Panel Discussion - The ILX Comic Strip Poll Results

Get Your War On such a Bush-era thing, from back before we all stopped really even caring about wars

=51: LITTLE LULU by Marge (54 points, 3 votes)
Marge and Lulu: The Art of the Deal

You might be thinking of the comic books, done anonymously by John Stanley.

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/d/d9/Firstlittlelulu022335.jpg
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/1/1d/Little-lulu-1943-marge.jpg
http://www.lambiek.net/artists/image/m/marge/marge_lulu2.jpg
http://photos1.blogger.com/blogger2/1656/3636/400/marge_lulu1.jpg

=49: PEARLS BEFORE SWINE by Stephen Pastis (55 points, 2 votes)
Universal

Pearls Before Swine is a syndicated comic strip that runs in 750 newspapers around the world. The strip pairs an angry, arrogant Rat with a sweet but dumb Pig, the latter of whom is protected by a violent, albeit delusional Guard Duck. Pig and Rat’s friends also include a bookish, intelligent Goat, and a poor, besieged Zebra whose only goal is to keep from being eaten by his inept and inarticulate next-door neighbors, the Fraternity of Zeeba Zeeba Eata crocodiles. Oh, and there are some lemmings who kill themselves.

https://fashionsspeaklouder.files.wordpress.com/2010/02/bwvnkw.jpg

http://www.indyweek.com/binary/7417/1349599133-pb100823__library_fine_.jpg

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content//photo/2008/08/13/PH2008081302511.jpg

http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-07XFuj_4A-o/TZOKOy7zmJI/AAAAAAAAAVo/idmzYjd33Wg/s1600/pearls%2Bbefore%2Bswine%2B2011%2B03%2B30.gif

=49: WONDERMARK by David Malki (55 points, 3 votes)
Wondermark

C19th illustrations detourned for ironolols.

http://www.wondermark.com/comics/013.gif
http://www.wondermark.com/comics/147.gif
http://www.wondermark.com/comics/119.gif

http://www.wondermark.com/comics/260.gif
http://www.wondermark.com/comics/275.gif

i like marge's original LL cartoons a lot, really wish they'd get a full reprinting. it's funny how little resemblance they bear to the john stanley comics -- lulu's personality seems very different.

Yeah, it was interesting to see how distinct Lulu is when I was looking for images. How late did it run or reprint anywhere? Genuinely curious how much exposure the voters had (obviously, from the blurb)

couldn't you just have had a post with the word "wondermark" and left it at that?

you assume Wondermark is going to be the best-known strip in the entire poll?

can we just like maybe post a list of the rest of the results

I was happy posting the results! sic wanted to do it.

I blame the poor reliability of undersea fiber to Australia

try kale.

should be re-rolling out as soon as I'm unemployed & have moved 10,000 comics and records into storage

=47: TERRY & THE PIRATES by Milt Caniff (56 points, 4 votes)
Complete in six volumes.

The adventure begins with young Terry Lee, "a wide-awake American boy," arriving in contemporary China with his friend, two-fisted journalist Pat Ryan. Seeking a lost gold mine they meet George Webster "Connie" Confucius, interpreter and local guide. Initially, crudely drawn backgrounds and stereotypical characters surrounded Terry as he matched wits with pirates and various other villains. He developed an ever larger circle of friends and enemies, including Big Stoop, Captain Judas, Cheery Blaze, Chopstick Joe, Cue Ball and Dude Hennick.
Most notable of all was the famed femme fatale, the Dragon Lady, who started as an enemy and later, during the war, became an ally. Caniff included a number of non-American female antagonists, all of whom referred to themselves in the third person. These included the Dragon Lady herself and crooks and spies like Sanjak and Rouge. In a rather bold move for a 1940s comic strip, Sanjak was hinted at being a lesbian cross-dresser with designs on Terry's girlfriend April Kane.[3] Caniff purportedly named the character after an island next to the isle of Lesbos.
Over time, due to a successful collaboration with cartoonist Noel Sickles, Caniff dramatically improved to produce some of the most memorable strips in the history of the medium.

http://allstarcomicart.com/auctionimages/uploads/775_2.gif
http://www.loc.gov/exhibits/cartoonamerica/images/ca062-06582v.jpg

http://cdn.comicartfans.com/Images/Category_10270/subcat_93001/CANIFF_TERRY%20SUNDAY_CAF.jpg
http://cdn.comicartfans.com/Images/Category_5676/subcat_10373/Milton%20Caniff%20-%20Terry%20and%20the%20Pirates%20Partial%20Sunday%20Comic%20Strip%20Original%20Art%20dated%2011-19-39%20Chicago%20Tribune%201939%20small.jpg

=46: GARFIELD by Anonymous Employees (58 points, 6 votes)
The official web site for the cool fat cat with games, fan club, e-cards and online catalog.

