The (Now-Overrated) ILX Top 100 Films of the 2000s Poll Results

(Is anyone in any suspense whatsoever about the top three, at this point?)

(I think this is what Harrelson's lone monologue is all about, right? that Chigurh has "principles")

― Wrinkles, I'll see you on the other side (Shakey Mo Collier), Thursday, February 11, 2010 3:28 PM (42 seconds ago) Bookmark

yes, which is why he tells brolin that chigurh is gonna kill his wife regardless

I thought it was Totoro.

kelly macdonald is so great in that

it's basically an almost completely astonishing genre thriller

prolly would've been a bit more thrilling for me if chigurh wasn't portrayed as a mythical evil superhuman

I mean, character and performance were ace but it made things kind of boring for me

also you guys are basically saying this was terminator gone western noir

"(Is anyone in any suspense whatsoever about the top three, at this point?)"

Only if they haven't been paying attention.

cf scene where Chigurh goes back to the bank that hired him and kills his "employer" (lolz Mr. Swingline from Office Space) - and then he turns to the low-level flunky. Low-level flunky asks if he's going to kill him and Chigurh says "that depends. Do you see me?"

x-posts

he gives brolin a chance to sacrifice himself and save his wife during that phone call and brolin just keeps on running.

film version of this in the works, right? agreed though. 90% of the power of the book is in the apocalyptic, Old Testament prose. plus shit would need to be NC-17++.

yeah. this is a terrible idea. looking forward to the scene where the Judge smashes a newborn baby's head against a rock btw

i dunno, so many great films are based around the notion of someone attempting to escape an exceptionally tenacious pursuer (horror, sci fi, cop films, and so on) that i'm not sure chigurh's superhuman skill is a negative. it's totally thrilling how inventive and batshit he is.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v212/etienne_saint/eternalsunshine.jpg

This goes much further than Adaptation or even Malkovich, in that it's sustained, and Kaufman even makes the ending stick. He's still as much of a smart-ass as Pope, but now he's also channelling Abelard directly, which makes all the difference. Gondry gets close enough to the right tone - after the insanely pretty opening, it has to keep moving. The cast help of course - thankfully Winslet has something to work with for the first time since, what, Hamlet?; I'd almost forgotten that she's the greatest actress of her generation (so far). But it's Kaufman's movie.

It's great. Probably not La Jetee great. Definitely Blade Runner great.

― B*R*A*D

Yeah, I loved it. One of the very few movies where I've geeked about the head-trippiness (narrative experimentation, sci-fi logic) and was simultaneously close to tears several times.

― jaymc

I saw 'Adaptation' and absolutely adored it, moreso than 'John Malcovich', it left me actually inspired, which felt like a really big thing for me. Usually when i go to see a film in the big theaters i go because it's with friends and i don't really care about it. Most big movies these days feel like they are going through pre-scripted motions, according to a system that i don't find interesting in any way. Obviously there is a head-trip feel to all his movies and a dada/surreal/hipster approach so i almost feel like it's a guilty pleasure, but then again i think he's getting better and better at them and by the time i saw 'Sunshine' i was completely taken over by it.

It didn't help that i was in tears for almost the entire second half. I figured maybe Kaufman knows his demographic too well (the sweater, the Eskimo boots, the Tom Waits and Beck) but most of the similarities between this movie and my life circa a month ago were scarily similar. If you go to this movie with a heavy heart, it's going to shatter you!

― Adam Bruneau

i fucking LOVED this movie btw - emotional wallop, smart enough, good acting, PANTIES, even mopey beck sounded good!

― James Blount

it's metafiction transplanted to film; it's an okay movie, but the device is so far from original it's kind of stale. See every single John Barth novel ever written.

― anthony kyle monday

very clever, sweet, scary and funny in places. didn't actually like the two main characters that much (not that relevant in a way). thought Tom Wilkinson was great, Dunst fine, Elijah OK tho he had little to do.

pretentious? mais naturellement!

would be surprised at anyone who loved BJM (i did) and Adaptation (still not seen) but hated this. other haters, not sure what you wanted (you so rarely explain...).

― stevem

wow. i don't think i've ever cried so much at a film (and i went there completely happy (and i'm happy now) - i don't think it'd be a good film to see if you'd had a recent breakup, as people have said upthread).

but yeah, it's a masterpiece. i think i need a little time away from it before i comment any further, though.

― toby

Absolutely loved this film to the fucking maximum. Totally changed my perspective on Gondry and confirms CK for me as one of *the* great screenwriters (a small band). Can't praise it too highly.

