Doctor Who: Classic or Dud?

Message Bookmarked
Bookmark Removed
Not all messages are displayed: show all messages (1836 of them)
Oh, I think the Peter Howell theme is fairly well-known among DW / RW circles (I only fit into the latter, not the former). And nothing divides opinion more: disciples of 80s mainstream production techniques *love* it, but everyone else ...

Robin Carmody, Sunday, 24 June 2001 00:00 (twenty-five years ago)

Leela temporarily reappeared more recently as a phony-Italian with stroppy kids in Albert Square - Rosa DeMarco.

K-reg, Sunday, 24 June 2001 00:00 (twenty-five years ago)

Isn't Leela played by Louise Jameson? Also played Jim Bergerac's estate-agent girlfriend in er, "Bergerac".

Dr. C, Monday, 25 June 2001 00:00 (twenty-five years ago)

Dr C lowers the tone...

mark s, Monday, 25 June 2001 00:00 (twenty-five years ago)

I heart Louise Jameson. And Mary Tamm. And Janet Fielding. And Wendy Padbury. And Elisabeth Sladen. And *hangs head* Nicola Bryant.

Did you all see the mid-90's TV movie with Paul McGann and Daphne Ashbrook? Any comments?

Dan Perry, Monday, 25 June 2001 00:00 (twenty-five years ago)

Was that the one where they invented a new enemy who moved faster than light and had no face? It was lame. The McGanns are the UK Baldwins, except that Canada has (inexplicably) failed to bomb their house yet.

mark s, Monday, 25 June 2001 00:00 (twenty-five years ago)

No, that was the Five Doctors, 1983.

Magnus, Monday, 25 June 2001 00:00 (twenty-five years ago)

Doctor Who = best TV theme music and visual ever. But Blake's 7 the better show. Or maybe not: Blake's 7 was more soap opera than tech based plots (not that I recall a single plot from either, other'n Blake's 7's final: plot = "everyone dies"). Anyhoo, both shows had alien robots made from bits of cardboard. And monsters that looked like random bits from a hardware store glued together: bolts, old circuit boards, couple rubber bands, strips of sandpaper, and a lick of paint. Those rock. (Cf. budget contrast w/ US counterpart Logan's Run.)

AP, Tuesday, 26 June 2001 00:00 (twenty-five years ago)

McGanns = UK Baldwins? FEAR.

There's a great Doctor Who book floating out there called _Interference_ where the Doctor runs into an enemy who completely FUBAR's his past timeline. I love that idea and I'm kind of bummed out that the show never really exploited that aspect of time travel (ill-conceived Valeyard aside).

Dan Perry, Tuesday, 26 June 2001 00:00 (twenty-five years ago)

one year passes...
I know it's lovely weather out and all that but surely some of the people who've arrived since June 26th 2001 have an opinion on Doctor Who?

Tico Tico (Tico Tico), Wednesday, 7 May 2003 12:57 (twenty-three years ago)

Revive these threads as well, go on...

Doctor Who assistants - Search/Destroy
The Man That Ruined Doctor Who
Doctor Who Weekly/Monthly comic strips - Search/Destroy

Alan (Alan), Wednesday, 7 May 2003 13:07 (twenty-three years ago)

MIND FITE!!!

Grr! (starry), Wednesday, 7 May 2003 13:11 (twenty-three years ago)

HSA claims to *HATE* Sci-Fi. Yet, on the basis of Castrovalva, even he had to admit that Dr. Who was pretty darn cool. Hah!

kate, Wednesday, 7 May 2003 13:11 (twenty-three years ago)

I still haven't seen that. Sarah when I get a place you must come round and watch some hot Doctor action.

Castrovalva is rubbish though!

Tico Tico (Tico Tico), Wednesday, 7 May 2003 13:13 (twenty-three years ago)

The best record in my mum's record collection is probably her 7" of the original Doctor Who theme.

The VERY FIRST companion was Susan, who was the doctor's DAUGHTER? No? She was interesting, it being 1963 and therefore pre- pop, let alone pre-Kate Millett: cuz she was SUPER-CLEVER, and the earth-boys were baffled and threatened and intrigued by this. But I don't remember her to look at since (a) B/W episodes never repeated

I remember the surviving B/W episodes being shown on UK Gold when UK Gold first started, in the early 90s. I think Susan told everyone that she was the doctor's granddaughter, but this might just have been a ploy to explain why he was her guardian to boring Earth people.

My favourite Doctor Who related thing is probably Dirk Gently's Holistic Detective Agency, a Douglas Adams novel put together from late-70s Doctor Who scripts that were never broadcast. (as was the third Hitchhiker's Guide To The Galaxy book)

caitlin (caitlin), Wednesday, 7 May 2003 13:16 (twenty-three years ago)

Castrovalva has 2 fun episodes, 2 boring episodes, a rubbish disguise, Michael Sheard, and a disappointing special effect which probably sounded great in the script. perfect.

