The Haunt Of Fear: ILX Top 100 HORROR Movies Poll Results Thread

contenderizer, love ya, babe but you're rong about Crash (1996) and rong about the end of Rosemary's Baby

Just saw a trailer for a flick called The Good Doctor. Dead Ringers fans might bite.

#73 Dr. Giggles

britishes must've gone to sleep early or are playing darts b/c there's no threads discussing yet!

contenderizer, love ya, babe but you're rong about Crash (1996) and rong about the end of Rosemary's Baby

people gots all kinds of ideas

wah wah, my eyes melted, nuclear winter, wah

that's ok they can just discuss threads later on other threads

or maybe they were so emotionally scarred from threads that even now, almost 30 years later, they STILL can't bring themselves to discussing it.

Still have to see it. Neat points/vote ratio.

oh yeah 40+ points per vote, that might be the highest average so far i think

i still haven't seen it, toying with the idea of youtubing it now, before bedtime.

yeah that's a good idea, sweet dreams

thanks x

i hear that it is a lighthearted romp

2 hours long though? heavy.

How's everyone's ballot doing so far? Of the 40 I voted for, I think 5 are accounted for.

I've only got one! :(

i've placed 4 so far (may, pontypool, phantasm and creepshow)

1/50 (Picnic at Hanging Rock). Super-excited for the rest of the poll.

2 hours long though? heavy.

― second only to popcorn (or something), Thursday, May 17, 2012 5:13 PM (1 minute ago)

it takes a while for society to completely collapse in 3 generations

I didn't vote for Pan's Labyrinth because it's fantasy to me, but it did blow me away. Interesting that Abbott compared her reaction to it with Plague Dogs, as those are the two movies I think of when I think of times I was reduced to a weeping mess during end credits.

Just took the trouble of dividing my ballot up by threat type. Monster, Witch, Demon and Vampire all tie for the lead with 7 entries each. If I count Psychic and Possession as the same thing, there's seven of those too. Nature only has one and Zombie only has two.

For the record, and so it is known -- I am not a fan of sexy vampire lit or movies outside of Nosferatu. Crap is crap and Herzog's Nosferatu is not crap.

LOL there was a Herzog festival in Seattle in like '95 and I got to write an article for the Stranger about it. I wrote that his Nosferatu was 'the only great vampire movie' (whatev, I was in my 20s and liked proclamations). Stranger film editor Andy changed it to 'one of the greatest vampire movies'.

So I started things of smoothly with Possession earlier in the day. It's about 8 hours later now and I don't even feel even remotely articulate enough to form a reaction that goes beyond a startled "Wha...?".

Ha ha. What a delightfully wrongheaded notion. "Starting things off smoothly with Possession, indeed. Memories of that movie are like PTSD-induced flashbacks.

I've got 3/50 - near dark, onibaba, and blood on satan's claw

hmmm kinda wondering now if Pan's Labyrinth fits the description upthread of movies where evil triumphs but it's not such a bad thing

Hmmm though if I look only at my top 10 it's a 3-3 tie between Witch and Monster...

xpost to self

xp - yeah, maybe! she becomes one of them.

I watched threads the other day, half out of legit curiosity & half b/c I was having a hard time finding good images online and holy hell u should prepare yourself to be pummeled relentlessly by bleakness. Genre-wise, I wouldn't classify it as such for obvious reasons but I'm pretty sure it is horror by default.

hmmm kinda wondering now if Pan's Labyrinth fits the description upthread of movies where evil triumphs but it's not such a bad thing

― Roger Barfing (Shakey Mo Collier), Thursday, May 17, 2012 2:23 PM

i wonder how the orphanage will place?

3/50 so far. Phantasm, rec and FWWM, which somehow makes a rather odd combination.

Apart from this, learned that I definitely should take a closer look on Picnic At Hanging Rock and The Seventh Victim.

4 so far: picnic..., duel, cabin..., wolf creek.

Ha ha. What a delightfully wrongheaded notion. "Starting things off smoothly with Possession, indeed. Memories of that movie are like PTSD-induced flashbacks.

― Bob Bop Perano (Deric W. Haircare), Donnerstag, 17. Mai 2012 23:21 (18 minutes ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

I was set for intense/heavy stuff, but I honestly didn't expect it to be that verschwurbelt. Which, as I have to confess, diminished the real impact (at least) on me quite a lot. Being fully aware that this will sound like a sacrilege, but I would have pereferred a bit more coherence, as the setup (Adjani, Berlin, Mauer, Gloom, the early Eighties) is prime for tragic suspense, and to pull some emotional strings too.

Well, not to single you or your response to the film out, but I always feel that it's valuable for viewers to critique movies on the basis of what the movie is trying to do and not on the basis of what the viewer wished the movie had done.

it is pretty bonkers, though. you can hardly expect everyone to stay in the saddle all the way through.

Exactly, was writing something in the same direction, seems to be a case of high/wrong expectations.

Nevertheless, and not to be misunderstood, I consider it an excellent movie in many aspects, from the camerawork to Adjanis performance etc. Quite a ride.

This was in response to DWH.

Maybe I somehow secretely hoped for a blueishly lit and furnitured East-German sequel to Don't Look Now.

sam neill is insane in it. i was expecting something different but once i gave up and went with it... made my ballot anyway.

I think it was incredibly helpful that I knew absolutely nothing about Possession before I saw it. And also that my girlfriend had just dumped me a couple of weeks prior.

yeah, i figured. it's anything but a sequel to don't look now, though. closer to a sequel to dementia, what with the "mind of a lunatic" POV. for me, the only thing about the movie that's really a hard sell is sam neil's performance. adjani just goes at it 100%, is completely present and convincing in almost every moment. neil can't quite get to those extremes, is by nature a rather awkward and mannered actor, and adjani's manic intensity only makes his mark seem that much more robotic. i like the tension between the two, but can see why it might be bothersome.

xpost

I was kinda primed for the experience, is what I'm saying here.

my xp was xp to graushleier

agree w deric. first saw possession without knowing anything about it or its reputation. rented it when anchor bay put out the restored original cut in the late 90s just cuz the box description sounded promising. came as a complete surprise and reduced my brain to ashes.

I'm 2/35 thus far--just Dressed to Kill and Dead Ringers. I've got a number of sure-things left; I'll probably end up between 15-20/35.

for me, the only thing about the movie that's really a hard sell is sam neil's performance. adjani just goes at it 100%, is completely present and convincing in almost every moment. neil can't quite get to those extremes, is by nature a rather awkward and mannered actor, and adjani's manic intensity only makes his mark seem that much more robotic. i like the tension between the two, but can see why it might be bothersome.

yeah that's interesting. but others in this, like the guy she's cheating with, seem weirdly theatrical too. adjani's is the most naturalistic performance in the thing, in a weird way. xp.

They're kind of all just different flavors of batshit.

re: Neill. True, but it's clearly the least rewarding role, to play against such characters like Anna and Heinrich.

Like, I saw Possession and The Ninth Configuration around the same time, and I was much more convinced that everyone in the Possession-verse was profoundly mentally ill.

it does seem as though they are. few film so effective capture and communicate the tense, skin-crawling horror of profoundly distorted perception. it's got a heavy bad trip vibe, imo.

^^this.

tho we should save all this for when it places in the top 20.

5 so far: Cabin in the Woods, Paranormal Activity, FWWM, Pontypool, & Creepshow

xpost

Better be at least top ten or it's on.

(It's probably gonna be on...)