the pure essence of an album

please, let five years win, i love the hell out of "Suffragette City" but it is by no means the essence of this creepy waiting-for-death weirdo from space record

there you go

1. "Five Years" – 4:43
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10. "Suffragette City" – 3:19
11.

YESTER/HENSKE FAREWELL ALDEBARAN

1 "Snowblind" - 3:07
2 "Horses on a Stick" - 2:10
3 "Lullaby" - 2:55
4 "St. Nicholas Hall" - 3:35
5 "Three Ravens" - 3:30
6 "Raider" - 5:12

8 "Rapture" - 4:09
9 "Charity" - 3:17
10 "Farewell Aldebaran" - 4:21

yeahhhhh! justice is served

i wholeheartedly love every song that's still left on this one except...

1.
2. The Ledge - Fleetwood Mac, Buckingham, Lindsey
3. Think About Me - Fleetwood Mac, McVie, Christine
4. Save Me a Place - Fleetwood Mac, Buckingham, Lindsey
5. Sara - Fleetwood Mac, Nicks, Stevie
6. What Makes You Think You're the One - Fleetwood Mac, Buckingham, Lindsey
7.
8. That's All for Everyone - Fleetwood Mac, Buckingham, Lindsey
9.
10. Sisters of the Moon - Fleetwood Mac, Nicks, Stevie
11. Angel - Fleetwood Mac, Nicks, Stevie
12.
13. Brown Eyes - Fleetwood Mac, McVie, Christine
14.
15.
16.
17. Beautiful Child - Fleetwood Mac, Nicks, Stevie
18. Walk a Thin Line - Fleetwood Mac, Buckingham, Lindsey
19.
20. Never Forget - Fleetwood Mac, McVie, Christine

(also, i just searched my itunes for the word "sisters" and that was my least favorite of the six songs that showed up.)

Storms & OAO nixed already? This is madness.

Surely the title track has to win on Farewell Aldebaran? Or do I need to listen to the album more because I'm an idiot?

can't believe somebody didn't cut this already:

1.
2. The Ledge - Fleetwood Mac, Buckingham, Lindsey
3. Think About Me - Fleetwood Mac, McVie, Christine
4. Save Me a Place - Fleetwood Mac, Buckingham, Lindsey
5. Sara - Fleetwood Mac, Nicks, Stevie
6. What Makes You Think You're the One - Fleetwood Mac, Buckingham, Lindsey
7.
8. That's All for Everyone - Fleetwood Mac, Buckingham, Lindsey
9.
10.
11. Angel - Fleetwood Mac, Nicks, Stevie
12.
13. Brown Eyes - Fleetwood Mac, McVie, Christine
14.
15.
16.
17. Beautiful Child - Fleetwood Mac, Nicks, Stevie
18. Walk a Thin Line - Fleetwood Mac, Buckingham, Lindsey
19.
20. Never Forget - Fleetwood Mac, McVie, Christine

can't believe somebody did cut the title song. speaking of madness.

How is "Beautiful Child" any kind of obvious cut? It's one of the best songs on the album!

seriously fuck you for cutting "beautiful child"

hahaha hey that's the breaks here, sorry! It never did much for me. Came in #8 on the album poll, which honestly surprises me.

Don't Say That You Love Me: The TUSK Poll.

Surely the title track has to win on Farewell Aldebaran? Or do I need to listen to the album more because I'm an idiot?

― emil.y, Thursday, August 8, 2013 4:26 PM (1 hour ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

youre not an idiot, but you need to listen to it more

1.
2. The Ledge - Fleetwood Mac, Buckingham, Lindsey
3. Think About Me - Fleetwood Mac, McVie, Christine
4. Save Me a Place - Fleetwood Mac, Buckingham, Lindsey
5. Sara - Fleetwood Mac, Nicks, Stevie
6. What Makes You Think You're the One - Fleetwood Mac, Buckingham, Lindsey
7.
8. That's All for Everyone - Fleetwood Mac, Buckingham, Lindsey
9.
10.
11. Angel - Fleetwood Mac, Nicks, Stevie
12.
13. Brown Eyes - Fleetwood Mac, McVie, Christine
14.
15.
16.
17. Beautiful Child - Fleetwood Mac, Nicks, Stevie
18. Walk a Thin Line - Fleetwood Mac, Buckingham, Lindsey
19.
20. Never Forget - Fleetwood Mac, McVie, Christine

swear to god youll thank me later

oops

1.
2. The Ledge - Fleetwood Mac, Buckingham, Lindsey
3. Think About Me - Fleetwood Mac, McVie, Christine
4. Save Me a Place - Fleetwood Mac, Buckingham, Lindsey
5. Sara - Fleetwood Mac, Nicks, Stevie
6. What Makes You Think You're the One - Fleetwood Mac, Buckingham, Lindsey
7.
8. That's All for Everyone - Fleetwood Mac, Buckingham, Lindsey
9.
10.
11. Angel - Fleetwood Mac, Nicks, Stevie
12.
13. Brown Eyes - Fleetwood Mac, McVie, Christine
14.
15.
16.
17.
18. Walk a Thin Line - Fleetwood Mac, Buckingham, Lindsey
19.
20. Never Forget - Fleetwood Mac, McVie, Christine

Tusk is my favourite album of all time but of the remaining tracks I'd definitely cut 'Save Me a Place' - 'Walk a Thin Line' does the same sort of thing better.