― Enrique

eternal sunshine of the spotless mind

#3

Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
Michel Gondry
2004
United States
(1348 points, 47 votes, 6 first place)

i like the way the film handles chigurhs racial... vagueness. i think hes supposed to be from the balkans? but hes played by a spanish actor in a movie set in the southwest? with a totally indeterminate accent

I thought it was Mononoke that did this? I remember it being the first Miyazaki movie even my non-anime-loving friends were talking about. But if SA was the real breakthrough, that's great, because it's clearly better than Mononoke.

Maybe Mononoke helped but I hadn't heard anything about ghibli til Spirited Away was released, that's when all the dvds started showing up in the shops. I think both are great and interesting for different reasons and leave it at that.

if this were Lost, we'd be all "why'd brolin go back to give that dude water? so stupid! now he deserves to die! Smokey, finish him!"

also you guys are basically saying this was terminator gone western noir

remove the messiah story and replace it with greed and yes, I agree, and it was fucking aweseome

he gives brolin a chance to sacrifice himself and save his wife during that phone call and brolin just keeps on running.

And in sticking with his principles, does exactly what he promises to do. And makes it clear to the wife that it's Brolin's fault!

Also yay to "Eternal Sunshine", kind of glad I've seen and liked all of these movies since #6

ok guys, i'm off for lunch....please try to not debate the final two and what they are or who will finish where, but i will say that coming down to the end of the ballots rolling in it was a pretty close race....leads were switched....

watch this space. continue to trash talk the other films.

lol yeah loved that, pancakes

'eternal shitshine of the shitless shit' is going to stay w/ me.

ISotSM had a good beginning and ending, but the middle section where they go through the fantasyland was waayy too long. I wanted to see more of Kate Winslet's character in real life, not just Jim Carrey's dream version of her.

Wow. So Children of Men may actually go #1.

looks like it's "dude wheres my car" vs "vicky cristina barcelona"

glad it's not #1

esosm: booming movie A+

please get your comedy jpgs ready for the #1, i expect to see some vv good ones.

No Country & There Will Be Blood - gag

IB is the worst Tarantino of the decade, but still pretty good. I would have voted for Death Proof if it had a spot separate from Grindhouse (Planet Terror suuuuuucked)

see you folks in about an hour and some change.

i think we should prepare prediction jpgs, like can we predict both the film and the scene omar will use

so many great films are based around the notion of someone attempting to escape an exceptionally tenacious pursuer (horror, sci fi, cop films, and so on)

I think a lot of good, entertaining films are based around this, not necessarily great ones.

no country for old men arbitrarily mixed heavy-hitting 70s style gritty realism and comic book noir at the same time and the tension didn't sit completely right with me.

that said, it was on my ballot - there's a lot to like there - but its high ranking by so many is kind of baffling.

knew this would make it, very gratifying. more Ruff love from me for this film

Wow. So Children of Men may actually go #1.

lol

no prediction or speculative jpgs, just comedy ones!

#1 The Blind Side

http://www.aceshowbiz.com/images/news/00026165.jpg

would have voted for Death Proof if it had a spot separate from Grindhouse (Planet Terror suuuuuucked)

glad someone agrees with me on this, I was def in the minority on the Grindhouse thread iirc

oh yeah - this is #2

http://www.terrortube.com/images/articles/killerpad2.jpg

I wanted to see more of Kate Winslet's character in real life, not just Jim Carrey's dream version of her.

b-b-but she was equally real, and frankly less of a horrorshow.

re: Blood Meridian

The Hollywood Reporter has confirmed that Ashton Kutcher is in talks to play the sinister Judge Holden in "Blood Meridian", director Todd Field's adaptation of the widely hailed novel written by Cormac McCarthy, author of "The Road" and "No Country For Old Men". Kutcher's agent was quoted as saying that Kutcher is "super-duper pumped for the role. This is going to do for Ashton what The Dark Knight did for Heath Ledger!"

super-duper pumped, guys.

super-duper

I still haven't seen "Planet Terror" but I love "Death Proof" to bits(the show the latter on cable a lot).

So is this basically Lost in Translation vs. Mulholland Drive for #1?

'eternal shitshine of the shitless shit' is going to stay w/ me.
--ogmor

It's Kid A.

This is going to do for Ashton what The Dark Knight did for Heath Ledger!

Give him fame-related anxiety attacks that lead to a fatal overdose?

I liked ESotSM a lot but the most amazing thing about it was kate winslet's american accent

yeah pretty much, LiT has so many votes that it's gonna place twice

Ashton Kutcher as Heath in Heath Ledger!

So is this basically Lost in Translation vs. Mulholland Drive for #1?

get a late pass son

so this is basically There Will Be Blood vs Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind for #1?

Is someone gonna come up with a "cuet" acronym for the inevitable top 5?