Animated Creatures: ILX's top 100 animated films (results thread)

In that interview posted upthread it sounded like John K's a huge admirer of Chuck Jones.

a true and correct poll.

(I.E. in a just world, GI Joe would have as well, oops, spoilers.)

aaaah I love GI Joe the movie

Loool, Leee.

heh, i just did a google search and found about a zillion blog posts where john k gushes about his favorite chuck jones cartoons. so i guess i stand corrected.

surprised Beauty and the Beast isn't going to place

#2 received the highest number of votes.

(This is your chance to post joke results!)

Hahaha imagine if it was Wall-E at #2, that'd be a pretty wild ride, huh?

If I were the type to post joke results I would've put "9" because that movie is awful.

Well imagine no more.

#2: Wall-E
dir. Andrew Stanton
2008, USA
556 points, 15 votes
http://i.imgur.com/UmcOu.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/xDo2W.gif
http://i.imgur.com/fPQcG.gif
trailer

A probable contender for #1

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C2zJGl5czk8

Jesus. Did it get many #1s?

I'll refer that question to silby.

I like Wall-E, so yay Wall-E.

Fern Gully #1

#1 Howl's Moving Castle

Hahaha.

#1: Spirited Away
dir. Hayao Miyazaki
2001, Japan
593 points, 14 votes
http://i.imgur.com/sUwFC.jpg
CHIHIIIIIIRRRROOOOOO (trailer)

I like Wall-E too, but 100 points over Duck Amuck is cray-cray.

yeah I will recover the #1 vote data this weekend or in like August or something

Spirited Away otm though, imo

I did not vote in this but I will submit a posthumous ballot to the ballot thread (which is where all the real shit goes down anyway ;D)

Thanks to silby for kicking this thing off! And everyone in this thread!

Far and away my favorite Miyazaki. Stellar art, hilarious characters, perfect fairy-tale logic, wonderful active hero, best Miyazaki soundtrack.

and thanks to Leee for bringing it home! If I ever run another poll I will appoint a rollout czar in advance because this is obviously the part I'm no good at.

if anyone (silby? Leee?) has a copy of my ballot... i'd love to post it. i lost my copy tho.

I can recover your ballot yes.

but not right now.

A worthy winner!

Pretty great top 4, really.

Bravos to silby and Leee!

I loved Spirited Away the first time and was oddly bored/distracted the second. Maybe should have given it more time in between. I bet I'd be very happy watching it now.

xpost I mean, given that we probably weren't going to see any high placements for, say, Tango

Worth it in the end, well done folks. Must get around to watching 'Howl's Moving Castle' I suppose.

Yes, well done silby & Leee!

Excellent thread, y'all.

and thanks to Leee for bringing it home! If I ever run another poll I will appoint a rollout czar in advance because this is obviously the part I'm no good at.

http://www.blacktoptens.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/06/tag-team.jpg

de-lurking just to say that this might be my favourite ilx poll yet & I can't wait to read all yr ballots! Personally would have liked to see more fleischer, some ub iwerks, svankmajer shorts like dimensions of dialogue, maybe a token norman mclaren... Also this, which is amazing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TkQ6X7g25H0

Yay at Bill Plympton, double yay at Aladdin not placing. That film is hella overrated imo

It's been fun, thank you!

I didn't vote because I had too much angst looking at the nominations thread, where I initially had some crazy idea that I should watch at least all the shorts before voting time, and then ran out of time without, uh, watching any of them. But I'm interested to see other people's ballots.

Up making it into the top 30, let alone the top 10, is baffling.

Thanks to silby and Leee for the poll! Could we have a top 100 recap?

1. Spirited Away
2. Wall-E
3. What's Opera, Doc?
4. Duck Amuck
5. Up
6. The Triplets of Belleville
7. Akira
8. The Iron Giant
9. My Neighbour Totoro
10. The Incredibles
11. The Wrong Trousers
12. South Park
13. Paprika
14. Toy Story 2
15. One Froggy Evening
16. The Nightmare Before Christmas
17. Toy Story
18. Fantasia
19. Who Framed Roger Rabbit?
20. Coraline
21. Duck Dodgers in the 24½th Century
22. A Charlie Brown Christmas
23. Fantastic Planet
24. Persepolis
25. Yellow Submarine
26. Perfect Blue
27. Robin Hood Daffy
28. Kiki's Delivery Service
29. The Secret of NIMH
30. Alice
31. Fantastic Mr. Fox
32. Creature Comforts
33. Snow White & the Seven Dwarfs
34. Finding Nemo
35. Ratatouille
36. Toy Story 3
37. Watership Down
38. Ghost in the Shell
39. Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind
40. Porky in Wackyland
41. Monsters, Inc.
42. Waking Life
43. A Scanner Darkly
44. Dumbo
45. The Wizard of Speed and Time
46. Your Face
47. Grand Day Out
48. Charlotte's Web
49. Waltz With Bashir
50. Batman: Mask of the Phantasm
51. It's the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown
52. A Close Shave
53. The Rabbit of Seville
54. Beavis and Butthead Do America
55. The Lion King
56. Grave of the Fireflies
57. Millennium Actress
58. Alice in Wonderland
59. Der Fuehrer's Face
60. Transformers: The Movie
61. Pinocchio
62. Lilo & Stitch
63. Beep, Beep!
64. Sledgehammer
65. Porco Rosso
66. Rabbit Fire
67. Princess Mononoke
68. Ninja Scroll
69. How the Grinch Stole Christmas
70. The Emperor's New Groove
71. Laputa: Castle in the Sky
72. I Love to Singa
73. Fievel: An American Tail
74. Bambi Meets Godzilla
75. The Brave Little Toaster
76. Red Hot Riding Hood
77. Feed the Kitty
78. Rejected
79. The Little Mermaid
80. The Secret of Kells
81. Jumping
82. Storytime
83. Wallace & Gromit: The Curse of the Were-Rabbit
84. Gertie the Dinosaur
85 (TIE). Rango
85 (TIE). Birds Anonymous
85 (TIE). The Jungle Book
88. Animal Farm
89. Allegro Non Troppo
90. The Illusionist
91. Kung Fu Panda
92 (TIE). Bimbo's Initiation
92 (TIE). The Plague Dogs
92 (TIE). Royal Space Force: The Wings of Honneamise
95 (TIE). Bad Luck Blackie
95 (TIE). 8 Ball Bunny
97. Lupin III: The Castle of Cagliostro
98 (TIE). Gandahar
98 (TIE). When the Wind Blows
100. Little Red Riding Rabbit

I strongly advise all Americans to watch Watership Down and When the Wind Blows. Still gutted they came so low. Also: more art shorts.

Warning: When The Wind Blows will ruin your life.

Up making it into the top 30, let alone the top 10, is baffling.

it just sort of floated in there

Considered going overboard with gifs for Spirited Away, but the screen cap I ended up using, which comes from the most potent scene for me, encapsulates the quiet affect that makes the film so strong.

Up has strong characterisation, powerful themes, amazing visuals, a decent twist, and talking dogs / dogs in fighter planes - let alone the merciless first five minutes. Up is the Pixar film that doesn't have to explain its place in the top ten.

Warning: When The Wind Blows will ruin your life.

― Public Brooding Closet (cryptosicko), Saturday, 19 January 2013 01:27 (41 minutes ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

up has the most moving first third of a move I've ever seen and then the most tedious longueur of a movie I've ever seen until the finish

Don't understand how anyone could find a single second of Up in the least bit tedious. Frontin'.