Alan (Alan), Wednesday, 7 May 2003 13:18 (twenty-three years ago)

The grebtest cameo appearance EVER is in CITY OF DEATH (this == my fave Dr Who story I think, apart from FACE OF EVIL) where John Cleese and er.. some bird pop up in the Louvre, analysing the Tardis as a GRATE ARTWORK - someone pls fetch Turner Prize stat!

Exquisite. Simply... exquisite.

Tico - The BRANE OF MORBIUS should only be attempted after a couple of cans of RELAXANT in my opinion cos it is very silly. Also you will be annoyed by the rubbish assistant who falls over a lot. The priestesses are brilliant. But yes I am up for DOCTOR ACTION.

Secret flame! Secret fire!

Sarah (starry), Wednesday, 7 May 2003 13:18 (twenty-three years ago)

Castrovalva irritates me cos it's two basically unrelated and not-that-good stories shoved together. Oh and the boring episodes are SO BORING. Where is the Doctor's casket??? zzzzzz. The Castrovalva set is lovely though.

Also the invention of real actual computers was catastrophic for Dr Who cos they insist on using them and seeing Z80 graphics on futuristic screens is more horrible than any rubber monster. Castrovalva has a particularly poor eg of this.

Tico Tico (Tico Tico), Wednesday, 7 May 2003 13:24 (twenty-three years ago)

The Brane Of Morbius is incredibly silly and very great fun indeed. Anything featuring a perspex Smash alien head with a brain inside is fine by me.

RickyT (RickyT), Wednesday, 7 May 2003 13:28 (twenty-three years ago)

Classic! My favourite two episodes are Pyramids of Mars and The Talons of Weng-Chiang, because sci-fi and Victorian England is a good combination. And I like the rubber-suit monsters - much more fun than cheep computer graphics.

fletrejet, Wednesday, 7 May 2003 13:32 (twenty-three years ago)

"It's like wrestling, but with Time Lords"!

It is vvv amusing in Castrovalva when they are reading up on ZERO CO-ORDINATES on what looks like a primitive Teletext reader. I do not like the assistants there cos one of them IIRC tried to SHUN K-9. Bah humbug.

K-9 did a STERLING job in the Sun Makers.

Sarah (starry), Wednesday, 7 May 2003 13:33 (twenty-three years ago)

Given comment:

X = reason why someone (who generally does not like Genre of which X is example) started to like Genre

Typical nerd response:

X = RUBBISH!!!

I hate nerds.

kate, Wednesday, 7 May 2003 13:33 (twenty-three years ago)

Eleanor Bron was the bird. The Man Who Ruined Doctor Who's reign was full of extremely k-rub guest stars. and CEEFAX GRAFFIX database is a grebt idea, in fact where's that php code...

Alan (Alan), Wednesday, 7 May 2003 13:35 (twenty-three years ago)

Kate my girlfriend only started to like dronerock when she heard the last Spiritualized album!!!

Tico Tico (Tico Tico), Wednesday, 7 May 2003 13:35 (twenty-three years ago)

The Man Who Ruined Doctor Who's reign was full of extremely k-rub guest stars

This leads us to a question I asked Mrs Tico Tico last night - why exactly was Beryl Reid famous again?

Tico Tico (Tico Tico), Wednesday, 7 May 2003 13:36 (twenty-three years ago)

I loved Dr. Who when I was little. It was all just totally bizarre to me, very colorful and full of weird sound effects. I can't remember any of the characters names (ha ha, except Dr. Who), but I have a deep respect for the show.

Sarah McLUsky (coco), Wednesday, 7 May 2003 13:37 (twenty-three years ago)

The last SPZ album is not dronerock. It is syrupy orchestral pop. If that made her investigate and appreciate the rest of SPZ's back catalogue and move on to SP3 and the VU, fair enough.

What I am trying to say is that for some people (including HSA) the rubber suits and stupid aliens were a turn-off, which distracted him from being able to appreciate the clever plots and interesting concepts which made Dr. Who so fantastic. Castrovalva had no rubbish monsters, but it did have an amazing concept.

So you get all these nerds going "My appreciation of Dr. Who is superior because I can look past the rubbish rubber monsters" (or even "I *like* the rubbish rubber monsters") which totally disregards the point that it is the concept and plots and writing which makes Dr. Who a cut above the usual rubber monster sci fi rubbish.

kate, Wednesday, 7 May 2003 13:42 (twenty-three years ago)

Sylvester McCoy was a good Doctor. There, I've said it.

Mostly because he could do the thing that still sets great Dr. Who stories apart: a fairly stable system which suddenly has a relentless resourceful force of chaos rampaging through it.

Andrew Farrell (afarrell), Wednesday, 7 May 2003 13:44 (twenty-three years ago)

The phenomenon that was Beryl Reids fame has been under some discussion at Sinclair Towers of late, again without satisfactory conclusions as to its cause.

