"Classic Rock Presents Prog" readers' all time best prog albums

Not really, ask most long-term Genesis fans which one they like best and it'll be Trick of the Tail or Wind and Wuthering.

Only those who like 80s Genesis. Hardcore Genesis fans prefer Peter Gabriel.

(And not one negative word about those two albums - they are great, but the Peter ones are mostly even better)

Only those who like 80s Genesis. Hardcore Genesis fans prefer Peter Gabriel.

Trick Of The Tail is by far my fave Genesis album. I love that album to death. and i have no time at all for 80's genesis. well, i don't hate 80's genesis, i like some of abacab and duke a lot, but i don't listen to it.

and wind & wuthering is probably my 2nd favorite! hmm, maybe i'm a peter gabriel hater after all.

also: Trespass has to be one of my LEAST favorite prog albums. by any band. ugh.

Only those who like 80s Genesis. Hardcore Genesis fans prefer Peter Gabriel.

If I was ever going to get drunk with power and abuse mod privileges, I would probably delete all of your posts where you made claims about anyone's likes and dislikes other than your own. It would probably take a month.

You know, Yes "Relayer" sounding better and better as years go by. I'm surprised there's no dedicated thread...

I read this whole thread after searching for Gnidrolog. The most bizarre assertion herein is that Eloy is better than anybody, I've heard three of their records and they're laughable.

Have you heard the concept album where some stoner travels back to the Middle Ages in a time machine and teaches a princess how to smoke weed?

I skipped that one, I'm sure THAT's going to be the album to convince me they're awesome, ha ha.

Pawn Hearts getting 10x the votes as Dark Side of the Moon warms my heart on this cold spring day

I wonder if we reran this exact pill whether ILM would get it so gloriously correct a second time

Don't understand who would pick Moonmadness as the best of this batch. The Snow Goose is quite nice but the albums where they write lyrics and sing them are not.

Will Romano's book Mountains Come Out of the Sky lists Moonmadness as the 5th best/most important prog album, but I thought his love of Camel was a personal peculiarity, not a trend.

Camel a big favourite for White Van Man Prog along with Yes and ELP. Must be the stoner feel to it.

They're apparently a big influence on neo-prog bands, maybe it's the straightforwardness that they find easier to emulate than the more arcane or complex stuff.

Bingo