I admire this more than I like it

punk music

I like the idea behind it but I can't stand listening to actual punk bands

death metal

there is loads of music i admire more than like. 'great work', and i can tell the artist put a lot of thought and time into their creation but for me as a listener, i rarely have the stamina or compulsion to listen for extended periods of time.

Lots of shouts in here that I agree with pretty much. Scott Walker is definitely in here. Ornette Coleman. John Coltrane. Elvis Costello too. Beach Boys. Kraftwerk. Bob Dylan is in a similar category, something like "I do not get this at all but so many other people do so there must be something to it". There are lots of records I own out of a sense of duty or history - this is important, this is significant - but that I don't have a personal connection to. Looking at the list, it often seems like stuff from 'before' my time as an active listener that I've gone back to due to it being acclaimed, rather than stuff I've 'organically' (whatever the fuck that means) come into contact with.

Bowie was broadly in this category until he died, but has been moving much more into genuine like since then. Radiohead moved into this category from one labelled "I resent the success and acclaim this gets over other things I like more", and have now wheedled their way into my genuine affections; sometimes you need an event or binge or something else with an artist to change your mind/heart about them. PJ Harvey similarly crossed over a few years ago. SFA too.

I think with some artists I often forget how much I like them in between binges of listening to them; like, I might go a few years without really listening to whoever, and in that fallow period if asked I might say I admired them but didn't love them, but then I'll binge and they'll be my favourite thing.

for me its Mark Stewart (solo + mafia).
i love the on-u sound groove, and so, over the years i have picked up every MS album, but it's very rare i feel like listening to his stuff as opposed to other parts of the on-u archive.
i admire the mans stance, and he should be top of my list.
i even went to see him live with the mafia a few years ago and loved it,
but still, other than his dub release, exorcism of envy,i have yet to really love one of his albums.

Jute Gyte.

most jazz

most things nakhers recommends

― I remember you was vote-splitted (imago), Wednesday, January 27, 2016 4:01 PM (Yesterday)

just curious, what jazz artists (if any) do you listen to for enjoyment?

Think the thing with Beefheart is that people dive straight into Trout Mask Replica when they would be much better off with, say, Mirror Man Sessions.

just curious, what jazz artists (if any) do you listen to for enjoyment?

― small doug yule carnival club (unregistered), Thursday, January 28, 2016 1:23 PM (1 hour ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

practically nothing

pharaoh sanders i guess, also idk if soft machine's fusion period counts at all

i know i have a way to go here

Think the thing with Beefheart is that people dive straight into Trout Mask Replica when they would be much better off with, say, Mirror Man Sessions.

― Camaraderie at Arms Length

Safe As Milk was my gateway drug.

Pere Ubu

I've been pretty good about pruning most of these out of my collection, but I have accumulated a lot of Xenakis considering I've never had anything like a transcendant moment listening.

Neu: Unbelievably influential on artists (hell, entire genres) I like, but the albums never drew me in on their own merits.

Louis, if you want to get into jazz, I wouldn't recommend starting with Sanders, he can be of acquired taste... Try some of these, they're still in the avant-side that I think you prefer, but you might find them more palatable:

https://play.spotify.com/album/5xserqdbmc3DiD0PIgpcyj

https://play.spotify.com/album/0AFwXU8Y6geV2rxREgKp6a

https://play.spotify.com/album/14qDLRNo3R2MsddIfWXpcB

https://play.spotify.com/album/2XtydLjClSxUt6uMA9Zhpb

https://play.spotify.com/album/3yDpL3EYEJhTiIHz9NhcCy

shamefully I've never really got late-period Scott Walker, even Tilt leaves me cold

― conditional random jepsen (seandalai)

absolutely nothing shameful about this

This kind of dogshit thread has been posted on ILM about 50 times.

Alex in manhattan I thought you'd struggle with every piece of recorded music ever apart from MBV's last album.

i was looking for this kind of thread but couldn't find it, sorry.

actually i am not very convinced about many answers in this thread. as i said in the beginning i can hardly think of artists/albums belonging into this category. why the hell for example should i admire scott walker? i think he makes boring, unlistenable music and he cannot sing. what is there to admire about him?

bob dylan actually may belong into this category for me though i quite like him but don't listen to his music very often. his lyrics are outstanding, some of his tunes are quite magical, he is a genius. john coltrane actually may belong here though i like his music quite a lot but not "a love supreme". the intensity and freedom of his late stuff like "ascension" or "meditations" i really admire though i hardly ever listen to it. roland kirk belongs here, another genius obsessed by music. but when you listen to him playing three saxes somehow his virtuosity does not translate into music i love.

btw it is not manhattan, it is mainhattan, xyzzzz. also known as bankfurt or even frankfurt...

oh shit you're actually in germany then? *updates worst_posters.xls*

are we supposed to be finding artists that YOU admire more than YOU actually like, because otherwise your previous post is nonsensical

no. you should name artists YOU admire more than YOU like. but it would be nice if there was a reasoning behind. it is a serious question. what exactly is there to admire about scott walker?

he is handsome

polite to journalists

he's alive

top bloke

nice ballcaps

better than a hitler

does not fornicate with household pets

loves his pasolini

stood up for Obama against Giuliani

loyal green bay packers fan

Tilt is troubadoursmetal haha, of zoiets. meesterlijke plaat, ik heb meteen zin om hem op te zetten. maar dat kan natuurlijk niet grr
― rizzx (rizzx), Friday, January 20, 2006 10:18 AM (10 years ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

still very much involved with Lotus

good foil for Vin Diesel

i know i have a way to go here

― ZESTY O'PRIDE (imago), Thursday, January 28, 2016 6:44 AM (5 hours ago)

are you aspiring to a doctorate in musicology or something? It's okay to not like things.