RickyT (RickyT), Wednesday, 7 May 2003 13:46 (twenty-three years ago)

Yeah fair enough Kate - the concepts in Castrovalva are very interesting and unusual for Dr Who (or other sci-fi TV from what little I know), but I think the writing is pretty grievous and the plot is shaky: much better if they'd just set the whole thing on Castrovalva and built the mystery up slowly. I still enjoyed watching it so "rubbish!" was meant in an amused but fond tone not in a dismissive one.

I am a nerd, but I wasn't trying to pull a move of 'oh no that's not part of the canon' or 'oh no that's not obscure enough' - Castrovalva is highly regarded among Dr Who fans I've discovered, but that regard baffles me a bit.

Tico Tico (Tico Tico), Wednesday, 7 May 2003 13:49 (twenty-three years ago)

As Sci-fi, Doctor Who was a joke (maybe a few episodes excepted). Doctor Who was more of an adventure series than sci-fi. But I agree the plots and writing were mostly good-great, and most importantly the show was FUN to watch, which makes it much better than tedious soap operas like Star Trek and its spin-offs. I am glad in the US Doctor Who never caught on w/ the fanboy community, therefore being spared from being taken too seriously by people.

fletrejet, Wednesday, 7 May 2003 13:56 (twenty-three years ago)

Beryl Reid. Psychomania http://www.britishhorrorfilms.co.uk/psychomania.shtml

spplutter, I am glad in the US Doctor Who never caught on w/ the fanboy community WHAT??

Alan (Alan), Wednesday, 7 May 2003 13:57 (twenty-three years ago)

>spplutter, I am glad in the US Doctor Who never caught on w/ the fanboy community WHAT??

I have not been to that many conventions, but at the ones I've been to, the Doctor Who presence was miniscule compared to Star Trek, Star Wars, anime, etc.

fletrejet, Wednesday, 7 May 2003 14:00 (twenty-three years ago)

yes, fair point, the Dr Who fanboy community is, err, niche

Did anyone* see the Cruise of the Gods one off drama on telly this past Christmas. A bit sappy, but funny stuff and well observed, obviously from 1st hand experience.

* these people did http://www.delgados.co.uk/dailydiary_1201.htm

Alan (Alan), Wednesday, 7 May 2003 14:15 (twenty-three years ago)

Cruise of the Gods, har har. The bit where the geekboy made him sign all of his fan fiction was funny if only for "ouch" factor. Heh.

kate, Wednesday, 7 May 2003 15:05 (twenty-three years ago)

The Brane Of Morbius is incredibly silly and very great fun indeed. Anything featuring a perspex Smash alien head with a brain inside is fine by me.

if you watch carefully at the end, when Morbius falls off the cliff his claw falls off, revealing the act-or's hand underneath.

DV (dirtyvicar), Wednesday, 7 May 2003 15:36 (twenty-three years ago)

Yeah, I saw that cruise show. Pretty good.

As for Dr Who, I liked it as a kid and stopped watching soon after Tom Baker left, and have hardly looked back since. I watched the one off filmed special and thought it was utterly misjudged, same as everyone else.

Martin Skidmore (Martin Skidmore), Wednesday, 7 May 2003 19:20 (twenty-three years ago)

Tom Baker, K-9, Leela, + THE PIRATE PLANET. OMFG Douglas Adams wrote the best villains ever. Still one of my favorites.
*is ostracized forever*

Millar (Millar), Wednesday, 7 May 2003 19:54 (twenty-three years ago)

(That was Romana I, not Leela.)

Dan Perry (Dan Perry), Wednesday, 7 May 2003 20:01 (twenty-three years ago)

'The Five Doctors' ruled. i started watching towards the end of the Davidson era so remember the Colin Baker episodes with some fondness (esp. Trial of A Timelord) even tho he may have been the George Lazenby of Timelords...the McCoy was a bit of a mixed bag but 'Remembrance Of The Daleks' brought memorable scenes such as the Special Weapons Dalek thing and Daleks finally getting up stairs thanks to some weird hover-beam thing.

stevem (blueski), Wednesday, 7 May 2003 20:31 (twenty-three years ago)

I was naming favorites, not the the cast of that particular episode

Millar (Millar), Wednesday, 7 May 2003 20:36 (twenty-three years ago)

Of course me naming Dr. Who faves is about like me naming my favorite classic hip hop songs, eg something I like but have had not nearly enough exposure to

Millar (Millar), Wednesday, 7 May 2003 20:38 (twenty-three years ago)

Doctor Who is great because it has heart. I just watched "The Seeds of Doom" the other night, such fun. The audio dramas are also a lot of fun, especially the ones with Paul McGann, being addicted to Doctor Who is more expensive than many drug addictions.

fortunate hazel (f. hazel), Wednesday, 7 May 2003 20:57 (twenty-three years ago)

a fairly stable system which suddenly has a relentless resourceful force of chaos rampaging through it.

This is the best one sentence description of Dr. Who ever.

I heart Dr. Who. But growing up I generally preferred UK SF TV (Dr. Who, and all the Gerry Anderson shows) to the tedious American ones.

