Year-End Critics' Polls 2012

not really sure how that's ironic

Terrorizer has never been at all gatekeeper-y wrt things having to 'sound metal' to qualify for inclusion

i think Torche and Baroness are at least "remotely metal"

yeah fnb's comment is p hilar actually

Ironic to see Christian Mistress and the quintessentially metal Dawnbringer not make the list, but instead Gunplay, Little Big Town, Robert Glasper, Juju & Jordash, BJ the Chicago Kid, Big Baby Ghandi and Foxygen. All good albums, none remotely metal.

i think Big Baby Ghandi and Robert Glasper are at least "remotely metal"

lol

Disco Naivete's album list (granted, DN makes no secret about operating within a very narrow scope)

01 Fiona Apple - The Idler Wheel
02 Lana Del Rey - Born To Die
03 Frank Ocean - channel ORANGE
04 Kendrick Lamar - good kid, m.A.A.d. city
05 Cold Specks - I Predict A Graceful Expulsion
06 Bat For Lashes - The Haunted Man
07 Cat Power - Sun
08 Jessie Ware - Devotion
09 The xx - Coexist
10 Grizzly Bear - Shields
11 Clock Opera - Ways To Forget
12 First Aid Kit - The Lion’s Roar
13 How to Dress Well - Total Loss
14 Beach House - Bloom
15 iamamiwhoami - kin
16 Niki & the Dove - Instinct
17 Chairlift - Something
18 Grimes - Visions
19 Chromatics - Kill For Love
20 Alt-J - An Awesome Wave
21 Marina & the Diamonds - Electra Heart
22 El Perro Del Mar - Pale Fire
23 Porcelain Raft - Strange Weekend
24 Bobby Womack - The Bravest Man In The Universe
25 Dirty Projectors - Swing Lo Magellan
26 Holy Other - Held
27 Perfume Genius - Put Your Back N 2 It
28 Lower Dens - Nootropics
29 Kindness - World, You Need A Change Of Mind
30 Taken By Trees - Other Worlds

Is that narrow scope "Stereogum"

Terrorizer's slogan is "The World's Number 1 Extreme Metal Magazine." So when they drop the ball on awesome bands like Dawnbringer, one might assume they do so because they're not extreme metal. That's fine, but then nearly a quarter of their list isn't even metal. OMG I'm SO hilar! So okay, maybe they're looking to shift to Decibel territory to extreme music, which works with bands like Swans. I suppose you could say Alcest are extremely beautiful, as are Wild Nothing and Beach House.

Or, like many people, they could think Dawnbringer are a bit shit.

the Alcest record has blastbeats on it, come on now

it's so false it was probably endorsed by Eddie Trunk of 'That Remotely Metal Show'

al are you not blurbing your tracks this year???????????

i blurbed them all in the genre lists!

oh right, word

can you post a list of your overall singles list for those of us that don't use spotify

i feel like i'd be bombing the thread if i c&p'd the whole 100 but it's here and there are also links to the genre lists within: http://narrowcast.blogspot.com/2012/12/my-top-100-singles-of-2012.html

oh word... good list w/ the exception of your blasphemous embracing of driicky graham

lol i was starting to get disappointed about not taking any shit for ranking driicky over chief keef

Revolver Magazine Albums of 2012

1 Deftones - Koi No Yokan
2 Meshuggah- Koloss
3 Soundgarden - King Animal
4 Baroness - Yellow & Green
5 Gojira - L'Enfant Sauvage
6 Pig Destroyer - Book Burner
7 High On Fire - De Vermis Mysteriis
8 Converge - All We Love We Leave Behind
9 Lamb Of God - Resolution
10 Stone Sour - House of Gold & Bones Part 1

