The (Now-Overrated) ILX Top 100 Films of the 2000s Poll Results

MD is a worthy #1, but is anyone else hoping it isn't?

deric w. haircare

i don't want mulholland dr (is there a morbsy alt title for it? i hope so. try to work in fact it is based on a tv pilot ep maybe) to even get in the top 100

people who hate dune are the most disgusting savages imo

hate is a strong word

sounds like the film actually followed ice cr?m out of the theater

Guys, hate to dismount the gangpile, but I kinda see where Tuomas is coming from w.r.t the movie's shameless sentimentality. Aren't the people who love it generally the most po-faced, unironic musical theater geeks you've ever met?

vetoing all proposals for a discussion on Lynch's Dune.

ok this is the part where I inexplicably stan for moulin rouge

guessing southland tales is not going to make it

moulin rouge not on my ballot but if I'd seen it again recently it might've made it

did vote for mull drive, too. think lynch is the only director to appear twice on my ballot. not something i could have predicted in the '90s.

― strongohulkingtonsghost, Wednesday, February 10, 2010 10:40 AM (3 minutes ago) Bookmark Suggest Ban Permalink

yah david got his grove back 4 sure

sounds like the film actually followed ice cr?m out of the theater

― 鬼の手 (Edward III), Wednesday, February 10, 2010 10:44 AM (1 minute ago) Bookmark Suggest Ban Permalink

it was, strange

MD is a worthy #1, but is anyone else hoping it isn't?

― Freddy 'The Wonder Chicken' (Gukbe)

still hoping it doesn't place tbh xp

― quiz show flat-track bully (darraghmac)

^^This a thousand times over.

xposts

don stop believin

Better MD #1 than ESOTSM #1

Truer words never typed.

If you're looking for a travesty, that'd be ESOTSM at #86 on the Sl*nt poll.

true, or slant???

Yeah. Too high.

never seen this degree of mulholland hate/inland empire love. is this a contrarian ilx universe or am i out of a wider loop here?

I think Once has a better shot at placing than Moulin Rouge. And I don't think Once has a shot in hell.

ilx is a contrarian ilx universe

that's not what's happening

the poll results are coming from inside the house

The people loving IE are not the same ones hating MD.

i voted for moulin rouge, totally loveable and sentimental film, i guess it has some cute po-mo storytelling tricks but don't think the overall effect is insincere or ironic, tuomas otm

i liked moulin rouge and would probably watch it again b4 i watched 75% of this list

the whole point of moulin rouge is taking this super-ironic all-surface glitzfest and using it to actually get at some real emotions

it's the campiest movie ever

and it was funny! the big production they're working on is called "spectacular spectacular", c'mon that's funny

I bet you people hate glee too

i hate musicals with all i can muster

HATE them.

Yeah, I just don't like Lynch. Watched MD because it was so universally praised and wanted to punch everyone who recommended it to me. Didn't bother with IE.

And I voted for Moulin Rouge.

glee is televisual. for all its pyrotechnics & cgi and sound design, moulin rouge is more the spectacle of musical theater

than cinema

taking this super-ironic all-surface glitzfest and using it to actually get at some real emotions

I think you're confusing MR! with Obama's election night

everyone loves moulin rouge

The people loving IE are not the same ones hating MD.

― queen frostine (Eric H.)

Ah! lol

thx

moulin rouge is sincere, but the thing it's sincere about is dumb, so its sincerity isn't really a virtue. btw i am a musical geek and i hate that movie so much.

no you don't - everyone loves it

I bet you people hate glee too

yeah , but for different reasons (glee's musical numbers are shit, for a start).

a slightly earlier start today for a few of these...

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v212/etienne_saint/Superbad3.jpg

I have to admit the heavy use of 1970s soul (mainly the psychedelic soul tracks) were a bit out of place throughout the film. Was it Judd Apatow wanking and needing to insert more memories from his own high school experiences into a film? Future audiences will be confused as to what era the film was trying to be from and why they intentionally tried to have that soundtrack.

Funny film, but how long can this creative team milk the adolescent experience (either through stories about actual kids or just "grown men" who refuse to grow up)? I've only seen, at most, one other film from Apatow, etc. but the bathetic way characters and plots get wrapped up is already stale to me.

― Cunga

I was a little underwhelmed too. I laughed a lot, but it wasn't really as complete a movie as 40-Year-Old Virgin or Knocked Up. Most of the laughs weren't really the result of the script or the jokes but were because of the reactions and the high standard of comedic acting - Michael Cera still kicks ass. I thought Seth Rogan and Bill Heder stole the movie as the incompetent cops.

-- n/a

I just saw this in a theater packed full of students from a large state university. The Orson Wells reference got laughs from maybe three people. The line about going to a state school where the "chicks are twice as dumb and therefore twice as likely to fellate me" got massive guffaws. Hey, we are slutty!

I thought this was way better than Knocked Up, which was strangely the last movie I saw in a theater.

― joygoat

michael cera is probably one of the 5 best comic actors in the world and he's younger than me for goodness' sake. and he's so so so lovable! the other dude had believable charm; not every line worked, but the ones that mattered did.

the wish-fulfilment ending is no less than the protagonists deserved. those girls were both hot and realistic. nothing was TOO far-fetched. nothing was (particularly) overplayed. it wasn't 'the making of a legend' (see: Road Trip, American Pie etc), it was the exploration of friendship.

srsly, one of the great bildungsroman movies.

― Just got offed

Where is a serious ILXor who aims to anticipate Superbad?

#25

Superbad
Greg Mottola
2007
United States
(483.5 points, 24 votes)

*rolls eyes*

*shakes head*

*sighs loudly*

shit I need to go to sleep :|

Loved Superbad.

i hate musicals with all i can muster

― strongohulkingtonsghost, Wednesday, February 10, 2010 9:54 AM (4 minutes ago) Bookmark Suggest Ban Permalink

HATE them.

― strongohulkingtonsghost, Wednesday, February 10, 2010 9:55 AM (3 minutes ago) Bookmark

i've tried to be cool w/ musicals cos of the line that they are a deeply bizarre urban american mongrel conflicted artform etc, but, i'm basically right there with you. i can take bob fosse kind of but that's about it.

wasn't v funny imo. also doesn't hold a candle to adventureland.

superbad is really bad. calculated quirkyness almost as offensive as juno's, and otherwise a standard fare american pie copy

superbad is not great but something about the way rogen says "are you familiar with yoda?" kills me every time

thought it was like american pie except not funny and I hated the characters and was basically rooting against them getting laid. maybe I should watch it again.

need to rewtch that. was kind of underwhelmed at the time compared to knocked up, which is i suppose more dramatic, but i remember more lols from it.

Superbad is the total opposite of Juno imo. The penis drawing scenes are amazing surreal insanity.