Chris Barrus (Chris Barrus), Wednesday, 7 May 2003 21:06 (twenty-three years ago)

I have all of the Virgin and BBC books from _Timewyrm: Crucible_ through _Trading Futures_.

Dan Perry (Dan Perry), Wednesday, 7 May 2003 21:12 (twenty-three years ago)

Has anyone else here ever seen the Tom Baker erm... biopic (for want of a better word?) where he sits in front of a tv, and is shown his own Dr Who episodes he hasn't seen in years?

It is utterly hilarious - if you've ever seen the Rowley Birkin QC drunk character from the Fast Show, then that's what it was like. Dear old Tom rambling away with stories that had bugger all to do with the episodes he was supposed to talk about (eg: "ah! Well, now, I don't recall a thing about this story, but I do know there was a delightful barmaid at the lovely little pub nearby. Smashing").

Towards the shows end he got all maudlin when he went over the fact that apart from a couple of guest spots on things, he's never really been succesful since. It was all rather sad.

Great viewing if you can find it, I wish I could remember the name of the thing.

Trayce (trayce), Wednesday, 7 May 2003 21:20 (twenty-three years ago)

Argh! We just watched the dumbest horror film (called Hypercube - sequel to Cube, which was actually pretty cool) which was a dead rip-off of Castrovalva! Hah!

kate, Thursday, 8 May 2003 08:08 (twenty-three years ago)

This morning I checked out my friends DR WHO collection and saw one called SPEARHEAD OF SPACE (or something - the first John Pertwee one) where the aliens have a super ability to CONTROL PLASTICS. Ph33rs0m3 or WOT!

Actually it *did* look rather ph33rs0m3 cos from the blurb on the back they seem to be taking over the world by controlling MANNEQUINS THE WORLD OVER. Arrrgh!

Why did I not steal this video? It is because I am a FULE. Also I forgot my shopping bags. Groo.

Sarah (starry), Thursday, 8 May 2003 08:21 (twenty-three years ago)

Dr Who was huge among my friends when I was very small -- and moreso, among my friends' older brothers -- because Star Trek wasn't in reruns and Battlestar Galactica had been cancelled, so it was the only sci fi television that was on (via PBS, which is the public television network here, for UKers who don't grok).

However, I've never seen it, except for the made-for-TV movie.

If I were to start, -where- should I start, and is it on DVD?

Tep (ktepi), Thursday, 8 May 2003 08:25 (twenty-three years ago)

http://www.staff.ncl.ac.uk/damon.querry/dvd/

ignore the 2 doctors and the varos one

Alan (Alan), Thursday, 8 May 2003 08:32 (twenty-three years ago)

sic, aldo, whoever, do you know how far "yellow fever" got and how much of this "recon" is just shitty ao3 fanfic?

afaik the sequence is this:

1981-10-22: the first two episodes of hit co-pro Tenko are TXed, filmed in Singapore

1981-11-05: episode 3, the first of a remaining 28 filmed in Dorset dressed as Singapore and introducing Louise Jameson to the cast, airs

1984: UP is invited to a convention in (Singapore or nearby country?), and asks the BBC for money for him and his assault-enthusiastic partner to take a holiday and location scout on the way back.

1984-10-19: UP and GD shoot some camcorder footage on a day out in Singapore.

1984-10-26: Holmes is sent the tape and asked to write a story set in Singapore, called "Yellow Fever And How To Cure It."

...

uploading this content requires perseveration (sic), Saturday, 14 March 2026 06:54 (three months ago)

previously, part 1:

UP had gotten pissed and laid on holiday at Mardi Gras in 1981, and thought it would be fun to get paid to go back and do it again, if the BBC would fund a story to be shot in New Orleans.
In late 1983, UP gets a verbal agreement from the company that distributes Who to PBS partner stations that they will co-pro on an American-shot storyline.
In November 1983, the week of The Five Doctors' TX (which preceded the UK's) UP asks a merry Troughton at a Chicago convention if he'd appear in such, and secures an agreement.
UP has already commissioned Andrew Smith for a new Sontarans story, the first in six years, but on learning that Frazer Hines has booked a sabbatical from the soap that he's been on for eleven years, to take place in the second half of 1984, UP sacks Smith circa January 1984 and asks Holmes to write a Sontarans story set in New Orleans.
Smith, for whom this would have been his second commission, gives up his TV dreams and becomes a cop, returning to writing 26 years later with a Companion Chronicles for Big Finish.

...

uploading this content requires perseveration (sic), Saturday, 14 March 2026 07:06 (three months ago)

previously, part 2:

Holmes did not like the idea of writing a story set in a specific place or bringing back old aliums for nostalgia, but he thought the two Sontaran stories that other ppl wrote were fuckin' stupid, so maybe he could make the actual joke again and see if it stuck. He proposed that the N'awlins aliens could be the second thing you thought of in connection to the city, rather than UP's suggestion of the first, as foodie monsters allowed for story possibilities, whereas monsters who enjoyed listening to jazz in their off-hours was shrug emoji.
With the 45-minute format, and a need to maximise the expensive filming locations, he pitched the longest DW story in 14 years.

