Lost Season 6 - RE: LA X

And it's not only lazy, it's irresponsible. They ought to be kicked out of the writer's guild.

Or retitle the series for the DVD release to "Cub Scout Campfire Tales."

Natural successor to Twin Peaks?

I think the themes of faith, fate, and agency were all there from the beginning. xposts

I assumed it wasn't so much that Smokey would run rampant on the mainland a la the T Rex in Lost World, more that the only way he could leave was if the light would go out and as such the whole world would be in peril. I think the fact that they never explained what would happen to the world is a good thing, as it leaves the ambiguity that, actually, maybe nothing would have happened aside from destroying the island.

fwiw just cause the finale sucked doesnt mean i hate the show now or anything

Twin Peaks had heaping helpings of style, though. This show just has lots of "GET OUT OF THERE NOW!" and running and crying. I am hating this show this morning.

it seemed that Smokey genuinely wanted to 'go home' and didn't really have a reason to want to destroy the world or whatever. his desire to see beyond the island was compelling. otoh Jacob was, rightly, worried that a guy who can turn into smoke could cause all kinds of problems away from the island. i don't think Widmore or anyone else would've needed much convincing about helping Jacob just on this basis...as fun as it is to imagine Smokey off island. I like all this, it's a pretty good dilemma - "sorry I created you accidentally and now you can't leave because you're too dangerous a thing to be released from the island".

Twin Peaks was great until they (admittedly, were forced) to solve the murder they never intended to solve. It was pretty shit after that, save the bonkers ending, which was only really good by virtue of being, well, totally bonkers. The problem with these shows (and the creators of Twin Peaks knew this) was that the solution can never add up to the build up of a mystery, at least if you're building that mystery for a large number of episodes. I really think going for the character resolution over answering questions was the best way to do it. I don't think they totally succeded on the character front, mind, but it was a pretty decent stab, especially considering a lot of the characters were never that interesting in the first place.

also Twin Peaks didn't have a chance to wrap everything up

also Twin Peaks was awesome and LOST sucked

Twin Peaks was never going to wrap anything up. The central conceit of the show wrapped up early in the second season, and that's why it flailed around after that. About a third of Twin Peaks' run was awesome.

No, Christian clearly meant that they all created this world so they could find each other again in the afterlife, and moveon.org. The bomb had naught to to with it

yeah agree with this - as much as it may suck

I think if everyone had died and the island had been destroyed in one timeline and everyone happily coupled up in the alt I would have been okay with it. It was the afterlife/vague religious bullshit that killed it for me.

tho why Jack would be experiencing the neck cut in this post-death world, amongst other presumably deliberate red herrings, seems stoopid. unless it was an attempt to get him to realise he was dead and move quicker towards the resolution but of course he was the last person to see the flashes and accept what was happening.

It was kind of quasi-religious, but we've had characters who never aged and could presumably live forever for a long while, not to mention Kate's horse and all that shit turning up on the island. It was always magic to some degree, and even if the alt-reality/purgatory was a bit half-handedly thrown together, it still might work if you consider it a reward given to them by Hurley. The island had powers that meant that death wasn't necessarily the end anyway. Either way it was really just a means to an end to deal with the crux of the show, which was really just a bunch of broken people being thrust into a situation that forced them to confront (or not) who they are and what they don't like about themselves. If Todd Van Der Werff were to be believed, the purgatory ending was hinted at in the first season with Sawyer reading Watership Down. I don't totally buy it, but I like the fact that you can read it that way if you want.

The alt-endings on Kimmel reminded me of how amazing the Sopranos ending was, which is a bad move, but then again that was always a much better show than Lost (even with its narrative dead ends and occasionally dud character arcs).

can't watch Sopranos ending ever again as have banned that Journey song from the rest of my life.

victim of its own success

Gukbe, your apologia is tiresome. The writers were geniuses at manipulation, but couldn't plot their way out of a wet paper bag. And didn't.

I'll take sub-par Spielberg any day.

sorry kenan, forgot this was the internet.

apologism is how i deal

http://farm5.static.flickr.com/4053/4639218352_f827076cfc_o.jpg

If Daniel Faraday and Drive Shaft had started a rendition of Bright Eyes it would have redeemed the whole thing.

sorry kenan, forgot this was the internet.

heh. I remembered.

did Claire go "crazy" because she got fat?

What the fuck? Fat? I don't get it.

TV fat, i.e., larger than a size 1.

End of this show = the new
http://www.dtheatre.com/story_images/ai_0715002.gif

she did look fat

wat

Oh, fuck off.

Seriously.

everyone looks fat to cutty

Here's tons o' fun three weeks ago:

http://www4.pictures.zimbio.com/gi/American+Woman+Fashioning+National+Identity+HjNtwxwwWpFl.jpg

Emile de Ravin is about 8 million times sexier than the character she plays. That said I think Claire was two-dimensionalised worse than anyone in the last series, except possibly Sun.

she looks like an olson twin in that pic

Sun's derail from badass business woman to Husband Seeking Robot was tragic. All about the characters my ass.

I saw her more as a Daughter Abandoning Robot

this ending=AI, so that means in about 9 years it will be widely hailed as a masterpiece right?

Did that happen with AI?

most definitely

how many pointless hours of limbo sun and jin did i have to watch this season. sooooooo boring. they even make getting shot boring.

sun and jin were shit this season, claire could have been interesting but they bottled it, and sayid was all over the map as well.

A.I. sucked ass

Claire really should've been abandoned again when they went for the plane because

a) funny
b) awkwardness of her living on the island with Ben, Hurley and weird animal skiletun - also funny

Plus they would have saved fuel by grounding her fat ass.

Did we ever find out exactly what happened with Sayid's death and revival on the island? He was kind of a zombie for a while. What was that about? What was the 'sickness' that Dogen was concerned about?

the same sickness that Rousseau had to deal with amongst her shipmates, but yeah never really explained properly iirc.

never explained properly? how about not at all. what were those injections desmond was taking when he lived in the hatch?

who exactly were those people ben had sayid kill when they were off island

STOPASKINGQUESTIONSITISOVER

I was wrong in one of my posts upthread-- apparently there is some synth in Giacchino's Lost scores here and there, used sparingly. Mea culpa.

The more I think about this show, the worse it seems. I don't know if I've ever been angry at a TV show before!

xposts