Magic: The Gathering C/D

ready/willing is gonna lead to some total blowouts

yeah, i like that deck a lot. i actually spent last night trading/buying the cards i needed for it in paper so i can play a version of it at the ptq/wmcq this weekend. i'm not running the gyre sage 'version' and only two domris but its been pretty good for me so far. my only match losses so far have been to g/b aggro (which i think is just a bad match-up and thankfully a fringe deck) and the prime speaker list. i was worried about jund but you can run them out of answers reasonably well

so the Dimir mythic is pretty much what everyone expected, right?

if its real then yeah it's not great. would still like to see one more pushed dimir card, since so far the guild has been completely absent from standard other than the occasional 1-of dimir charm. far//away and notion thief seem playable, not sure about warped physique. cipher is still lacking the constructed-pushed card that all the other guild mechanics have, though i'm not sure what it'd look like. maybe they actually thought people were going to play soul ransom, or find a way to break whispering madness?

and of course duskmantle seer has a really high power level but i have no idea how to use it still, might have to wait for rotation

the hate card for it shows up months too late

My favorite is Seedtime, the supposed answer to Fact or Fiction. Wizards hyped this card up a ton in the previews, didn't make a dent in Standard. The metagame had moved a bit past FoF by the time it came out anyway.

armadillo cloak is back! with a new name though since lifelink isn't quite the same rules-wise

http://media.wizards.com/images/magic/tcg/products/dgm/tiwoirwiixix/spzkwz3www_EN.jpg

BUG suddenly doesn't seem so horrible...

ha, I remember Seedtime opening around $10. it quickly settled around 10 cents.

i do like R&Ds new policy of making the hate cards useful otherwise so they're not just dead if you don't hit the thing you're hating

http://media.wizards.com/images/magic/tcg/products/dgm/tiwoirwiixix/vhlr9buvxs_EN.jpg

that seems really good but there has to be better finishers out there

there are better finishers but it's also useful not as a finisher

its certainly the most resilient as long as you have blue mana up

when drownyard's gone, revelation decks will need a way to kill people before they deck themselves so there's certainly a market for 'creature taht can never die if you have blue mana up'

also you can play it early and then blink and wrath later if opponent's board can beat it

well it essentially costs 7 mana so I dunno what "early" really means here

well i meant 'early' as in 'before you've drawn half your deck and taken complete control'

full set spoiler monday

yep, always curious whether there's something big that slipped through the preview week cracks like boros reckoner did last time around.

looks like the rest of the cards are starting to leak out now though from whoever had the early copy of the fat pack encyclopedia
http://forums.mtgsalvation.com/showthread.php?t=504862

I think this is gonna be a really fun set

Hidden Strings 1U
Sorcery
You may tap or untap target permanent, then you may tap or untap another target permanent
Cipher Common

has a lot of potential

put it on a one drop and a blue deck can cast a 4 mana instant on its second turn

I could see Crypt Incursion being a nice sideboard card

the beetle mage is awesome for limited

damn that's a common?

3/1 haste for BR seems pretty good

That's gonna be an annoying card for sure. Can even be pumped as an instant.

heh xp Spike Jester looks like one of those Constructed cards that's a little under the radar - it's way better than Chainwalker, which has seen play in some mono-red decks.

yes, that card is potentially quite good. haste is one of the best abilities in constructed because creatures don't live that long

jesus, Craterhoof is now worth 15 tix online. wish I wasnt so stupid when I did AVR and just sold everything

well i couldnt have predicted that one either

whoa, I just noticed that if you play every common evolve creature in order (Cloudfin/Shambleshark/Crocanura/Anemones/Snapjaw) that you hit every evolve trigger. cool

GTC Phantom Sealed is starting to make me hate myself. I can't seem to catch a break with this thing.

I think I need to admit that I'm just not very good at GTC.

Yeah I constantly 1-2 those things with wonky Simic/Gruul decks. I never seem to get like 5-6 of the good common Orzhov guys like everyone else does and my Boros is often garbage. Or I get like 18 cards to a good Dimir deck. I have real terrible luck with getting Gates that match the colors I want to play, too!

even when I get a decent pool, I seem to undermine myself by mis-clicking or letting time run out

gatecrash is also not a very good sealed set. play some RTR sealed, it's more fun

yeah rtr sealed is 10x more fun

had a pretty nuts deck in paper draft today:

frontline medic
wrecking ogre
gift of orzhova
boros charm
3 x daring skyjek
2 x wojek
sunhome guildmage
3x syndic of tithes
3x court street denizen
skynight
warmind infantry
cinder elemental
armored transport
martial glory
righteous charge
angelic edict

yeah the boros decks ended up being the most fun to play but they are never ever open on mtgo

complete spoiler is up on the wizards site - haven't looked through much of it yet but i am v v excited to draft this set

this is gonna be rad

great cards all around

feel like the rtr guilds might be slightly ahead overall

maw of the obzedat is my fav art in a long time. is it a cat?!

card is sweet too. there are really just gems the whole set around. draft is gonna be great fun, and a total deckbuilding exercise as opposed to GTC which was completely a signal reading exercise

looking at the full set guild by guild, i'm noticing that each guild has exactly one multicolored creature at common. none of them are particularly good. meanwhile, all of the multicolored guild cards are at uncommon, and the stable of uncommons is really quite solid.

meanwhile, we have a range of monocolored commons. their power level is lower than the uncommons, but they only commit you to one color.

the tradeoff thus becomes: do we spread ourselves thin taking a spread of powerful uncommons/rares early, and then hoping we can zero in on a playable 23 cards later? or do we settle in on one color/guild at a time? or do we adopt the "gobble up the early guildgates" strategy? i think each of those approaches could prove fruitful or disastrous.

this draft environment is really really really gonna reward going in with a specific vision of what you want your deck to look like. every pick is going to be incredibly challenging. GTC rewarded play skills, DGM is gonna reward draft skills. we're gonna need to know the archetypes inside and out to have any success with this.

i really don't think there are going to be archetypes per se, i would hope/expect it to just be really fluid and most decks will trend towards midrange so you'll want to look for card-level synergies to get you ahead. also you should be drafting the gates pretty high and if other people aren't you can really take advantage of that by setting yourself up to steal all the individually powerful cards in packs 2 and 3

thought about this more and there definitely are archetypes still but they're more about what your deck is doing than about rigid gameplans like in the single set formats. like for example there's the +1/+1 counter abuse deck but that could be simic+golgari or it could be one of the two simic colors plus rakdos, or it could be simic plus one of the two rakdos colors. likewise, there will be the aggro deck which is probably going to want to have boros and/or rakdos in it for the cheap above-curve creatures but the other half could be azorius, gruul, or even izzet which all have mechanics that punch damage through in different ways.

I really have no idea what this'll be like but a lack of too many "junk" commons + the 15th slot being a dual land instead of a basic means that DGM will likely have a lot of influence on your final deck and honestly I just don't see 2 color decks working

2 color's not supposed to work, its supposed to be 3 by default. so 2 would be equivalent to playing a mono-color deck in most normal formats, which is only very occasionally viable

i'm trying to envision a scenario where you could hit one guild super hard but it just doesn't seem possible. what's going to be interesting is that if you go like Red/Blue/White then you get Boros in GTC and then Azorius and Izzet in RTR, so you have to hit RTR hard even though it's the 3rd pack. also all that artifact destruction may be nice with the Cluestones floating around.

my problem is going to be keeping it to 3 colors and not always going for 4 or 5.