Doctor Who: Classic or Dud?

please say that you said you liked it in 2009!

Did I mention that I gave up on DW this year? Because yeah. K-9 would probably be more fulfilling tbh.

I had the exact same "STOP RUINING MY CHILDHOOD" reaction, sorry

I like matt smith but the stories weren't really any good. Same with most of the Tennant era really. God help us if we ever get a colin baker type shit doctor.

I thought both "The Lodger" and the one with the Angels was very good. I think the big problem was that they had issues defining what the interplay between Amy and The Doctor should be; the initial episode strikes a very good balance but as the season goes along she sometimes veers into budget-Donna territory and isn't very convincing as a result.

Most of the stories were saved by Matt Smith's surprisingly great Doctor, though.

Season 5 is amazing, u mad. xp

Like, I love this season to a degree that I have to judge myself for liking it *too* much.

Rory was great pretty much the entire time he was onscreen, too.

All the Moffat-penned ones were good, all the ones written by others were a bit balls.

Lodger was the best of those though.

I liked the characters, they were great, but the stories just weren't there and haven't been for ages.

oh, and "Amy's Choice" was pretty great, too!

yeah actually I did like this season a lot

The only one I really disliked was the Silurian two-parter.

Oh yeah, forgot about Amy's Choice. I didn't think it lived up to its potential, but it was definitely decent.

Back to K-9 for a moment: how can this show be anything other than total garbage?

NO LAUGHING = NO K-9 THEREFORE ITS A COMPLETELY DIFFERENT ROBOT DOG AND HOW ABOUT YOU CALL IT ANOTHER NAME

In other news, I'm very much in love with Matt Smith

"Victory of the Daleks" was the season clunker IMO

ARGH I HAD GOTTEN THE HATRED OUT OF MY BODY AND HERE YOU ARE PUSHING IT BACK IN KILL THIS BASTARD K-9 AND ALL THAT IT STANDS FOR

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gx3tXw7TU58

NEVER FORGET

I love how we can get a huge new post count just because of a tin dog regenerating! lol

I want to be Sarah Jane in these credits, wearing legwarmers and drinking wine while I work. xp

Vampires in Venice and The Silurians were mediocre potboliers (also the new Silurian design was so bland!) The Van Gogh one was too slushy and manipulative, hello Richard Curtis.

aw I thought the Van Gogh one was nice. Nothing wrong with a sappy story now and again.

it says a fucking lot that I can look at the K-9 and company credits and go "lol, that is so dated and terrible, yet still endearing *chuckle*" when the them song includes K-9 SINGING of all things

K-9 paid his dues as a minor character & helping in adventures so the least they could do was let him sing his own theme song.

As long as that doesn't happen in the Rory spinoff.

Fairly vocally said I wasn't that impressed with this series, but it was better than maybe any of the DT ones (although there's actually a couple of really good eps in the Donna series, the first one is almost sub-Avengers).

I love A Girl's Best Friend, I really do. I have never managed to watch one of this series, despite the fact I have them lurking somewhere.

xpost I totally want Rory to sing his own themesong. Are you kidding?

Leeson tells a story somewhere (might be on the DVD for that) about recording the theme song, that Ian had him in to say "K-9" twice and that was it.

I have a feeling it would be indie-schmindie as hell. xp

I'm picture more 90's house

ugh picturing

Really, Tennant/Donna and Tennant/Martha were way way better than Tennant/Rose, which is kind of a shame because Rose is great.

Oh I saw the Cybermen episodes over the weekend with Rose in her alterna universe and I got SO sad bc I miss her terribly

I HATED Tennant/Rose. I think RTD starting writing Rose completely differently than in the first season, and she became this lovesick little groupie. xp

Rose was ballsy and great and I would fall in love with David Tennant too, who can blame her

(this is going to turn into a crazy cage match with chairs & ladders, I can feel it)

Naw, I know a lot of people really liked them together but I could just never get into it.

I feel kind of bad for spamming this thread tonight but I have to work late by myself tonight so I really have nothing else to do but talk about Doctor who.

martha was the biggest waste of space since adric

well the thing is at least with Martha was at least that was directly in the character from the beginning; with Rose it sort of seemed to pop in from nowhere and was kind of cruel and callous towards Mickey in the process

xp: OKAY NOW THERE WILL BE FIGHTING

MARTHA WAS FUCKING GREAT, AT ALL TIMES, FOREVER AND EVER AMEN

new K9 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Martha

Martha seemed a bit too meek or something. Like she never fully believed that it was even happening until RIGHT at the end and then where are you. Nowhere. but she was beautiful and she's an excellent addition to the Torchwood organization.

Donna was fun, I liked her, bc no worries about mooney eyes or falling in luff...and her family, old gramps and crazy Mum were fun. Like the old days with Rose's mum.

But my favorite is still Rose. And I liked how she was with Mickey, reminded me of ppl I knew in my hometown who had been dating since godknows when.

ugh rose's mum was the pits

RARRR BRING YER CHAIR AND YER LADDER, IT'S CAGE MATCH TIME.

Oh I quite liked Rose's mum, she was a recognisable type.

Martha yesterday
http://www.jaaroncaststone.com/pics/wood_info_pages/plank_example.jpg

I liked her better than Rose, tbh. xp

lol @ GiS. someone please photoshop martha onto one of these planks of wood
http://www.fox-hound.us/misc/Keanu-Plank.jpg

Amy Pond still drives me round the twist bc she's so flighty and sort of, bipolar or something. Fun, and strange and cute but also routinely want to strangle her

LOLWUT:

Bill Pullman (Ruthless People, Independence Day) has signed on to star in the upcoming fourth season of Torchwood as a regular. Pullman — who joins series stars John Barrowman, Eva Myles and the just-cast Mekhi Phifer — will play Oswald Jones, a dangerously clever convicted murderer who escapes his lifelong prison sentence on a technicality and quickly becomes a media sensation. Genuinely repentant yet boiling with lust and rage, Oswald gets caught up in a terrifying worldwide crisis.