Jim Davis created and contributes jokes to this comic strip about a fat cat who is lazy and likes lasagna, and his proto-Redditor owner. Piggybacked on the format of B. Kliban’s “dead cat” cartoon books, and was so successful it became the default format for strip collections for a decade.

http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_M6vB-ENvPwQ/Rg8qZTytkSI/AAAAAAAAACM/6DHr6JtwTpA/s1600-h/Garfield.gif
http://www.mezzacotta.net/garfield/comics/0129.png
http://www.reocities.com/televisioncity/5479/garfcomc.gif

debut strip:

http://www.comicmix.com/media/2007/06/19/garfield_19_jun_1978.png

Because someone had to:

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/B_D7ZpkVIAAXHR8.jpg

what the

idg this poll, the rollout, or the joke in that Garfield strip

the joke in that Garfield strip is that Jon just drank a cup of dog sperm

Does dog semen resemble coffee in any way

Apart from being hot when freshly made

I'm not familiar enough with dog semen to say

but... drinking dog semen doesn't make you pregnant. so the implication is that the cup contains ... dog pregnancy test results? idgi

which would be (I guess) dog urine (or blood)? neither of which resemble coffee.

Garfield hates puppies

but... drinking dog semen doesn't make you pregnant.

oh my god dude

maybe Garfield is pregnant with puppies somehow

learning so much here

I have other obvious observations if yr interested

but... drinking dog semen doesn't make you pregnant.

Now you tell me.

guys you are missing the point

garfield hates puppies

you are missing the point

jon arbuckle don't mind if he does

wow that is basically a Kliban cat in that first strip

Finally, this thread got good.

I can imagine the impact these Terry strips must've had in 1941:

http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-VPxxntqLM3w/VAOl9qL1YwI/AAAAAAAADWs/j8bw7LpoStI/s1600/Raven.JPG

Caniff was the master; having him place behind fucking garfield is just well i mean it's an ilx poll but on no poll anywhere should that happen

^^^

results are utterly baffling

lol, i started this thread literally over a year ago.

It's hard to compete with Anonymous Employees.

since Terry was 56 pts, 4 votes and Garfield 58 pts, 6 votes, I don't need to do any complex math to suggest that their relative placement in this poll was essentially a coin flip. One might consider it a flaw in the Borda count that a candidate that 4 people ranked an average of 36th out of 50 (was it 50?) might lose to a candidate 6 people ranked an average of 40th out of 50. Especially if 4 of those 6 people also voted for Terry in a higher position. (Apparently this is a violation of the "later-no-harm" criterion, thanks Wikipedia.) You might be able to use a single transferable vote instead and get slightly less goofballs results when you get beyond the "overwhelming consensus" part of the poll

Terry and the Pirates is too wordy. Garfield, on the other hand, is in-and-out. A set-up, a situation, a punchline – then OUT.

Shoulda been ten places in between them.

=46: GET FUZZY by Darby Conley (58 points, 4 votes)
Universal

This daily strip features the squabbling dog and cat of a Boston advertising executive, it says here. Truly a Garfield for our modern times.

http://www.quotationspage.com/weblog/wp-content/uploads/2007/07/getfuzzy2007261870726.gif
http://images5.fanpop.com/image/photos/30500000/Get-Fuzzy-bruce-willis-30555056-1650-1275.jpg
http://images2.fanpop.com/images/photos/6000000/Get-Fuzzy-get-fuzzy-6025370-725-378.jpg

Garfield placing behind Get Fuzzy = on no poll anywhere should that happen

Yeah, that one just shut my mouth.

Get Fuzzy often eschews the traditional "setup-punchline" format of most funnies, instead building on absurd dialog between characters.[1][2][3][4]

this seems like a longwinded way of saying 'has no good jokes'

Garfield tied with Get Fuzzy.

http://www.citizenx.cx/img/comics/get_fuzzy_food_anything.gif
http://www.argon.org/~roderick/tmp/favorite-comics/Get%20Fuzzy-2004.06.20.jpg
http://photos1.blogger.com/blogger/6782/168/1600/getfuzzy2006043261710.jpg

Guys I am starting to suspect comic strips are all quite bad

I like to think that Satchel and Bucky are both stuffed animals IRL. We just never see them in that form since fucking Rob Wilco never leaves the house and has no friends.

What a world.

http://i.imgur.com/Gc7ehwl.png