1984-02-13: first episode commissioned.
1984-03-09: the other two episodes commissioned.

between the two dates, it turned out that a small regional distributor of BBC programming that had only come into existence 2.5 years earlier

-- and only because the previous distributor, media giant Time-Life, had illegally re-edited and censored the final (/only) season of Monty Python at the request of local US tv station ABC, leading to the members of the group gaining ownership of the programme from the BBC, leading Time Inc to go "well fuck you then" and drop the Beeb altogether --

could not actually afford to fund an entire British cast and crew on a month's location shoot across the Atlantic.

...

uploading this content requires perseveration (sic), Saturday, 14 March 2026 07:44 (three months ago)

(more later, my back started hurting so I sat down to post for the first time in two months and two cats sat on me)

uploading this content requires perseveration (sic), Saturday, 14 March 2026 07:56 (three months ago)

can't wait, really interesting to hear about the time/life -> lionheart thing, i thought there was more continuity between the two than that (specifically that the "time/life" who had distributed who in the US were fairly loosely affiliated and when time/life dropped them the people involved went on to form the backbone of lionheart? that could be a misunderstanding on my part though). i'm also very interested in the implicit propagandistic aspect of int'l distribution of Who stories... i've seen hints that there may have been some minor (no more than minor and probably incidental, to be clear) involvement by more formal, uh, _covert diplomatic_ elements.

i also was pretty ignorant of the monty python case and its implications... is is there more information on what's in these specials anywhere? i guess they're probably not circulating, though it's theoretically _possible_ for someone to have taped them off-air in 1975.

hope your back feels better!

Kate (rushomancy), Saturday, 14 March 2026 19:45 (three months ago)

correction: no convention in or near Singapore, he just pitched it outright as a Tenko cash-in ahead of the final series airing

previously, part 3:

1984-02-15: UP asks the Beeb if they'd shell out the full amount for the New Orleans shoot
1984-02-29: Trout and Jamie signed

1984-04-16: Beeb says no to US shoot
rest of April: UP suggests Venice instead; numbers are run and found to still be too expensive; a junior in the office suggests Seville, as she'd had a cheap holiday there earlier in the 1980s; UP cuts two (of eight) studio days & four (of twelve) location filming days, gets cast and crew to agree to minimal per diems, and books a holiday package deal with airfare, accom and breakfast included

early May:
Holmes reluctantly agrees to rewrite the three scripts of "The Kraalon Inheritance" to be set in Spain, throwing out 90% of the jokes, including a major throughline of differences between British and American English
making up for this reduction in humor, anagram enthusiast UP changes the aliums to an anagram of "gourmand," retitling serial "The Androgum Inheritance," and adds the name "Dastari" (A TARDIS).

late May:
in a helpful fever of creative contribution, UP changes the story title several more times, to Creation, Parallax, The Seventh Augmentation, The Seventh Amendment, and The Two Doctors.

June: fresh from the triumph of The Twin Dilemma, Peter Moffatt is booked as director, and hires two tall actors as Sontarans because he thinks they might seem non-threatening, even comical, if they are played as belligerent while being short. Or fitting into the costumes.

Cast and crew leave for location shoot 1984-08-07, with entire case of Androgum eyebrows and hairpieces getting permanently lost in transit. Various other disasters and illnesses plague the shoot, but Moffatt's efficient directorial style ensure no time is lost, even with only 2/3 of the shoot days available. Three studio sessions take place between August 30 and Sept 28, connecting us back to 1984-10-26: Holmes is sent the tape and asked to write a story set in Singapore, called "Yellow Fever And How To Cure It."

uploading this content requires perseveration (sic), Saturday, 14 March 2026 21:35 (three months ago)

(the Python eps are just cutdowns of eps 1-3 and 4-6 of that season afaik. presumably a) the details exist but b) watching off-airs or receations would only prove the court right: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monty_Python_v._American_Broadcasting_Companies,_Inc.)

uploading this content requires perseveration (sic), Saturday, 14 March 2026 21:41 (three months ago)

(the Python eps are just cutdowns of eps 1-3 and 4-6 of that season afaik. presumably a) the details exist but b) watching off-airs or receations would only prove the court right: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monty_Python_v._American_Broadcasting_Companies,_Inc.)

― uploading this content requires perseveration (sic), Saturday, March 14, 2026 2:41 PM (seventeen minutes ago)

yeah i just have an unhealthy interest in monstrous perversions, such as Stolen Assets' Clutch Cargo's Unnamed Superfan's Loose Cannon's photocomposite's Donald Tosh's John Lucarotti's The Massacre of St. Bartholomew's Eve. we're at the bottom of the uncanny marianas trench here lol

Kate (rushomancy), Saturday, 14 March 2026 22:10 (three months ago)

November 1984:
UP then asks him to add the Rani (a new bad Time Lady whose appearance was being shot at the time).
And to bring back the Autons, another alium monster creation from two Holmes stories, 14 and 13 years previously.
And to include the Master, the bad Time Lord introduced by Holmes 13 years earlier but never written again in the original character's run. Holmes had created a new, deadibones version of the character eight years previously, and never written it again. UP had debuted a third incarnation of the character three years earlier, used him in three consecutive stories, then in 14 episodes in another 24 months, and was also appearing in the currently-shooting story.

