Not all messages are displayed:
show all messages (384 of them)
beware, loads of stet otm forthcoming
People are really good at conversations, the job of the software is to get out of the way and let them happen. But programmers seem to be unable to not see the messy randomness of human conversations as problems and starting thinking of shit like "can't we rate people? Or thread the display of posts neatly by their subject matter and their place in the conversational hierarchy, just as I do with all my personal correspondence?"
otm. ime ui developers in particular can get excitable and plug in a load of stunning effects that look utterly gorgeous in an international car show kind of way, but (a) were not requested by the customer, (b) were not requested by the designer and (c) are really really shitty for the average user to work with. i've spent entire weeks of my life breaking the hearts of good ui developers who couldn't bear to let go of their usability-destroying eye candy that nobody asked for.
I think there are two things about ILX's design, and they're interlinked: one is how it appears on the web, and the other is how it functions as a way of organising and storing discussions. The former I think is pretty good, but there's work could be done there
responsive design is ~the in thing~ this year, but ilx has been doing it properly since last century. it always looks consistent and behaves predictably on any device (mobile device interface notwithstanding, but that's a different subject).
the whole model of questions, answers, flatness, etc -- is something different, and I think that is one thing ILX has definitely got right. It gets out the way and lets people manage the conversations themselves.
biggest otm right here. getting out the way is an art from that too few sites seem to manage in their desperate attempt to be unique, or appealing, or mega-usable, or etc etc. as an example, medium.com seems to be heading back to genuine simplicity, but even then it's all six billion point garamond and fading-in text and other crap that pushes all the wrong envelopes. they can't help themselves.
marco arment (as much as he drives me up the wall in a gruber kind of way) is a big flag waver of keeping interfaces clean and simple, and eliminating anything that might work as expected 95% of the time (e.g. gestures). ilx has always done that. there is no easier message board to read—no avatars, no auto-refresh, no pop-up menus that leap into focus if you accidentally move your mouse over them, no fashion-week ajax shit.
i also love that ilx is not like every other bloody discussion-based site in the universe (phpbb, facebook, twitter, whatever) because it greatly reduces the chance of my family wandering in here and getting all up in my shit.
― Esteban Buttiérrez (Autumn Almanac), Friday, 29 March 2013 00:16 (eleven years ago) link
three years pass...