Rock Sound Albums 2012

50. "Maybe Today, Maybe Tomorrow" - We Are The Ocean
49. "The Golden Age" - Your Demise
48. "Daybreaker" - Architects
47. "Astraea" - Rolo Tomassi
46. "Lost Songs" - ...And You Will Know Us By The Trail Of Dead
45. "Sonic Boom Six" - Sonic Boom Six
44. "Tycoon" - No Trigger
43. "Gnosis" - Monuments
42. "Weapons" - Lostprophets
41. "Funeral Beach" - Blood Command
40. "COLOURMEINKINDNESS" - Basement
39. "The Front Bottoms" - The Front Bottoms
38. "The 2nd Law" - Muse
37. "Long Live The Struggle" - The King Blues
36. "Uno!" - Green Day
35. "Don't Panic" - All Time Low
34. "Port Of Morrow" - The Shins
33. "Collide With The Sky" - Pierce The Veil
32. "Whitechapel" - Whitechapel
31. "Slave To The Grave" - Emmure
30. "Priorities" - Don Broco
29. "The Parallax II: Future Sequence" - Between The Buried And Me
28. "The Union Of Crowns" - Bury Tomorrow
27. "Sentenced To Life" - Black Breath
26. "No Gods" - Sharks
25. "Dead Set On Living" - Cancer Bats
24. "Honor Found In Decay" - Neurosis
23. "Celebration Rock" - Japandroids
22. "L'Enfant Sauvage" - Gojira
21. "The Plot Against Common Sense" - Future Of The Left
20. "Changing Tune" - Lower Than Atlantic
19. "Ex Lives" - Every Time I Die
18. "Harmonicraft" - Torche
17. "Everything You Ever Loved" - Make Do And Mend
16. "Floral Green" - Title Fight
15. "A Flash Flood Of Colour" - Enter Shikari
14. "Bones" - Young Guns
13. "Atlas" - Parkway Drive
12. "This Is The Six" - While She Sleeps
11. "Yellow & Green" - Baroness
10. "Handwritten" - Gaslight Anthem
09. "Gallows" - Gallows
08. "Exister" - Hot Water Music
07. "Dead Silence" - Billy Talent
06. "At Heart" - Miss May I
05. "Koi No Yokan" - Deftones
04. "Failed States" - Propagandhi
03. "Get What You Give" - The Ghost Inside
02. "All We Love We Leave Behind" - Converge
01. "On The Impossible Past" - The Menzingers

LA Times list hasn't been posted yet, has it

http://graphics.latimes.com/storyboard-times-music-staff-best-2012-list/ (also individual writer ballots in link)

1. Frank Ocean, “Channel Orange” (Def Jam) (62)
2. Kendrick Lamar, “good kid, m.A.A.d. city” (Aftermath/Interscope) (43)
3. Fiona Apple, “The Idler Wheel….” (Epic) (17)
4. Dr. John, “Locked Down” (Nonesuch) (17)
5. Japandroids, “Celebration Rock” (Polyvinyl) (16)
6. Miguel, "Kaleidoscope Dream” (RCA) (15)
7. Cat Power, “Sun” (Matador) (14)
8. Andy Stott, “Luxury Problems” (Modern Love) (14)
9. Swans, “The Seer” (Young God) (13)
10. Alabama Shakes, “Boys & Girls” (ATO) (12)

I rather like driicky graham / don't hate me.

hate you, tim

it's totally one of the best radio rap productions of the year, and the rapping doesn't get in the way of it (possibly even helps, considering every time i've heard someone else rap on the beat it hasn't sounded as good) xpost

yeah, pretty much agree. still can't get over his name tho.

the song basically disappearing before he could even get to like Ca$h Out's level has probably fed some of my enthusiasm for it

If anyone cares about my albums list (with dumb blurbs!), here it is: http://on.fb.me/10yKMnt

http://my2ndheartbeat.files.wordpress.com/2011/11/icare.jpg

thx some dude, xo

There's always some dude that cares, Johnny. Just remember that.

No one gives a shit about mine so I didn't bother.

lol can i post it for you

Sure! Not enough Pinkish Black love on this thread.

my albums list, sans blurbs (although i'd like to write some for at least the top 10):

http://grannykart.com/2012/11/05/jodys-top-30-of-2012/

http://lightbulbhead.tumblr.com/post/38479597599/2012-favorites (xp)

i keep forgetting about that new neneh cherry album.

That Moon Duo record was one of my last cuts, but I dropped it once I realized “Sleepwalkers” sounds like Zooropa-era U2 taking lots of acid and trying to play Adam Ant’s “Vive Le Rock” from memory without having heard it since 1985.

you say that like it's a bad thing.

Not at all! But I docked them slightly because when I saw Adam Ant this fall his current version of "Vive Le Rock" sort of sounded the same way.

In other words, those last few cuts were some arbitrary bullshit.

Ok that Moon Duo description makes me wish you wrote blurbs

Am deeply saddened the Black Bananas album fell of your list, get bent

i'm saddened too. i like that record. i'm so close to restoring it to the list.

black bananas is back.

So okay, maybe they're looking to shift to Decibel territory to extreme music, which works with bands like Swans.

no this stuff has been within their remit since literally their first issue

Yay! xp

my albums list:

http://humanizingthevacuum.wordpress.com/2012/12/28/for-the-last-time/

i kind of want to have an extended discussion of cloud nothings vs. the men but i'm probably the only one

xpost

Does this mean you had a change of heart on the Mountain Goats record?

I don't think I outright disliked it -- it merely wasn't the keeper that last year's was.

Singles: http://humanizingthevacuum.wordpress.com/2012/12/20/best-songs-2012/