Having resented the "shopping list" nature of that year's previous commission, and been contemptuous of the requirement to rewrite it completely when the list turned out to be for a different supermarket, Holmes requests that the delivery date on the commission he was sent for the first episode be amended until after rights to use the Rani character, and to shoot in specific locations in Singapore, are secured.



...


1985-02-13: Holmes' agent is told that Singapore is confirmed, and subsequently sent a contract for all three episodes.

by 1985-02-25: Doctor Who is cancelled. After this hits newspapers on the 27th, the BBC announces that it's just taking a rest for a bit and the next season will air in 18 months.

early March 1985: Three of the six writers commissioned to write 45-minute-episode stories for S23 are asked to write them as 25-minute episodes instead for 1986, when S23 will be cut from 26 to 14 episodes.

late May: S23 is decided to be a single narrative, with all existing story plans dropped.

1985-07-09: Holmes' advance for 6x25 of Yellow Fever And How To Cure It is transferred to eps 1-4 and 13-14 of Trial Of A Time Lord.

uploading this content requires perseveration (sic), Saturday, 14 March 2026 22:42 (three months ago)

(sometime in the 90s?): UP tells DWM his very detailed plan for the two-and-a-half hour story that he asked Holmes to write: Peri asks to go home to the USA, the TARDIS lands and they see the Statue Of Liberty out of the scanner screen. They open the door, but it's a 12-foot replica in a cultural garden in Singapore. As they leave, they don't notice some statues moving (omg Autons!). Maybe the Master and the Rani have joined a travelling street theatre?

uploading this content requires perseveration (sic), Saturday, 14 March 2026 22:48 (three months ago)

sometime in the '00s: USF claims that he has the full three-part story outline and completed first 45-minute episode script.

By 2012, he says that he has mislaid the script, and the outline is somewhere in his shed, but his memories of reading them 27 years ago are so reliable that he has written a new 3-part version that he has had audio recorded and privately animated.

He also claims that in the revised S23, it was to be preceded by a story called Gallifrey, written by Eric Saward, which Saward had discussed in detail with him. This USF has also written himself and had animated, with changes to both in order to link planned themes and characters better.

The original story had conmen pulling a major scam, but in turn being used by a bunch of evil Time Lords, trying to frame Flavia and depose her. Eric and I had talked about it. Bob Holmes told him to expand on the Manchurian Candidate idea by having sleeper agents in place controlled by the evil Cardinal who would be the next President (Julian Glover). The ONLY element I added here was making it the Matrix secrets because they did crop up in the next story which was written by Bob Holmes, so they could easily have been used in Gallifrey anyway, as Bob was advising Eric on it. The Deadly Assassin had been one of the highest rated Doctor Who stories ever, and Eric, with Bob's guidance, wanted some more of that, and used the success factor to try to win JNT round to his way of thinking. After all, Arc Of Infinity hadn't exactly been a classic.

The original story ideas for both Yellow Fever and Gallifrey were both so outstandingly strong that they almost wrote themselves just by extrapolating each writer's original story plans.

In the real world, paperwork shows that Pip & Jane Baker were commissioned to write Gallifrey for the revised 25-min S23, but did not turn anything in before it was scrapped for Trial, and have confirmed they never put pen to paper. Eric Saward has confirmed that he never had anything to do with it, let alone writing an entire plotline and collaborating with Holmes on a half-year arc.

When presented with the paper trail on all the above, USF insists that Eric has a terrible memory, and that re Yellow Fever, Nick Courtney had agreed to be in it*, Peter Moffatt was hired to direct it**, the idea of the Rani being in it was dropped because Kate O'Mara was booked to be in the US shooting Dynasty for the entirety of 1985***, and that Holmes was still going to write Yellow Fever even after the entire season was scrapped for Trial****.

* never signed, never approached, never mentioned until USF's private animated version included UNIT
** the story never entered pre-production, as Dr Who was cancelled a little over a week after the story outline was requested
*** P&J were paid for the rights to use the Rani in January 1985. Kate O'Mara arrived in LA in mid-October 1985 to shoot her first episodes of Dynasty. Yellow Fever would have completed shooting before this.
**** Holmes formally withdrew from the YF commission when his fee was transferred to Trial.



By 2015, USF claimed that Gallifrey was commissioned for the 45-minute S23, and Saward argued that they should drop all the stories paid for, not just half of them in order to meet the reduced episode count, and UP was such a bitch that he then commissioned P&J to write the 25-min Gallifrey from Saward's outline, but that Saward "made such an almighty stink" that this commission was withdrawn a week later.

