Broken Social Scene...C/D?

really wanted to like it cause I love this guy's work in BSS, but kind of underwhelming. I think "Spirit If" is much stronger.

Listening to the self-titled BSS album now. 10 years later, and I still love this album. Perhaps it's nostalgia, but I think it holds up nicely.

CLASSIC, the s/t is the best one!

yep. really good. i might need to dig it out too although i remember it coming out in '06, not '05 for some reason.

i like the alternative version to Shoreline that came with a free EP on the back of the album.

u sure u don't mean "Major Label Debut (fast version)"?

I listened to this album a lot on headphones & eventually saw them live around this time (mighta been early 2007?) it sounds real good but kinda overlong/underwritten

... & I could understand haters calling it "overproduced" but they would be missing the point b/c the production is brilliant. "Ibi Dreams Of Pavement" is like 4 minutes of the roof being ripped off the house by hurricane winds & falling trees.

I will have to give this another chance because I was one of those overproduced haters. I liked Forgiveness Rock Record a lot, despite the ridiculous album title.

you might be right, bernard snowy. it's been ages since i last heard it.

It's getting better with age. I still prefer "You Forgot It In People" any day of the week, but "Ibi Dreams of Pavement" is incredible, maybe their best ever song.

xp "Major Label Debut" is the song about "just coming here to come down" that was v.laidback & chill on the album, but uptempo with horns on the EP

I take pleasure in the silliness of things like "Forgiveness Rock Record" or "Major Label Debut (Fast)" as titles

Fire-eyed Boy is my fave

I think their drummer has a lot to do with the greatness of the s/t

I put on almost crimes today and it was still pretty great

this new Brendan Canning album has the muddiest production

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6JtdYQtIhdY

New song!

happy they're back

I wonder if anyone who listens to the new one knows what it's about ?

"Our Faces Split the Coast in Half" is CLASSIC. never been able to figure out the lyrics to that one...

That song has lyrics?

i mean it could be gibberish vocalizing but idk always sounded like words buried in there

New single kind of underwhelming?

i hadn't thought of them in years but Hug of Thunder came on my Release Radar today and I rather enjoyed it.

I've come around to the single. It sounds nice and warm now like bss does

bought the record and have invested several listens but something just seems off. probably user error

This album is wayyyy better than I expected. I put off listening to it because I was never a big fan of these guys, "7/4 (Shoreline)" excepted, but this is really hitting the spot for me right now.

I'm a particular fan of "Halfway Home," which has the muscle and drive that "7/4" has and most of their other tracks do not, and "Towers and Masons."

I tried really hard to like this album but I ended up trying way too hard for it to be natural.

The album is great for biking. Good rhythmic drive, though not too tight to pedal along to, and a lot of climaxes. Have heard it a lot over the last couple of weeks.

I think Frederik has confused the new BSS album with his favourite porno.

LOL

Porno is bad for biking. Everyone knows that.

lol!

Spoken like a true specialist :D

yeah I'm a fan of the album, but people listening to music while biking are dangerous and scare me.

I keep thinking that this album is named Days of Thunder.

Not really a fan of this record. Too middle of the road. This band caught lightning in a bottle a long time ago.

What do we think of this new EP?

I like it.

I’m probably wrong but this single “can’t find my heart” sounds like maybe the most urgent and real thing they’ve done in years
https://open.spotify.com/track/6iRYhL6cwnuT2EnWsiDW15?si=P-zPnBW6Q4m3ACmWMuWj6Q

Twenty Broken Social Scene threads? Really?

Got a cheap used copy of their first album the other day. I love it...great driving music, reminds me of Yo La Tengo at their meandering-instrumental best.

I should prob give it a go, along with the last two, but #3 never hit me like #2.

yeah I don’t really like too much of their other stuff but the first album is beautiful. Clemenza, you might like their previous album as KC Accidental, it’s sort of in the same vein

Will definitely look for that, thanks. This, the first song from the debut, is a good test. If you love it as much as I do, you'll like the whole album; if it bores you, ditto.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7ZuikjeK6Do

Was just thinking about them the other day. Love the s/t.

I had one of those experiences where seeing them live made me like the records less. (Granted, I saw them live, for the first time, only a couple years ago. Maybe they were mind-blowing 20 years ago but the show I saw very much had the vibe of dads in search of their lost glory.)

Steve west air drum fill

I saw one of them open for Television in 2014, and in a low-key, non-disastrous way, it was one of the least effective professional shows I've ever seen.

“One of them?”
Had to be Kevin or Brendan right

I looked into KC Accidental and ended up ordering a used compilation from Amazon. The two original CDs are too expensive--one a little, the other ridiculous--and I couldn't find them on Soulseek.