if u don’t think this next project will be the perfect catalyst for lindelof to get right back on his bullshit and then some u are frankly out of ur goddamn mind

not here for the lindelof slander by people who haven't seen leftovers

voodoo knows what's up

Damon Laurence Lindelof (born April 24, 1973) is an American screenwriter and producer. He was the co-creator and showrunner of the television series Lost (2004–10). He has written for and produced Crossing Jordan (2001–04) and wrote for Nash Bridges (2000–01). Lindelof also co-wrote the science fiction films Cowboys & Aliens (2011), Prometheus (2012), Star Trek Into Darkness (2013), and Tomorrowland (2015). He wildly smacked his ape paws against the keys for long enough that he eventually and wholly accidentally co-created the TV series The Leftovers for HBO, adapted from the novel by Tom Perrotta.

it's almost like he writes for money!

Exclusively so, even!

The Babaloo Mandel of our generation.

how quickly we forget akiva goldsman

what really haunts me about Goldsman is that he's credited with most of the best episodes of Fringe

i choose to believe that fringe was orchestrated by alternate-universe versions of goldsman, abrams, orci and kurtzman, who all returned to their dimension after their work was done

lmao

anyway to sum up The Case For Why I Think This Will Be Good so I can just lie down and die on this hill

1. the vast majority of the stuff that was bad about Lost mostly comes down to poor planning and production mishaps, which Lindelof has pretty freely acknowledged and taken his knocks for (hell, he even consulted Mike Schur on What Not To Do when planning a high-concept TV show)
2. The Leftovers slaps and I would put money down on this using a bunch of the same creatives. lest we forget TV is a deeply collaborative medium and if nothing else the dude has proven he can put together a very talented bench
3. the direction laid out in the letter (diversify, find new angles, no more apocalypses) all sound good and productive to me

Of all the terrible ideas about Watchmen, this one sounds like the least terrible

The best idea remains: do nothing, give Alan Moore rights back

I'm willing to buy bg's theory on Fringe

Nash Bridges was good, this is the hill I'm going to die on

i do apreciate simon's argument that lindelof's watchmen's gonna be good because he'll hire writers who are better than he is

Trying to think of things that are easier than hiring writers who are better than Damon Lindelof. Eating, breathing...I'm sure there's a third.

Ahem, excuse me, just burped out a writer who created Lost and The Leftovers, my bad

anyway to sum up The Case For Why I Think This Will Be Good so I can just lie down and die on this hill

none of these explain why it is a sensible, useful, or not-offensive idea to do

The sensible and useful reasons are "to make money, because capitalism" and the not-offensive reason is "gtfo with your hand-wringing on behalf of a relatively small number of malcontents, because capitalism."

Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons are malcontents?

"because capitalism" really carries a lot of weight eh

lmao "offensive"

would you have preferred unethical

Who knew that a little Lindelof was all it would take to get Simon to finally champion capitalism.

(Lindelof or the notion of butthurt nerds, not sure which really.)

on the list of capitalism's sins, the violating of old intellectual property is reaalllly low

also realllly easily remedied

You're moving those goalposts like an old pro! Welcome to the dark side, Simon, we've kept a seat warm for you.

if you want something less dramatic, "because we think it will make money"

lmao moving goalposts, I already said I think the show will be good and don't care about Tarnishing The Legacy or w/ever, p sure zooming out to get mad at capitalism (which, yes, is absolutely my jam) is when the goalposts moved

"old intellectual property"

DC's #2-seller for 2017

if I read Simon right he thinks that the quality of the final product will trump all ethical concerns. Both propositions are highly suspect, but for different reasons.

what's more annoying: unironic sneering at "funnybook nerds" or saying "lmao" at the start of every post

i vote both

(ie 1) that the product will be any good and 2) that the quality of a product overrides all other concerns about how it is made)

xp