Eric finds this period so painful he has forgotten half of what happened, but Bob Holmes had offered the guidance of a mentor to Eric to write a story about con men, deposed Presidents, and sleeper agents with a hint of The Manchurian Candidate thrown in. Eric discussed the entire plot with me prior to the cancellation, but it never made it past the original story ideas as it would have been the last of the six stories to go into production, but Julian Glover was considered as the machiavellian arch villain President.

At this point USF revises his claim about Yellow Fever to be that he only ever had the outline, because Saward had been commissioned to novelise it for the Target book line, but later returned the advance and gifted USF the outline. Presumably due to trauma.

He also now says that

was a story about The Master, The Brigadier, UNIT, and Benton. The first half was set in London, with an Auton Prime Minister, the second half in Singapore. It would have been wonderful, especially with Graeme Harper directing.

It was very common to hire two directors in those days: a good one and a shit one.

The next paragraph from that version of the story is

I am really sick and tired of people spouting fantasy mistruths about this cancelled season.

One might propose a very specific solution to this frustration.

I always regretted its loss,down to being JNT's mouthpiece to Charles Catchpole of The Sun, and the dreaded Doctor In Distress, and I reconstructed three of the missing stories myself on audio, and did detailed visual recons on DVD of all six stories, with Nicola Bryant, Julian Glover, Milton Johns, Jon Levene, Waris Hussein, John Leeson, Nigel Plaskitt, Ian Fairbairn, and many many more. I am incredibly proud of them. Both Yellow Fever and Gallifrey were totally faithful to the original storylines.

I can 100% assure you all, no matter what anyone says to the contrary, that Gallifrey WAS to be the sixth story of that aborted season.

I apologise for not being able to track if this means that Gallifrey has moved from leading directly into Yellow Fever to following it.



Ten years after that: USF begs for donations to pay grifters to make multiple iterations of promptslop versions of Yellow Fever from his circa-2010 audio recordings of scripts that he had been able to type because the non-existent details he had imagined from never-existed outlines wrote themselves so comprehensively. He posts the results, to verifiable acclaim:

https://i.postimg.cc/dk6p6syr/Grf-BV4s-Xg-AAD7DQ.jpg

https://i.postimg.cc/8JNxLJjy/Gu-TRz-GCXs-AATMo2.jpg

uploading this content requires perseveration (sic), Sunday, 15 March 2026 00:02 (three months ago)

to wit,

the really bizarre stuff are his "reconstructions" of episodes that never existed, like "yellow fever". i tried watching one because i haven't ever actually seen a breakdown of the plot beats of it or know how far it got to having a script written. it was just so. fucking. bad. utterly execrable. sic, aldo, whoever, do you know how far "yellow fever" got and how much of this "recon" is just shitty ao3 fanfic?

The entire three-episode, 135-minute plot breakdown of "Yellow Fever And How To Cure It" consists of https://www.tripadvisor.com/LocationPhotoDirectLink-g294265-d324758-i202515446-Haw_Par_Villa-Singapore.html

uploading this content requires perseveration (sic), Sunday, 15 March 2026 00:09 (three months ago)

(but Holmes would have had to add fifteen minutes of extra detail for the six-episode version.)

uploading this content requires perseveration (sic), Sunday, 15 March 2026 00:13 (three months ago)

...

argh :( pics:

https://i.ibb.co/wFyCnXnq/Grf-BV4s-Xg-AAD7-DQ.jpg

https://i.ibb.co/Vc87RpT7/Gu-TRz-GCXs-AATMo2.jpg

uploading this content requires perseveration (sic), Sunday, 15 March 2026 00:16 (three months ago)

ah! this would explain why i have never seen anything about this supposed story mentioned in any other source, including richard molesworth's holmes bio, which i do have a copy of, read, and liked, but can't recall very well. in general i get the impression that molesworth is a reputable, reliable writer who seems to have done a good deal of research, in contrast to unnamed superfan, who gives the impression of having nearly the exact same talent for self-promotion possessed by UP without _quite_ the level same level of artistic refinement as said UP. which leaves just one mystery left to solve: how the hell is moonstone's cover of "the visitors" such a fucking banger?

this does remind me though that i do wanna track down a copy of the book by that guy who wrote an early, pretty much entirely abandoned, draft of "the ark in space". i forget his name. not lucarotti. whoever did the info text on "the ark in space" did a good job on those... i learned a lot from them.

Kate (rushomancy), Sunday, 15 March 2026 00:26 (three months ago)

well i can't say that unnamed superfan doesn't know his audience, at least.