1.
2.
3. Think About Me - Fleetwood Mac, McVie, Christine
4. Save Me a Place - Fleetwood Mac, Buckingham, Lindsey
5. Sara - Fleetwood Mac, Nicks, Stevie
6. What Makes You Think You're the One - Fleetwood Mac, Buckingham, Lindsey
7.
8. That's All for Everyone - Fleetwood Mac, Buckingham, Lindsey
9.
10.
11. Angel - Fleetwood Mac, Nicks, Stevie
12.
13. Brown Eyes - Fleetwood Mac, McVie, Christine
14.
15.
16.
17.
18. Walk a Thin Line - Fleetwood Mac, Buckingham, Lindsey
19.
20. Never Forget - Fleetwood Mac, McVie, Christine

my first post was itt!

^cool Rev. i hope you're still proud of it!

xp in general: i really think there's a tension here between the title of the thread ("the pure essence of an album") and the suggested procedure. not so much the whittling away (necessarily painful, but i'm cool with that), but the fact that we're to whittle away what we think the "worst" remaining track is. or let me put it in more straightforward terms: i don't think the procedure of removing the songs we just don't like is a way for us to collectively arrive at the "essence" of an album. for example, on led zep iv, "stairway to heaven" is probably my least favorite track. but it would be one of the last tracks i would remove in trying to get at the essence of the album. similarly, i can totally get why someone might not dig "tusk" or "storms", but i like to think even these people would think the former to be one of the signature tracks of the album, and as for the latter, yeah, it's a little languid and doesn't "rock", but its naked, lo-fi, at times tune-less intimacy is exactly the kind of thing you'd find on this album and no other by this band.

(but yeah i'll admit my username strips me of any claims to objectivity)

i think i proposed this thread-type originally (though i cant find that thread)? and like DEFINITELY its some hyperbole but like i feel you, i like storms too!

the casualness with which people cut things is pretty great

I for one never followed the 'worst' line of thinking, or maybe took it as "the worst in terms of fitting the pure essence criteria." I actually think there are probably some very good albums whose 'essence' song might be among the worst tracks! Like, "Four Sticks" might actually be it for Zoso.

the casualness with which people cut things is pretty great

― puff puff post (uh oh I'm having a fantasy), Friday, August 9, 2013 5:04 AM (13 hours ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

I for one never followed the 'worst' line of thinking, or maybe took it as "the worst in terms of fitting the pure essence criteria." I actually think there are probably some very good albums whose 'essence' song might be among the worst tracks! Like, "Four Sticks" might actually be it for Zoso.

― Doctor Casino, Friday, August 9, 2013 5:06 AM (13 hours ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

OTMZ

Yeah, Doctor C, it was clear to me from your comment on Five Years that you were thinking about this in exactly the right way.

But instead of acknowledging you, I chose to pout, harrumph and take my ball home because some of the other boys were being mean to songs i like.

1.
2.
3. Think About Me - Fleetwood Mac, McVie, Christine
4. Save Me a Place - Fleetwood Mac, Buckingham, Lindsey
5. Sara - Fleetwood Mac, Nicks, Stevie
6. What Makes You Think You're the One - Fleetwood Mac, Buckingham, Lindsey
7.
8. That's All for Everyone - Fleetwood Mac, Buckingham, Lindsey
9.
10.
11. Angel - Fleetwood Mac, Nicks, Stevie
12.
13. Brown Eyes - Fleetwood Mac, McVie, Christine
14.
15.
16.
17.
18. Walk a Thin Line - Fleetwood Mac, Buckingham, Lindsey
19.
20. Never Forget - Fleetwood Mac, McVie, Christine

I keed, I keed

1.
2.
3. Think About Me - Fleetwood Mac, McVie, Christine
4. Save Me a Place - Fleetwood Mac, Buckingham, Lindsey
5. Sara - Fleetwood Mac, Nicks, Stevie
6. What Makes You Think You're the One - Fleetwood Mac, Buckingham, Lindsey
7.
8. That's All for Everyone - Fleetwood Mac, Buckingham, Lindsey
9.
10.
11. Angel - Fleetwood Mac, Nicks, Stevie
12.
13. Brown Eyes - Fleetwood Mac, McVie, Christine
14.
15.
16.
17.
18. Walk a Thin Line - Fleetwood Mac, Buckingham, Lindsey
19.
20. Never Forget - Fleetwood Mac, McVie, Christine

― No longer active (Moka), Fri

David Sylvian - Secrets of the Beehive

1. September
2. The Boy With The Gun
3.
4. Orpheus
5.
6.
7.
8. Let The Happiness In
9. Waterfront
10.

actually, missed one. should look like this now:

1.
2.
3.
4. Orpheus
5.
6.
7.
8. Let The Happiness In
9. Waterfront
10.

1.
2.
3.
4. Orpheus
5.
6.
7.
8. Let The Happiness In
9. Waterfront
10.

(Hint to next person: Let the Happiness In)