troubadoursmetal haha

otoh based on your aesthetic preferences in other genres, you might go in for John Zorn stuff -- Naked City, Painkiller, his game pieces maybe, esp. Cricket.

wait imago isn't already a zornian zorny for zorn. color me shocked. must be some third level contrariness math going on.

or hipster fave Alice Coltrane

articulate ensemble of chicago

i don't remember ever having listened to john zorn. i must have though. naked city is on deezer. it sounds interesting. it has got enough complexity without being too tuneless.

that was a recommendation for imago tbh

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y2EsZpobWJs

xp i know i know. thanks anyway.

I find A Love Supreme totally accessible, but something like Carly Rae Jepsen ... don't like it, don't admire it ... it can exist as a cultural artifact without my approval and I feel totally good about it

A Love Supreme seems like a token name-drop album for people who've never really listened to any other John Coltrane albums.

I think I love everything about Scott Walker since the 80s apart from some of his tastes (no interest in the films he curated)

Crescent is a much better gateway album for Coltrane than ALS anyway.

For me, Giant Steps was a way easier way to get into than anything after. Really, if the only things Coltrane had done were his 1964-and-after records, I'd have added him to my list.

I kind of worked backwards with Coltrane. My gateway was "Live" At The Village Vanguard. Next was the just-released 2CD The Major Works of John Coltrane (with Ascension, Om, and several other pieces), which was what I was looking for -- I'd seen a concert by Milford Graves, Charles Gayle, Hugh Glover, and William Parker that changed me forever, and I was on the hunt for more of that music. Ballads and Coltrane Plays The Blues didn't cut it for me (though I grew to love those, and the rest of his work, years later), but Interstellar Space and Live In Japan were perfect.

the best way to get into Scott Walker is to watch 30th Century Man.

i feel like there are a lot of awkward things colliding in her rhythms on occasion and the sustained ecosystem of funkiness i am always after is not achieved but i also think she's interested in doing different things than that sonically, and she consistently achieves those things, and sometimes i really feel them, esp. on midtown 120 blues which is still a favorite. n.b. ballroom crashes don't do much for me either so ymmv. and tuomas, i would be surprised if you could pass a basic reading comprehension test, as i never said i found it difficult and neither did anyone else.

what do you think of her remix of the adultnapper track?

it's very hardcore homo deep house thug which is a good thing imo. like i picture just the baddest bitches in the world grooving to it on an underlit dancefloor. i'd probably lose it a little if i heard it in a club, i'm sure the bass would sound divine. but i'm not totally sure about the build-up of layers and how they match, it's a little too messy and busy for me somehow like it feels less than the sum of its parts. but some of those parts sure are fantastic...

too much going on in the hi-hat / snare range i think. it's not articulated in a way that hits me directly, which i mean could be a reason to admire it too. lots of mid-treble. there's something anemic and busy about it at the same time.

fair enough. how do you rate ALS in comparison to other Coltrane-led albums?

I mean... certainly in the top half, wouldn't you say? I can't say I've ever thought about which Coltrane albums are "the best" or "my favorite" but I go back to Love Supreme a lot and my opinion of it hasn't diminished at all.

a love supreme is a magnificent record and even if you've listened to every goddman coltrane recording you would be a fool not to rate it among his best work, the fuck do i care if jazz dabblers only pick up that one and no others

(sorry polyphonic that was not directed at you at all even though the posting sequence looks like, i don't meant to call you a fool!)

i'd probably lose it a little if i heard it in a club, i'm sure the bass would sound divine.

Fabric soundsystem:)

The question of aspiration and its relationship to taste is really interesting. There was a period in my late teens/early twenties where most of what I listened to was jazz and classical, but then I turned back to rock and pop music. I bought a number of complete opera sets that I haven't played in several years, and now I have practically no desire to listen to them at all (I started to have the perception that the culture that values that form is moribund, though you could read it more favorably as carrying on a tradition, or talk about vital if obscure new works).

I do think there's something fundamentally valuable about being a "good listener," but the real desire to engage with music that is radically difficult (especially in the improvisational vein) left me at some point in my twenties. By contrast, it seems there's a common trajectory is for people to start taking up, say, jazz around that time, maybe because they no longer identify with the fantasies (or realities) inscribed in pop music, and seek after something that engages them on a more overtly intellectual level. Despite having worked through a fair amount of Adorno at this point, though, I'm comfortable admitting that I still turn to music largely for affective reasons (though I also like to relate the feelings to a sense of history — my own and that of the music, the culture that produced it, etc.). This could still change, though!

I mean... certainly in the top half, wouldn't you say? I can't say I've ever thought about which Coltrane albums are "the best" or "my favorite" but I go back to Love Supreme a lot and my opinion of it hasn't diminished at all.

yeah, it's impossible to rank the music.. my mistake for implying that. it was my entry point, and it sort of put me off of his music until i got older, heard "India" and a live recording of "My Favorite Things", etc. i'm still a n00b. it's that most every conversation i've been a part of (on the topic of Coltrane jazz) invariably leads to somebody proclaiming it the end-all be-all of John Coltrane music, or all jazz music (as well as the conversation), which is disappointing.