Kate (rushomancy), Sunday, 15 March 2026 00:27 (three months ago)

two weeks pass...

ok, i went through and watched the first three episodes straight through - i'd seen "day of armageddon" before, but i figured there was no point in just skipping from episode 1 to 3. i'm glad i did, because it really brought home that there is just no larger story at all here - it's as close as the show came to a classic movie serial. it's just a bunch of stupid, random shit happening with no larger point or real respect for its audience, and i love the story so much for that. hartnell here is doing what i kind of think of as "prequel trilogy george lucas", which is to say, a sort of burlesque, exaggerated version of the character he was supposed to play, with almost complete indifference to the actual lines. this is just as well, because the doctor here is written as an absolute bumbling idiot who has nothing but terrible ideas.

like, the literal first thing the doctor does on this story is land on a random planet and go out looking for drugs. he doesn't know anything about this planet - its name, its population, whether or not its atmosphere is _breathable_. he's just like "oh, cool, a hostile jungle planet. well, i'll go see if i can find someone here who has drugs." then nick courtney shows up - and he's great, god, just a joy to watch. we get some great scenes of courtney's character, bret vyon, and kert gantry doing this very... well, in my head they're gay lovers, is all i'm saying. why not, if bret vyon is apparently sara kingdom's brother, you know? everything in this story is just shit randomly thrown at the wall, and some of it is fun. i actually enjoyed watching the scene where lizan and roald argue about what to watch on TV. there's this real feel of, i don't know, kitchen-sink sci-fi. characters argue for no reason and then bret vyon tells them to "shut up" and then billy hartnell does this whole character bit where he's like, well, ok, the script says i'm supposed to say "no, you shut up," how can i do that in a way that feels like the doctor? ok, the line wasn't written as "we must get through! the daleks will stop at anything to prevent it!", but you know what, i like it better the way billy says it. it's a dumb line. it doesn't deserve to be read as written. really this is not terribly different from how tom baker around season 17 would deal with lines of dialogue he didn't like, but tosh and wiles were trying to bring a real season 18 vibe to things. fortunately tosh and wiles were so shit that they couldn't even manage to get rid of a lead actor who clearly couldn't remember his lines and was not well enough to continue in the role...

anyway, this kind of thing is just perfect for terry nation, because he's great at writing filler and this whole story is nothing but filler. i didn't realize that the macguffin doesn't even show up until episode two! which of course leads us to the great scene where bret vyon does a stealth takedown of seaweed alien zephon, solid snake-style (clearly going for that big boss rank), at which point the doctor has the brilliant idea of tying up zephon, stealing his clothes, and infiltrating the conference pretending to be zephon. i mean, the doctor isn't, in fact, a seaweed alien, doesn't sound anything like zephon, and doesn't even steal, apprently, the only significant part of zephon's costume, zephon's blinged out necklace. he's just a random guy in a black robe covering his face who doesn't know anything about what he's doing or why he's there. he still manages to steal the macguffin, though, because, like i said, this story has no respect whatsoever for its audience.

i am really enjoying watching douglas camfield's direction. i don't have any strong opinions on richard martin as a director (HE'S STILL FUCKING ALIVE!?!?!?), but the show was fun to watch, and the good kind of stupid, and i think a lot of this is down to camfield bringing a certain amount of panache to the proceedings, even if there's just nothing he can fucking do with desperus. god, what a piss-poor excuse for a "prison planet". apparently everyone there is a caveman? like, if the cavemen from "100,000 BC" spoke english, it'd be basically the same fucking thing. i also have to say that clearly nobody had any idea at all how to write katarina, because as written she's a complete fucking idiot who believes she's dead and is incapable of understanding concepts like "keys" and "drugs". adrienne hill does the best with what she's given, which is, really, less than nothing. perhaps that's why i'm so fond of the character!

best discovery from the episodes - i have heard the complete soundtracks, but it hits different to be able to actually watch them - is that the doctor _invented his own bondage furniture_. i know there are a lot of weird things about the first doctor era of who, but even by those standards "doctor who, designer of kink furniture" is, uh, a little odd. for the record - i'm speaking as someone who's seen a fair amount of kink furniture here - the doctor should stick to his day job of saving the universe. dungeon interior design is not his forte.

---

technical notes: it doesn't seem to have undergone much restoration at all... episode 1 in particular looks not great... the closing credits scroll is obviously misaligned, for instance. i'm not really connected with broader fan communities... are these prints suppressed field or stored field? has their been much speculation on the source of the prints? like, we now have five of the eleven-ish episodes of this story, from three different recoveries... is it fair to assume that they're all from the same set of prints, either the set that we know was sent to australia or another set that was made at some point before the videotapes were wiped? like, maybe there was a set that went walkies in a way where it wasn't, like, extremely well valued or desired or cared for. these were just some old junk prints of some old TV show. and since they weren't valued, any or all of them could have been junked by now, or they could still be around somewhere. i don't buy into these "hoarder" theories where there's some superfan sitting on a hoard of 50 episodes that they're keeping for themselves... that's probably true in at least _one_ specific case, but given what i know of film collectors, a lot of it is just weirdo film collectors with weirdo film that they don't want to talk too much about because it's _technically illegal_ and they don't want to get in trouble, nevermind the fact that they don't even know what half of the shit they have is (hi, i'm a digital hoarder with way too much random uncategorized shit on her file server!)

Kate (rushomancy), Friday, 3 April 2026 23:30 (two months ago)


You must be logged in to post. Please either login here, or if you are not registered, you may register here.